New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Stropping

Posts

Stropping

#1

Stropping

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Questions for those of you who use a strop as part of your sharpening...

Do you use a strop on both chisels and plane irons?

Do you worry about rounding over the edge?

How is your strop made?

Leather on piece of wood?

Do you use the rough or smooth side of the leather? Both?

What do you charge the strop with?

Do you have different strops charged with different compounds?

How do you use your strop(s) for chisels and irons-what is the technique?

Do you strop both sides of the iron/chisel?

Years ago I read here at WC about using the green compound on a flat piece of hard maple. I've done that occasionally and it seems to make a little difference. I recently got a piece of leather and was thinking about making a strop or two and wanted to know what you guys have to say about strops and about using them.

By the way, I have one of those green compound stick things I've used. I also have white compound in a tube that is used on the buffing wheel of a grinder. Can this white stuff be used on a strop.

White vs green. Is one more aggressive than the other.

Thanks!

PS, I hope this isn't one of those pins first, tails first kinda a questions...

:)

Re: Stropping

#2

Re: Stropping

Kees

Do you use a strop on both chisels and plane irons? Yes

Do you worry about rounding over the edge? No

How is your strop made? Leather glued to wood.

Leather on piece of wood? Yes, I added a lid to keep the leater clean.

Do you use the rough or smooth side of the leather? Both? Rough side

What do you charge the strop with? Autosol

Do you have different strops charged with different compounds? No

How do you use your strop(s) for chisels and irons-what is the technique? A couple of swipes, back and forth.

Do you strop both sides of the iron/chisel? Yes

Chisels I regularly swipe on the strop during work. This helps to keep the edge sharp for longer.

Re: Stropping

#3

Re: Stropping

Sgian Dubh

Do you use a strop on both chisels and plane irons? (Yes, usually)

Do you worry about rounding over the edge? (No)

How is your strop made? (Skin [leather?] on the palm of my hand)

Leather on piece of wood? (No - the skin's still attached to my hand, ha, ha) Slainte.

Re: Stropping

#4

Re: Stropping

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Disclaimer....I have not studied this topic. I do what I do, empirically, because it works for the need at hand. It may not be best.

Can this white stuff be used on a strop. I use green stick

Do you use a strop on both chisels and plane irons? occasionally. If I don't get out the 1 micron paste, I strop.

Do you worry about rounding over the edge? back YES! bevel no

How is your strop made? high quality leather on wood stick

Leather on piece of wood? yes

Do you use the rough or smooth side of the leather? smooth

What do you charge the strop with? green stick

Do you have different strops charged with different compounds? no

How do you use your strop(s) for chisels and irons-what is the technique? I actually use the strop on knives most. It is quick way to refine an edge when I don't quite need to sharpen on a rock. I sometimes use the strop in lieu of 1 micron diamond paste on cast iron. Experimenting with this approach. Going from fine "rock" to strop works well for my knife sharpening.

Do you strop both sides of the iron/chisel? I found that I rounded over the back when stropping them. Took a lot of grinding to restore flatness. Now avoid doing backs.

White vs green. Is one more aggressive than the other. Don't know

Re: Stropping

#5

Re: Stropping

Hank Knight

Ha! That's the first time I've heard of stropping on the skin of your hand in the woodworking context. My father used to strop his double edged razor blades on the palm of his hand before shaving. I've often wondered if anyone did this with woodworking tools.

Re: Stropping

#6

Re: Stropping

Sgian Dubh

And I thought it was a pretty common technique Hank. Maybe that's simply because it's the way demonstrated to me many moons ago, and I simply emulated my teacher, an old gnarled cabinet maker who'd worked in the trade for perhaps forty or more years! Slainte.

Re: Stropping

#7

Re: Stropping

William Duffield

My answers are similar to the other answers you've gotten. Some details: I've stropped on my hand when I didn't have a better strop with me. The grit normally embedded in my skin seems to be coarser, and of uncontrolled size compared to what I put on my horse butt strop, and therefore doesn't give as good an edge.

I mix up my own from 0.3 µ chromium oxide powder and mineral oil. It's a lot finer than what is in the green sticks. It doesn't contain any silica or alumina or other abrasive compounds mixed in. Does it work better than the green stick or other abrasive sticks? I don't know. I haven't done any rigorous testing. It works well enough.

Many years ago, green crayons worked well, but I think they've replaced the chromium oxide with green dye, and they don't work at all any more.

Re: Stropping

#8

Re: Stropping

David Charlesworth

I have a similar experience to Richard.

The palm of the hand.

I understood that this was for bending wire edge to and fro, until it hopefully dropped off.

Was never convinced of the abrasive property.

David

Re: Stropping

#9

Passed down from when straight razor was common

Keith Newton

If the blade picks up a bit of compound leaving a little residue just back from the edge, it could push the whiskers down rather than offering the fine edge without the buildup.

I use white compound on a mdf disk. it is so easy to set the heel down first, then tilt up until I feel the bevel touch, then come up a couple more degrees.

The mdf disk edge is shaped with a very long ellipse which allows me to get inside the flute of my smallest carving tools or turning gouges, which also makes it easy to do the flat side of a chisel or plane blade in seconds.

The mdf fiber really holds the compound well, but isn't soft enough to bend around causing any rounding over.

Re: Stropping

#10

Re: Stropping

TomD

How cold is it? Cold be an Eskimo bar... Normally though, the white is for polishing stainless. The red is for soft metals. In woodworking tools form they progress like grits with the white coarser faster working.

The green, the LB stuff is all you need on a power wheel or belt. But for hand stropping you could use several grits. I just use diamond. I mentioned at one point I used a strop with hard leather, now in fact, I use a hard leather strop which was originally loaded with rouge and green. That might explain the durability, if it is stopping the diamond from sinking in.

Re: Stropping

#11

Re: Stropping

TomD

I think razor stropping, or hand stropping is an alignment or cleaning process, if we are loading something up with grit and basically abrading it, then I think the process is grinding/buffing range. Of course you can sometimes combine processes.