New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Story stick tips and tricks

Posts

Story stick tips and tricks

#1

Story stick tips and tricks

Tony

The idea is using story sticks for building furniture appeals to me. Since I'm building (at least) a matching pair of short book cases, this is a good opportunity to start.

My main question: what material do y'all use to make the sticks out of?

I also thought this might be a good opportunity if anybody has tips or tricks they've discovered along the way in making/using story sticks to share them.

Re: Story stick tips and tricks

#2

I rarely use them.  alternative philosophy

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I don't find this approach to building something useful to me. I don't ever expect to build a second or third of something years in the future. If I am building two of something at once a stick offers no advantage for I cut the duplicate parts at one time.

I do often "measure" from the developing project. For example, the length of drawer dividers will be scribed on the divider lumber off the actual case dimension. An intermediate transfer to a stick offers no benefit.


Occasionally, I make a full sized drawing of a project, like the display cabinet I am building. I will take measurements off the full scale drawing. Otherwise I use dimensioned scale drawings in a note book to record dimensions which I will transfer to lumber with a ruler.

Rarely does the gross size of furniture need to be accurate. Whether a chest of drawers is 50" high, or it turns out 50 1/2" is typically immaterial. I keep this principal in mind when building.

Re: Story stick tips and tricks

#3

Re: Story stick tips and tricks

Hank Knight

I use story sticks a lot and find them very helpful laying out repetitive measurements. For example, when I lay out placement for drawer dividers, i mark the first side and the story stick simultaneously and simply transfer the marks directly from the stick to the opposite side. They're sometimes useful to check your positioning during assembly. Easy, foolproof and very accurate. There are hundreds of other occasions where story sticks come in handy.

I make my sticks from whatever is handy, usually a thin (3/16"-5/16" thick X3/4" wide) rip offcut. I make my initial mark with a knife, then go back and darken it and label ut with pen or a pencil. Labeling is important because, once you put a few marks on the stick, it gets confusing. It's also important to note which end of the stick you're measuring from. I draw an arrow from the mark to the appropriate end of the stick.

I don't often make multiples of any project, so once I'm done with the project, I'm done with the stick. I don't try to reuse them; I just cut another one when I need it.

Re: Story stick tips and tricks

#4

drawer dividers question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Why do you make each side independently? I clamp them together and mark both at once.

BTW, a typical Period Furniture rank of drawers increases in size by the divider thickness, which leads to an easy way to make them out. Set divider #1(marking device) to the drawer divider thickness and a second #2 to the height of the first drawer. Then just walk the dividers down the case edge.

1, 2, 1, 1+2, 1, 2x1+2,1, 3x1+2, etc.

This technique saves a lot of summing of fractions to calculate the layout. You could walk the dividers down the story stick too.

Re: Story stick tips and tricks

#5

Great on the drawer dividers with dividers


Re: Story stick tips and tricks

#6

Re: Story stick tips and tricks

Mark Hennebury

Story sticks are the most important tool in your arsenal.

They are not for recording history to be read years later, although there is no reason that they cant be kept and used at some later date.

They are for precise layout of components and joinery of your current job.

As Hank stated, they are usually discarded at the end of the job.

There simply is no more accurate, fast and foolproof method of removing error and ensuring precision fit of all parts.

You would do well to learn how to use them.

I make always make extra stock of the same size as most frame components and use pieces for story sticks, test setups, spacers and measuring blocks.

Mark out with a knife, square and spacer blocks.

Clamp frame parts and story stick together and drop the knife in the line on the story stick and transfer across to the frame parts with the square. A knife goes into a knife-line with precise registration, no guesswork, no measuring, no calculation, no pencil-line thickness.

If you want to join multiple rails into stiles; you use a cut-off from the rail as your reference block and two story sticks; Once you have placed your knife in the line on the story stick and transferred it across you stiles, keeping you square in place, place a rail cutoff block against the square and scribe across, then mark-out the space to the next one ( this also can be generated with a story stick). this is now your master reference for rail and space. Now unclamp and remove your stiles

Now you have two story sticks with three knife-lines representing a rail and a space.

Use one to repeat the pattern on the other as many times as you need. Then you have a master reference with the original rail and space, and the second with all of the rails and spaces.

If you clamp your pieces, then put your knife in a line and slide your square up to it and transfer, you will have layout lines as accurate as is possible.

There are innumerable ways to use a story stick, once you become familiar with using one you wont need a ruler or tape measure for anything accept for gross measurements.

Re: Story stick tips and tricks

#7

Different strokes for different folks.


Re: Story stick tips and tricks

#8

some comments and questions

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I am open to convincing but I need convincing with some examples I can relate to. - making a frame or making a case. I discribed in the above post how I lay out a case. I have not seen how a story stick would improve my process.

"Story sticks are the most important tool in your arsenal." Well, they just aren't of any importance for me, yet. I can't imagine anyone more lazy than I am, yet I still don't see any advantage......presuming we are defining story stick the same. Yet, I think I use an equivalent techniques in cases and don't call it a story stick- gang marking and gang sawing.

"There simply is no more accurate, fast and foolproof method of removing error and ensuring precision fit of all parts." There are other means to this end that don't involve a stick that does not become part of the project. For example drawer dividers. I simply hold the divider-to-be up to the case and scribe its length, or a length to a shoulder, etc. The actual divider is my "story stick"

and it winds up in the project.





I am making 4 frames that will become the two doors and sides of a display case. All the stiles are the same length, which is about 45". I measure with a ruler about 45" down one of them and make a pencil mark. I set a stop on the table saw to cut near this mark. I stop cut the 8 stiles which will be about 45" long (+/- 1/32) and exactly the same length. I don't see any quicker or more precise way of getting 8 identical rails and identical is all that is required. (I recognize that if I was hand sawing then I would scribe the 8 while they were clamped in registration. Again, a ruler and no story stick). Ditto for the rails.

.

"I make always make extra stock of the same size as most frame components and use pieces for story sticks, test setups, spacers and measuring blocks." I use cut-offs for sets ups, test cuts and fits, etc. too, but not story sticks.

"Mark out with a knife, square and spacer blocks.

Clamp frame parts and story stick together and drop the knife in the line on the story stick and transfer across to the frame parts with the square. A knife goes into a knife-line with precise registration, no guesswork, no measuring, no calculation, no pencil-line thickness." Agree but where did the mark on the story stick come from? A ruler? I just transfer the measurement from my drawing, to the ruler, to the first of these parts, then proceed as you describe.

"If you want to join multiple rails into stiles; you use a cut-off from the rail as your reference block and two story sticks; " I didn' t understand this discussion. I am unclear on what is being made so I didn't understand how the steps related to the final result.

Re: Story stick tips and tricks

#9

Re: Story stick tips and tricks

don stephan

My understanding of story sticks for a furniture project is that all the layout lines would be made on the stick(s) and component pieces would then be marked from the stick(s). By looking at all the layout marks on the story stick(s) hopefully one would spot any measuring errors before cutting component pieces.

More than once I have noted a dimension on a drawing, then made a mistake measuring that dimension on a piece of wood (such as 9 3/8" instead of 9 5/8").

This discussion has made me want to experiment with story sticks.

Re: Story stick tips and tricks

#10

Re: some comments and questions

Mark Hennebury

Hi Bill,

If you imagined that you built a cabinet the vertically sliced through it so that you had a sectional view, all of that information is on a story stick, all of the rail sizes shapes positions mortise positions, rebate and goove sizes and position, panel positions and clearance gaps etc.. all of the precise measurements and positions of all of your pieces, that goes for slicing the cabinet side to side or front to back.

So the story stick is your complete full size drawing, but in high precision, done with a knife, so that it can be transfered, as close to absolute as you will get in woodworking, to as many parts as needed.

The story sticks are also used as you use your dividers. to layout and divide spaces, and as i tried to explain, to record the exact stock sizes by placing your stock cutoffs on the stick in the place and scribing against the stock and square.

In other words, you can build and entire cabinet without measuring anything, no rulers not tape measure. just marks on a stick.

You can also check cabinet openings, top, bottom and diagonals with two sticks. You can do the same for an opening between walls to fit a cabinet into. Two sticks and a pencil or knife line, then you can transfer that onto a story stick, its a lot more accurate than holding a measuring tape across a big opening between walls to measure.

If you are not worried about a tight fit as in a kitchen cabinet you may leave a half inch gap between walls and cabinet, then of course its not critical and you can of course use a tape measure, but you still run the risk of reading it wrong. That is a big risk. and happens a lot if you are right handed and in the habit of holding the tape in your right hand, as when you read the tape its upside down.

Below is what i was talking about with a square and cutoff.

You put your knife in the line and push your cutoff block up to the line with the square, hold the square tight to the story stick while removing the block and strike a line against your square. That gives you the exact size of your rail. You don't have to measure it and mark it with a ruler.

That goes the same for the gap between the rails.


Re: Story stick tips and tricks

#11

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Story stick tips and tricks

#12

Interesting concept

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"If you imagined that you built a cabinet the vertically sliced through it so that you had a sectional view, all of that information is on a story stick,"

I will contemplate this idea and see where it saves time and errors.

In my typical builds I make a scaled dimensioned drawing. I find if the proportions look good to me in the scaled drawing they will look good in reality. Then I proceed to transfer these dimensions to lumber to be cut.

If I employed a story stick I suppose then the next step would be to transfer the vertical measurements from the scaled drawing to the "vertical story stick" with a ruler, dividers, or whatever?

Re: Story stick tips and tricks

#13

Re: some comments and questions

Mark Hennebury

In the drawing below, is a sequence for dividing space into equal parts with two sticks, similar to using dividers.

At the top; clamp and mark two sticks.

next down; flip one and mark the other ends

next down; both are marked.

next down: guess the middle and strike line

next down: slide stick over to check;

next down; the centre is in between the two marks.

At most you may need to do this two or three times to get very accurate. Mark the first time with a pencil and the second and third times with a knife.

I use this method of guess, check, split the difference to divide and determine space sizes.

I will use one space and one stock size marked on a story stick as my reference, they will then be transfered onto another story stick and repeated to create a fullsize stick with multiple rails and spaces, they are all transfered from the original. So i may accumulate overall minor errors in the outside dimensions of a cabinet, by repeating measurements, but all of the internal measurements will be the same, so everything will fit. I often mark halfway along on two sticks then flip one and transfer also.


Re: Story stick tips and tricks

#14

Re: some comments and questions

Mark Hennebury

If you are making a simple frame;


You do the same thing just with all of the blocks; put your knife in the line, push the blocks with the square to the knife, hold the square tight to the stick, remove the blocks and strike a line against the square. The remaining space is the total of your spaces between the rails. In this case you need to divide into four equal parts, which you do using two sticks.


Re: Story stick tips and tricks

#15

Re: some comments and questions

Mark Hennebury

Once you determine the size and position of the rail and space. you mark them on the master ( short stick in this picture)

Then transfer and repeat as many times as needed to the full length. You can use two long sticks, mark halfway and flip to mark the other half reducing overall accumulated error.

The long stick is the full-length story stick that you use to mark your furniture, the short stick is the working stick that you use to mark your story stick with the original dimensions and for repeating those dimensions.

There are many ways to do things depending on what is or is not critical, and if you are working from one end and the other end is where it ends up, or if you are working strictly between to end lines.


Re: Story stick tips and tricks

#16

Re: Story stick tips and tricks

William Duffield

The Lee Valley story stick is so popular it is currently out of stock.

http://www.leevalley.com/us/wood/page.aspx?p=65359&cat=1,43513,65359


:)

Of course, it has a serious issue: You can't mark it with a knife, as Mark explains.

OTOH, if you are building custom kitchen cabinets, or cabinet shelves or a fireplace surround or assorted finish carpentry, it can be really difficult to bring the room back to the shop for making direct measurements, and carrying sticks long enough to record room measurements between site and shop can be difficult. Inside closet measurements, where a pencil mark can be accurate enough, can be really awkward with a stiff piece of wood.

All else being equal, I prefer tulip poplar sticks. I have used plywood cutoffs , but they can be inconvenient because they can often be marked clearly on only two faces. Some projects need measurements in three or four dimensions.

Re: Story stick tips and tricks

#17

Re: some comments and questions

TomD

I never have tapes that don't have only one measurement on them and are read upside and down the same.

I do agree misreading, particularly on metric tapes can happen. I am all for sticks.

Your lovely CAD drawings do show where this ought to be going. It is still tough to beat a knife cut, but I design in CAD, and want to take things out in CNC. May not live long enough though.