New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Do you push or pound waste removal

Posts

Do you push or pound waste removal

#1

Do you push or pound waste removal

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Waste removal to a scribe line is a common operation building furniture. It is used in both dovetails and M&T joinery, common to most pieces. I, and many others, cut the waste out as much as we safely can with a saw and then chisel to the scribe line. This discussion relates to the removal of that small, 1/16" or less, waste at the scribe line.

A common operation is to set the chisel in the scribe line and tap the chisel with the pounding(tapping) device of choice. Personally I like a soft rubber mallet. Removal proceeds quickly as it is quick to guide the chisel along the scribe line and tap, tap, tap.

An alternate is to saw close enough to the scribe line that a single thrusting paring cut can be used to remove this waste. It was this approach I recently tried while preparing some bridle joints in ash. I discovered some advantages and disadvantages for each approach without reaching a conclusion on what is "best".

What do you all do?

Re: Do you push or pound waste removal

#2

Re: Do you push or pound waste removal

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

For me, it depends on the wood species. I can easily hand-pare softwoods; hardwoods frequently require more grunt.

I recently acquired a 5/8" wide paring chisel. When time permits*, I want to grind it to a 20 degree bevel, and see if the lower angle increases the range of hand-paring I can do.

*This is my subtle way of saying, "heck if I know when I'll get around to it."

Re: Do you push or pound waste removal

#3

Re: Do you push or pound waste removal

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Bill, I saw as close to the line as I can, and then pare away the remainder.

I am mindful that chopping is hard on chisel edges. The harder the wood, the harder it is in the edge of the blade. Paring a thin slice will retain the edge far longer.

The lowest bevel I use is the 25 degrees on my Japanese slicks. Bench chisels are 30 degrees regardless of steel.



Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Do you push or pound waste removal

#4

It depends how closely I sawed.

Chuck Nickerson

My fret/coping saw work is not (yet) very consistent. If I sawed close enough I will pare.

Re: Do you push or pound waste removal

#5

Re: Do you push or pound waste removal

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Bill,

Dovetails. I fretsaw, then pare, using a paring block. Japanese paring chisels, about 12" long--fist around the end of it, and then lean on it, no arm strength used, just body weight. Chisels are honed to about 25 degrees. If I use a striking chisel (registered in the scribe line), I have less control as to exactly where the chisel will end up on the other side of the board. [BTW, if it's drawer sides, I clamp both sides (or sometimes 4 sides) together and gang saw both the defining tail cuts and the waste fretsawing. This simplifies the marking and makes for more precise saw cuts--in my hands. YMMV.]

On the tails board, the pin width will have been selected to match (usually) a 1/4" or 5/16" chisel, so it's one push and done. On the pin board, the waste is wider, and I use a 5/16" or 3/8" and walk the chisel down the line, rather than use a wider chisel and try to span all the way from pin to pin.

Single tenon shoulders. Arrange the marking so I can register the dozuki (0.012" kerf) right in the kerf and make an on-the-money cut. Then use a small chisel, 3/16" or so, to very slightly undercut the shoulders all round. This undercutting has to be done very carefully at the ends of the stick, to avoid actually cutting into the shoulder line on the adjacent side.

Multiple tenons, like on a case side, or the lower front rail under a drawer section. As above, but fret saw the waste between tenons, and pare.

Wiley

Re: Do you push or pound waste removal

#6

Re: Do you push or pound waste removal

William Duffield

I pare. If the waste is too thick due to clumsy sawing, I try to make two or three thin paring cuts, because it is less wear on the chisel edge and less work than picking up the mallet to chop. If the chisel happens to not be sharp enough to effectively pare, then instead of breaking stride and concentration to go sharpen it, I'll usually pick up the mallet and chop.

Re: Do you push or pound waste removal

#7

Re: It is faster...

TomD

to chop to the line, that is pretty much how it was always done, and the only downside I can see is lack of accuracy at the line. If you are bruising the shoulder you are doing it wrong. All the info you need is in FK's video. Follow it exactly no excursions to my preferred tool or personal weakness (as far as chopping is concerned anyway).

That said, there are situations where you have a few pins and a ton of open space and those are faster to do with sawing, but you have to saw right to the line. I have a special method for doing that, but it uses power tools. Every dovetail involves doing a crosscut across the end of the board's worth of cutting. If the waste comes pretty evenly from both sides then chopping is normally faster.

The very fastest is the system where one chops right through without breaking any material out either. That works on some best quality work were tiny drawers with soft sides can be penetrated without splitting out. Learned that from a Mack Headly video. But I don't have a ton of use for it as I am not that dainty in most regards.

Re: Do you push or pound waste removal

#8

Re: Hammer

TomD

I do use a hammer and a chisel for the cuts you actually asked about. I used to use metal Japanese Chisel hammers, but generally use a 20 oz (sounds a lot heavier than it hits), urethane carving mallet. It is a lot quieter.

If a 16th needed to be removed from a non socketed area like the end of a block, I would pare it with my paring chisels. Even in the socket, you can get tremendous force on a paring chisel by bracing it against your shoulder. My paring chisels were a special gift I bought myself, after the largest payment I ever received. But a very decent set can be accumulated from socket chisels with woodturning length handles. That is basically what the LN ones are. The kind of chisels one can pick up for a few bucks at flea markets. Mine are Japanese, non-tourist grade. Another option is something similar to a knife scales approach, or the handles on the LN

I like hammers because unlike piling on dead weight, the blow from a hammer is discrete. Once it is applied the chisel only goes so far, it can't be overworked in the cut.

Re: Do you push or pound waste removal

#9

Tap Tap


Re: Do you push or pound waste removal

#10

Re: Do you push or pound waste removal

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I use paring, chopping, and also sawing to the line. I generally saw right to the line if the surface is to mate with something else and not be seen. Like for tenons or tenon shoulders or dovetails, I saw to the line.

I use chopping or paring for surfaces that cannot be cut with a saw, or surfaces that will be seen. If bending or chipping of the edge results from using a mallet with the chisel, something is very wrong.

I think it is worthwhile learning all these techniques. If one seems clumsy, it would be helpful to try to discern why that is.

Re: Do you push or pound waste removal

#11

Re: Do you push or pound waste removal

Ron in Sterling, CT

I do both on dovetails depending on how close I get with my sawing. If to far away from the scribe line I will chop until I get close, then pare. I always do the final removal on dovetails with a paring cut.

Ron