New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Wooden Jack Grain Orientation

Posts

Wooden Jack Grain Orientation

#1

Wooden Jack Grain Orientation

Steve Kang

I'm building a traditional jack plane which will have a walnut body with an ipe sole. The 8/4 walnut board that I have for the body has near vertical grain, which is counter to most recommendations that I've read on the internet. Should I go through the trouble of ripping and laminating the board so that the grain is horizontal and "correct" or continue as is... The ipe also has vertical grain, similar to the walnut.

I have a 3rd option of laminating ipe cheeks onto the walnut in addition to the sole, though that may introduce new complications relating to dissimilar wood movement.

Any thoughts on the matter?

Re: Wooden Jack Grain Orientation

#2

Re: Wooden Jack Grain Orientation

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Steve

Left vertical, all ends of mortices (the bed and the wedge) will be weak and vulnerable to breaking away.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Wooden Jack Grain Orientation

#3

Re: Wooden Jack Grain Orientation

Steve Kang

Thanks Derek, i've chosen to take the horizontal grain approach for the body. Hopefully I won't run into any issues with the radial to tangential lamination.

Re: Wooden Jack Grain Orientation

#4

Re: Wooden Jack Grain Orientation

TomD

So if the issues you are considering are wood movement, you can deal with them by sealing the block. The main blocks that have substantial mass are the central one ahead and behind the blade. You are putting a sole on the plane, gluing on cheeks (?), if you skim veneer the tops, and saturate the endgrains with epoxy, you have sealed unit that will not be prone to movement. The cheeks are another mater, I just sealed the ends there.

After 35 years of making planes, I don't personally use laminations, I would find walnut a little soft. I don't sole planes. I use beech, white oak, or maple, in monolithic sections, for the most part. There are some planes that are just so much easier to glue up in sections, particularly single use planes. Or planes like rebates, or molding planes for one offs.