New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Cleaning antique finishes

Posts

Cleaning antique finishes

#1

Cleaning antique finishes

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

I have this old secretary that I obtained a year ago from a 92 year old friend. This secretary had been in his family for many generations and was used in a tavern in Rhode Island in the late 1700's. I have no idea how old this is, but the tavern burned down in the 1880's.

George Washington wrote about staying at this tavern in his diary from what I've read. Did he sit at this secretary? Probably not. I think it was probably made after his death.

The closer I look at it, I can see it was pretty crudely made. The whole piece appears to be made of pine with walnut veneer. Even the two doors are each a single 17" wide board with walnut veneer applied to look like rails and stiles. Of course the pine boards have split which is why the venner is split. Even the sides of the case are a single wide board. Each of the 4 turned feet are slightly different. I've found some cut nails as well as steel screws that appears to be hand made/filed.

It's interesting to see all the old hand tooling marks on it.

Anyway, I was reading an article by Jeff Jewitt about cleaning old finishes. He talks about first using mineral spirits, then wiping down with soap (Dawn) and water. Lastly, wax. I was thinking of doing this in hopes of not doing any damage and trying to preserve the patina - the finish may be too far gone though. There are some spots of spattered paint too. I may have to wipe on a coat or two of varnish after cleaning since the finish is pretty much shot I think.

Any advice anybody would like to share in regards to cleaning it? I am not looking to restore and refinish this, just want to kind of conserve it.

A couple pictures.


The backside of one of the doors - single wide board



Paint splatter




Re: Cleaning antique finishes

#2

Re: Cleaning antique finishes

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Disclaimer: I don't know anything about conserving valuable antiques.

I have had good success cleaning with 4/0 wool and wax. The wax solvent dissolves gunk well and the wool loosens gunk. If the finish is gone, then 4/0 wool and linseed oil is used. If it is really gone then your varnish idea seems reasonable.

BTW, the furniture refinishers guild (I don't recall the right name) went after Antiques Road Show, a program that advocates avoiding refinishing under any circumstances, with apparently bogus claims that any refinishing reduces the value of an antique. Not so according to other experts in this field. According to the article, an agreement with this group was reached whereby the ARS backed off their "don't ever" refinish advocacy.

I don't know. If it looks too shabby to live in my house I make it look more like original by refinishing. However, if it already looks like original then I agree with the Antiques Road Show opinion about refinishing, an approach advocated by Bob Flexner. Bob too has gone after ARS claims about refinishing.

I attended a seminar that described restoring the "Fox and Grapes" signature piece in the Philadelphia museum.....by refinishing to achieve its original appearance. Apparently this renowned furniture conservation lab thought refinishing this piece improved it.

Re: Cleaning antique finishes

#3

Re: Cleaning antique finishes

kim

I think the ARS don't finish dictum is nonsense, especially if you want to use the piece involved. Perhaps a better dictum would be "refinish without destroying patina." Along those lines I recently came across light and dark balms sold by LV which seem to work great, at least on some old furniture that a UHaul truck mistreated. Worth a try as it's application keeps the patina.

Kim

Re: Cleaning antique finishes

#4

Re: Cleaning antique finishes

kim

Here's the link: http://www.leevalley.com/US/wood/page.aspx?p=74503&cat=1,190,42997

Kim

Re: Cleaning antique finishes

#5

Re: Cleaning antique finishes

don stephan

It's possible there are some situations where one might want to consider refinishing an antique, and other situations where one might not want to consider refinishing. I would be shocked if a refinishing guild did not challenge a blanket statement to not refinish - their business is refinishing.

Whether to refinish is always the choice of the owner, including a museum. That doesn't mean refinishing won't sometimes might lower the auction value - if selling is not a consideration then possibly lowering the auction value is not a worry.

If patina is meant to include just the color portion (including uneven accumulation of dirt and grime) of the appearance, applying a clear topcoat that creates an even sheen (flat, matte, satin, semi, or gloss) won't affect it. If patina is meant to include the color as well as the likely varying sheen, then applying a topcoat that creates an even sheen would change the overall patina.

Without doubt there are some antiques that I would not hesitate to consider refinishing if I was the owner, and others I would feel should not be refinished, again if I were the owner.

Re: Cleaning antique finishes

#6

Re: Cleaning antique finishes

TomD

The problem is if you are on the young side, you may make the right decision for now about use and refinishing, and 30-50 years down the road it will be very costly. That thing that is a user today will be an antique in 50 years when 150 million more americans are in the house.

There is no one way to proceed, as there is no one finish to deal with. With tools I just make them the way I want them, though these days I use few wooden tools that are not made by me. But when I did the odd one, I cleaned them with an antique cleaner and then slaped on some whatever, normally an oil or wax.

Re: Cleaning antique finishes

#7

Re: Cleaning antique finishes

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

I have had good success cleaning with 4/0 wool and wax.

What if you decide you need to apply a finish, would you wash the wax off with mineral spirits?

If the finish is gone, then 4/0 wool and linseed oil is used.

It could very well be too far gone. Looks and feels oxidized, if that is the right word. When you say 'linseed oil' do you mean linseed oil or boiled linseed oil?

Thanks for the info.

Re: Cleaning antique finishes

#8

Re: Cleaning antique finishes

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If it is that far gone then I think you need to remove the "dead" finish. If you put fresh varnish over dead finish it probably will not adhere.

I have a "high dollar" walnut desk I bought cheap ($140). The lacquer finish on the top was worn through a few places. I didn't have time to do a refinish at the time. I wool and oiled it (boiled) and it brightened it up considerably. Eventually I need to strip and recoat though.

Re: Cleaning antique finishes

#9

Understood. Thanks.


Re: Cleaning antique finishes

#10

Re: Cleaning antique finishes

Warren in Lancaster, PA

For some reason I am unable to see your pictures. I recommend doing no abrasion, no oil and no varnish until you know whether the desk was made in 1710 or 1910, whether it is worth $80 or $80,000. For 18th century stuff we rarely use anything but wax, shellac, and hide glue. Things that can be removed.

Edit: I removed a story about a piece of furniture that was greatly devalued by careless refinishing.

Re: Cleaning antique finishes

#11

Re: Cleaning antique finishes

Sgian Dubh

"I wool and oiled it (boiled) and it brightened it up considerably."

Bill, I'd be wary of recommending including linseed oil, boiled or raw, in polish revivers. Linseed oil has a tendency to darken wood, which may be undesirable. There's an old recipe for polish reviver that used frequently to be suggested made up of three equal parts raw linseed oil, alcohol (meths) and vinegar. Charles Hayward was a well known proponent of this and other similar concoctions. As I understand it (and I could be wrong) most antique restorers nowadays are no longer in favour of this type of formulation because of the previously mentioned darkening effect on wood. Slainte.

Re: Cleaning antique finishes

#12

Yes, but

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If the finish is so far gone that oil will absorb then I would use varnish. But often some finish remains that still seals the wood and no darkening will occur....in my limited experience. The surface film of oil will brighten up the dull areas and make the surface look presentable for a while.

Re: Cleaning antique finishes

#13

Fox and Grapes restoration

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

In keeping with the current philosophy of furniture conservation that any material added must be reversible, the museum shop removed all the previous botched finishing materials they could. They then added colored shellac to achieve the color of the original piece (no stain as that would not be reversible) and finally top coats of shellac.

Personally I find varnish easier to remove than shellac, but what I learned at the lecture is what Warren posted.