New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

ebay handsaws

Posts

ebay handsaws

#1

ebay handsaws

Joseph Piotrowski

I'm adding used Handsaw to my ever growing hand tool pile. ebay is addictive.

i'm not sure as to what is best for each task, wood type etc. is there a handy chart somewhere? i need a cheat sheet while combing through ebay

for instance i just bought, as listed, a Atkins 26" rip saw 10 PT. it basically looks new and for 9.99 plus shipping, i just had to jump on it.

there is another i bidding on: "Disston No. 16 has a 26" blade with a faint etch still on it. This saw is 5 1/2 PPI,"

are these worth it? any good resource on what saw to use with what?

Re: ebay handsaws

#2

reverse engines

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It seems to me that you are approaching woodworking in reverse. Maybe step 1 should be to answer the question as to why you want to do woodworking.

In my case I wanted to make furniture. Faced with making something with the skills I had acquired it became readily apparent what I needed that I didn't have and what I needed to learn.

In the case at hand I never would have found any need for either of the saws you are after. Someone else might use them daily. You need to find out where you are at before buying stuff, unless the objective is to collect tools. A rip saw, no matter the bargain it might be, is as useless as tits on a boar hog unless you plan on ripping lumber with a hand saw.....after learning how to rip lumber with a hand saw....after discovering a need to rip lumber.

Re: ebay handsaws

#3

Re: ebay handsaws

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I'm with the other Bill. Stop buying, and look at how you want to work.

I've never heard of a rip tooth saw that length with 10 ppi. That doesn't mean they don't exist; I've just never heard of one. Generally, when you're at that length, you're cutting your rough stock into slightly oversized versions of the sizes you'll need, so that you can then plane the stock to size; so the relatively rough cut left behind by 5-1/2 or thereabouts teeth is fine.

A backsaw (10"-12" long) filed to rip pattern with ten teeth, yes, that I can see: for cutting joints.

Chart? Is the wood you're working green or dry? Softwood? Hardwood? Really hard hardwood? Do you buy it rough, or smoothed two sides or four sides? How large are the pieces you're making? All these will affect saw size and tooth configuration choices.

The classic basic recommendation for handsaws (26" or so) was a ripsaw in 5-1/2 ppi, and a crosscut saw in either 8 ppi (if you're mainly doing carpentry) or 10 ppi (if you're mainly doing furniture). No harm in having all three. I've got an 11 ppi crosscut that's handy, too, although I'd buy good backsaws before I'd get a fourth handsaw, if I were buying intentionally.

Are you (or your customers, even if "customer" in this case means "significant other") interested in getting the projects done, or do you enjoy handwork enough that you're willing to do things by hand even if it will take you way longer than power tools will permit and even though the work you do will disappear in the process of the project? Let me explain that last phrase: when you rip a board to get the stock you need for a project, by the time you've planed and trimmed the board straight, square, and the right size, all those saw strokes will be gone, living only in memory, erased by the plane. If you take pleasure in ripping by hand, and have the time, go for it! It's a great feeling, watching that saw move through the length of the cut; ripping is particularly amazing, because a sharp saw with the right number of teeth for the thickness of the stock moves down the line so fast.

I will occasionally use a rip saw; but I have to confess that, for the work I'm doing now (carpentry on our house, with a lot of the trim boards going straight from saw to installation to paint), a lot of electrons are moving around.

----------

Full disclosure: I have a lot more handsaws than I'll ever need. I've paid $1 for them at yard sales, so, when I realize I should get rid of them, I can donate them to the ReStore without pain. My goal, when the work on the house settles down, is to spend some time analyzing what I've got, keep the good stuff, and release the rest into the wild one way or another. In the meantime, they hang from the ceiling joists, not in my way. But, realistically, I'm recommending that you not do what I've done; I've learned, my son, and am here to encourage you not to follow my path.

Re: ebay handsaws

#4

Re: ebay handsaws

Joseph Piotrowski

Sounds like the saw I bought is more of a cross cut pattern. Thanks for the information.

Re: ebay handsaws

#5

Re: ebay handsaws

TomD

You might look at some of Christopher Schwarz's work. He has a DVD on saws that takes you through it, I think. I just go to his blog and look topics up if I want to know what he thinks. Not my go to guy for a variety of reasons, but he is a good combination of knowledge and restraint.

If you want to work wood as opposed to buying tools and hanging out on forums, then guy's like Chris also have to be evaluated based on whether their advice really relates to your path. But beyond that, woodworking is an amazing activity where the tools you can legitimately amass are never ending. Something like tailoring certainly has some tools also, but at the same level the best work can be done with a very short list of tools. In woodworking there are many tools for every single mark you make on the wood. Just for starters. You can soon end up spending most of you time trying to wade through and maintain the stuff. Every tool you buy is a time commitment and a certain amount of metal space.

Re: ebay handsaws

#6

You certainly....

Brian Roberts

need to educate yourself to the point where you can, with certainty, tell whether a saw is rip or crosscut by looking at how the teeth are configured.

Re: ebay handsaws

#7

Sounds like it might be time for a librarian

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

You should wander down to your local library and see what books they have on woodworking. A basic book (look for the older ones) will give you an introduction to saw types, and teach you how to distinguish crosscut from rip. Yes, you can get much of that by wandering around the interweb, but a book will generally have a coherent structure with all the information in one place.

Re: ebay handsaws

#8

Simple difference

John in NM

And I found you a picture rather than a thousand words :D

It sounds like you've already bought the Atkins, so have a look at the teeth when it arrives, then cut a partial kerf in a board and have a look at that too. At 10 teeth or whatever it was, I'm guessing its a crosscut, but you never know, someone could have re-filed a crosscut for their own custom purpose.

A general purpose handsaw is a good thing to have around, but unless you want to do handtool work only, you probably won't use a rip saw much. I have two or three cross cuts I haven't used in a long time.

Re: ebay handsaws

#9

the saw arrived.

Joseph Piotrowski

thanks for the information. the saw did come and it looks brand new and i believe its a crosscut but i will test it out today to see for sure. i have to winterize my house today. meaning all the outdoor furniture, hoses etc get stuffed in my gargae/shop.

i will be arranging all the tools and house equipment in there. i'm aiming to leave me self enough square footage to tinker over the winter. so that may very well leave me with the need to rip and cross cut. obviously nothing big.

Re: ebay handsaws

#10

Re: the saw arrived.

John in NM

Sounds like you are limited on shop space - which is one of the many great reasons to utilize hand tools.

Short saw horses are a great asset for hand sawing, a pair of those would be a good project to start on and familiarize yourself with your new saw(s) :D

Re: ebay handsaws

#11

Re: the saw arrived.

Joseph Piotrowski

exactly! I only have enough room to work safely with hand tools for the next few months. at least that is easiest. i need to learn some good hand tool skills. after all the power could go out and i have nothing to do but cut wood :)

there is a short list of things i need to make by hand and near the top is a saw bench. probably the one that this guy stumpy nubbs has on you tube.

it probably right after i master sharpening my chisels and planes to a high quality.