Re: Do try the belt sander if you want to
TomD
That is like saying use a hand saw to rip lumber, you can get into a lot of trouble using a BS or TS. Which is to say it is true... But well within average skills. I should say though that with a belt sander you want to drag your edge, you don't want the belt turning so it meets the edge first, you can skew the chisel and usually get away with that. And then to that I would qualify by saying all my rough grinding (down to a pre-HT edge of maybe 1/32") is done with the belt coming at the edge first, leading the edge. But that isn't sharpening mode.
Advantages of belt grinders are that:
- You don't move the tool you just present it. This makes control a lot easier.
- While grinding on hard wheels is easy enough, belts are less likely to burn a tool
- They cut faster which speeds certain jobs up, but one still needs to work within the capacity of the tool.
Basic strategy is the same, learn to hold the tool against the moving surface with full contact, and "no" cutting or heating happening. This is like learning to rub the bevel, or find the bevel in woodturning. In woodturning once you are there, you alter the angle to take a cut. In grinding, you just apply more pressure.
Belts cut so fast that you don't need a lot of speed for sharpening. Remember Scary Sharp was a manual process. Variable speed is a big advantage on a belt grinder, and these days it is a cheap option off ebay etc. I paid 25 bucks for two varaible 1/2 HP motors, off craigs. Reducing speed is going to make things easier, and reduce any danger of kickback (never happened to me on a belt grinder, but it is possible).
Belts can't blow up; and while they produce dust from the abrasive on the belts, particularly real steel grinding belts seem to produce a lot less dust than one gets off soft wheels, for an equal cut.