New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Sharpton Stone question

Posts

Sharpton Stone question

#1

Sharpton Stone question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I do not have any experience with water stones. I was gifted a Sharpton 120 Professional stone. No idea where it was bought or I would return it for credit on something I know about. Anyway, I sharpen as follows: hollow grind with power wheel, followed by "Fine" fixed diamond plate then 1 micron loose diamond on cast iron. For those with experience, do you see some way this stone would beneficially fit into my sharpening regime? I also sharpen kitchen knives, but this grit seems a bit coarse to be useful for knives.?.

And....included was a 8000 Norton water stone. Would this stone be equivalent to the 1 micron diamond? Or, to put it another way, is this the finest/last grit one would use in a sequence? Is it overkill fine?

An improvement I see in my sharpening would be to use 15 micron loose diamond after the hollow grind. Loose 15 micron diamond cuts much faster than my "Fine" fixed plate. I am reluctant to follow the 15 micron loose with 1 micron loose for worry about carry-over of the 15 micron grit to the 1 micron plate. Would it be practical to follow loose 15 micron with the 8000 Norton stone, assuming the Norton stone will cut abrasion resistant tool steel (probably not?).

Re: Sharpton Stone question

#2

Re: Sharpton Stone question

Paul in NJ

Hi Bill,

I have 240, 1000, and 8000 Shapton water stones. The 240 is useless for me. It is soft and wears out of flat almost instantly. I suspect your 120 will be similar. The 1000 and 8000 cut so fast, I bought the 240 to flatten backs but it was a waste of money. The Shaptons do fine with A1 but I don’t have anything more exotic than that. When I grind, I do so just short of creating a burr on the edge. The 1000 creates a burr quickly and I move on to the 8000 to finish. I like the Shaptons and they cut very fast but I have gone back to oil stones. I got tired of flattening the Shaptons and they actually get my hands dirtier. I briefly tried loose diamond but got exasperated with cross contamination when moving up grits. I have a fixed diamond stone that flattens my Waterstones and I sometime use to flatten a back. I don’t think your 8000 Norton would be overkill fine.

Paul Dzioba

Re: Sharpton Stone question

#3

why is it important to have a flat sotne

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Well, I answered my own question for blade backs, but for bevels? I don't see why it makes any difference.

Re: Sharpton Stone question

#5

Re: Sharpton Stone question

Hank Knight

Bill,

I have never used Shaptons, so I'm no help there. I did, however, sharpen with Norton water stones for years. The 8000 was my final stone. it leaves a highly polished edge on O1 and similar tool steels that needs little, if any, stropping. It will also cut A2, but slowly. I abandoned it for my wear resistent irons and have started using 3 micron diamonds on cast iron. This works much better. I would guess the 8000 Norton stone is approximately equivalent to 3 micron loose diamonds. It is a very soft stone and will gouge easily. Like all water stones, it requires regular falttening. I still use mine for O1 and similar steel edges. My guess is that your new water stones are redundant and don't fit well in your current regimen.

My $.02.

Hank

Re: Sharpton Stone question

#6

Re: Sharpton Stone question

kim

It's actually "Shapton," not "Sharpton." This may help you find information as well as sell it.

The 120 is for shaping edges initially, 1st step.

Kim

Re: Sharpton Stone question

#7

Did you want a camber on your chisels?

Brian Holcombe

If not then you'll want to flatten your stones :D

Smart-Assery aside, I think you may be better off without that stone. I'd return and find something more useful.

WRT Shaptons, I think the 1k and 5k are nice stones, I had the chance to try a few out and I've been impressed by how well they stay flat. My Chosera 3k goes out of flat much quicker.

Re: Sharpton Stone question

#8

not that direction

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have never had a stone go out of flat laterally (perpendicular to the long axis). So I presumed the flatness fretting was from the stone hollowing along it long axis. It was lack of flatness in this direction that led to the question of why is it important.

I no longer sharpen woodworking tools on stones that wear unflat. But I do sharpen knives on stones that wear. I spend time on all the stones's surface to distribute wear. But eventually the center of the stone gets somewhat thinner than the ends. But I don't see that it matters any more for a knife than a plane blade. I presume the result is a slightly convex bevel. Some argue this profile is more robust.

Re: Sharpton Stone question

#9

Re: not that direction

Brian Holcombe

It will certainly go out of flat laterally in this case, especially in this case. I have the 320 grit shapton and it's a very friable stone, that goes hollow in a hurry.

I've broken up with it, for use of other methods.

Re: Sharpton Stone question

#10

Re: Double shuffle

TomD

They go out of true in both directions for the same reason, people sharpen more in the middle than on the edges. You have to take the chisels out over the edges to keep the edges down, and usually they will require some truing no mater what you do.

By the way, while most people don't use the stone surface properly, the reason they work the middle more than the ends is partly just how it is. If you go to the end of the stone and stop before you run off, you don't wear the end of the stone as much as the middle which you cross going in both directions. Most people stop before they get to the ends, so not curving out is impossible. Side to side most people do not overlap the edges.

If you have ever seen FK sand a surface he sands in strokes from end to end (size permitting), but he runs half off the ends and does a double rub there, before starting back towards the other end, where he does the same double shuffle. Same deal.

Re: Sharpton Stone question

#11

Re: Double shuffle

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have two soft "rocks". One is hollowed along the long axis 1/8" and the other newer harder one is hollowed 1/16". Both are flat end to end across the narrow face. I don't use either for chisels which I suspect would change the situation.

I use cast iron now days and it stays flat forever. One less thing to worry about.

Re: Sharpton Stone question

#12

Re: Double shuffle

TomD

I think I picked up the diamond thing from you. I don't really like the way it works on cast, but I use it on strops and it saves me tons of time sharpening, particularly in the cold winter shop. So thanks for that.