New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Dangerous Question

Posts

Dangerous Question

#1

Dangerous Question

Tony

I have a bronze Lie-Nielsen #4 that I had posted about in another forum with a tarnish problem. I have to take breaks from woodworking because of my health. I've been offered several solutions to take off the tarnish and a couple to keep it off. I'm not positive I want to deal with this - especially if I have to do it after every long break (depending if how effective wax is).

So now the dangerous question: I've been hankerin' to try a Veritas custom plane; thoughts on selling the LN and buying a Veritas custom #4?*

*I had a Veritas BD #4 of the previous generation and liked it ok but not the mouth adjuster (no longer an issue) and prefer the Bailey to the Norris adjuster (still something to consider).

Re: Dangerous Question

#2

Re: Dangerous Question

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Tony, the two smoothers I use the most are a bronze LN #3 and a Veritas Custom #4 (I would have purchased a #3 if this had been available). Both work very well, and both have strengths and weaknesses. Nothing is perfect. Think of the ideosyncracies of each as just being their respective personality.

I prefer the lateral adjuster if the Bailey/LN design over the Norris adjuster of the Custom as it can be more easily adjusted on the fly. However, both only get you into the ballpark and neither are good enough to be as exact as I would prefer.

All final adjustments are made with a small and light jewellers hammer, by tapping the side of the blade.

Fore- and aft blade projection is easier on the Custom. The adjustable mouth of this plane also facilitates quick clearing of shavings. Plus, adjusting the chipbreaker becomes less complicated on the Custom once you get used to the different system (I shall not get into this here). The more familiar chipbreaker of the LN will initially cause one to be frustrated with the small screws on the Custom (as noted earlier, a different method reverses the situation).

The ergonomics of the planes I have are similar. In part, this is because the handles are similar - the Custom comes with a choice and I went with one that is similar to the Bailey design. The #3 size handle on the LN is small, and I swapped mine out for a #4 size (needed a little tweaking to fit).

Great planes, both.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Dangerous Question

#3

Re: Dangerous Question

TomD

Have you explored the socks they sell, I have a few planes in those. Not something I would do overnight, but if I am not thinking of using the plane for a while.

I'm a bit of a yachtie, and when it comes to avoiding tarnish, we use bronze not the sewer pipe cast iron they use in LV. One of the events that killed off cast iron for me, for the most part, was having an earlier iteration of LV planes, a standard bailey that was made to work out of the box, and with a document guaranteeing the sole was ground to the tens... Anyway, no fault of the plane, it got into the one moving box I had that apparently sat in some water last move, and when I got back to it, not having known, it was ruined. A few exceptions along the way, that was it for me with the sewer piping. Overall another advantage of wood.

Re: Dangerous Question

#4

Why is tarnish a problem?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Exactly what are you talking about when you speak of tarnish and why is it a problem to you?

I don't own any bronze tools so I don't understand why this tarnish problem is worth any effort to cure, or why this is a problem in your case and apparently not a problem for other bronze plane users. In any case, we are able to store silver with out it becoming tarnished. I'll bet I could find a way to store a small plane where it would not tarnish either.

Re: Dangerous Question

#5

Re: Why is tarnish a problem?

Tony

Tarnish leaves black streaks on the wood. Wouldn't be a problem on any plane but a smoother. Darned inconvenient to set a smoother to leave a beautiful reflective surface and then have black smudgy streaks all over the board.

I do have plane socks but when I pulled my iron planes out they all had rust on them -and they were camellia liked when put away. Didn't do the same with the bronze plane as I was thinking it wouldn't rust (which was a big reason I bought the darn thing).

If I was confident that any solution would keep it from coming back I wouldn't worry about this question. On a side note I made a doe's foot that I'm going to take it to to reduce down the depth of because I don't care if it has black streaks. I'll see how the wood 'polishes' it.

Re: Dangerous Question

#6

Re: Why is tarnish a problem?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Where are you storing these tools that they rust and tarnish? Obviously in a location where the humidity is too high for tool storage.

So if you trade out your bronze plane for a LV steel one why isn't it going to rust just like the planes you described that rusted It seems to me the solution to your problem is to store your tools in a different place. Instead of a "sock" maybe the sock drawer.

Re: Dangerous Question

#7

Re: Why is tarnish a problem?

John in NM

Is a box with some desiccant an option? Could be a fun little project and useful too.

You could also try making a wood bodied plane, that would solve the problem of oxidation of the metal body (Bill's right, if tarnish is a problem rust will be one too).

Re: Dangerous Question

#8

environment

Tony

I live on the south plains where we're lucky to get 20" of water from the sky. The planes are in my heated/ac'd garage - I have one of those Mitsubishi wall mount units. They usually sit on my bench. I think I got on top of the rust issue finally with a combo of CRC 3-36 and camellia oil.*. I'm going to order some renaissance wax for at least the bronze plane unless someone tells me something better.

UPDATE: I used the #4 on a doe's foot I made out of BORG white pine to try to polish the sole. Still had just a bit of streaking at the end but was taking 1.5 thou shavings and leaving a shimmering surface - which is useful for a bench appliance made of wood that dents when you look at it. Think I'll keep it for a might and find another way to meet my hankering.

*haven't put the 3-36 on the soles because I was afraid it would interfere with finish.

Re: Dangerous Question

#9

Re: environment

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Tony

You and I have discussed this before, so I mention the issue for the benefit of others here.

I have a bronze LN #3, as well as a number of other brass planes, and I do not experience any marks from them. In fact, I cannot ever recall marks from the #3 in all the years I have owned it. The plane has had a lot of use in the past 4 years (since I began using the chipbreaker to control tearout) .... and this is the main difference between my plane and yours - yours sits unused for very long periods.

The simple fix is to wipe it down before you use it. And to use the plane more frequently. You are dealing with oxidation (although George at SMC believes that the black is leeching out of the brass, and advises a solvent to remove it), and either burnish it away on wood, or wipe it away before use. If the marking is slight, a second shaving will remove anything from the first.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Dangerous Question

#10

Strange....

John in NM

Basically the same here - though we're higher up the rainfall is the same scant average you're used to. I only have a couple bronze planes, but neither tarnishes much. Is the annoying marking the only sign of tarnish you're seeing? I could easily believe you'd still get a bit of marking even if the visible tarnish is mild.

Re: Dangerous Question

#11

Re: Strange....

Tony Wilkins

The tarnish was bad enough that my fingers turned black rubbing them on the plane body.

Re: Dangerous Question

#12

may be another problem

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"Leaching" of something inside the bronze makes no sense. What is going to survive the temperature of casting bronze, then be able to diffuse through the bronze and finally be soluble in a solvent? Not a chance.

Unless the environment is unusual the bonze is going to acquire a thin layer of oxidized metal which will not be a problem. Obviously we are dealing with an unusual environment here, either local to the storage area or in the atmosphere.

Tony stated that his cast iron planes rusted in this same environment. He went on to say that the environment is dry. This claim should be confirmed for high humidity is the most likely cause of the observed corrosion. Texas might be dry but this area of the shop may not be.

However, oxygen plus moisture is not the only oxidizing agent that would cause this problem. Are there oil wells in the area, a power plant or other source of "pollution"? Sulfur compounds in the atmosphere will cause the corrosion reported, especially on bronze where there will make a black deposit.

It would seem to me that moving the storage location would provide some useful data to diagnose this problem, if not eliminate it. Is the source of the corrosive agent in the shop, or in the atmosphere?

Re: Dangerous Question

#13

You may be onto something there...

John in NM

I remember working with mesquite in the summer in AZ, your hands would turn purple - a combination of the high tannin dust, sweat, and iron from tools.

If there are oil wells near Tony's place, it wouldn't surprise me much if a trace contaminant was causing the unusual tarnish problem.

Re: Dangerous Question

#14

Re: You may be onto something there...

Tony Wilkins

Not too many oil wells but a lot of cotton. There are lots of cotton gins. And it can be dusty, especially when New Mexico blows by - thanks John;)

Re: Dangerous Question

#15

Re: You may be onto something there...

John in NM

Lots of salt and gypsum blowing in on our dust :D

You could try waxing the sole before each use - that might help buff off any oxidation since the last use and keep from marking the wood at least. It'd still stain your hands though.

Re: Dangerous Question

#16

Re: may be another problem

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Tony and all,

Tolk coal-fired power plant is located in the south plains area, and is currently challenging an EPA mandate to install SO2 scrubbers. It's quite a large plant.

My experience with LN4 is exactly as Derek describes, but you seem to be dealing with a far more difficult problem. The LN4 is a great plane, and I imagine you would get good bids for it, especially if it is lightly used and you still have the box and wrapping.

Wiley

Re: Dangerous Question

#17

Toolchest solution

Tony

If I finish my Dutch toolchest, that will be a step in the right direction I'm sure.

Re: Dangerous Question

#18

Thanks Derek for answering my email

Tony

The one I sent about using LV PM-V blades in LN planes. Just wish I could get one for my LN 62.

Re: Dangerous Question

#19

Why do you think that

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It appears that something in your shop atmosphere is corrosive to iron and the "bronze" the plane is made from (I looked this stuff up and I would call it brass. It can be used for nautical hardware so it would appear that moisture is not corroding it. )

Why would putting a tool in a tool chest keep your shop atmosphere from getting to it and causing corrosion?

I would be looking for a source of sulfur in your shop atmosphere. Some sulfur compounds react promptly with copper to make soft, black copper sulfide. In the mean time store the plane somewhere else to see if the corrosive atmosphere is local to the current storage area. I wasn't kidding when I suggested a sock drawer.

Re: Dangerous Question

#20

Re: Dangerous Question

don stephan

Late to the discussion. Have you discussed with the manufacturer?

Re: Dangerous Question

#21

Re: Why do you think that

Tony

It would keep dust, cotton junk, and other airborne stuff from landing on it. Not sure what would make sulfur in the air. I guess I could bring it into the house for a but to see if that changes anything. I also have some renaissance wac that will be here Tuesday to try.

Re: Dangerous Question

#22

LN suggested cleaning with maroon scotch brite


Re: Dangerous Question

#23

H2S sources

John in NM

Both the water heater and sewer pipes can host bacteria that produce H2S, as well as (obviously) the sewer vent, all of which could easily find a way into a person's garage shop.

Then there is oil wells, compost piles, the town dump, water treatment plants, and paper mills (doubt there's one of those down in Tony's neck of the woods :D )

Then there was also that Chinese drywall maybe 15 years ago - didn't that out gas H2S?

Re: Dangerous Question

#24

Re: H2S sources

Tony Wilkins

Of those, the water heater is in the other end of the garage so that's a possibility. House was built in 2013 so I doubt there was Chinese off gassing dry wall. Not sure about sewer vents but there are two gas fireplaces with vents just outside.

Re: Dangerous Question

#25

Re: may be another problem

Tony Wilkins

Interesting about the coal plant as it's upwind most of the time.

And I still have the box and everything that came with it.

I still am getting black fingers handling the plane.