New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Making Shoji

Posts

Re: Making Shoji

#2

Re: Making Shoji

TomD

Nice piece of work! Where is Kandosha with the contract. You said this was for a bathroom, is the paper, not to mention the glue, up to that?

Re: Making Shoji

#3

Re: Making Shoji

Brian Holcombe

Thanks Tom!

Should hold up fine, I have an exhaust fan to remove excess humidity in the bathroom. In either case, I figure the bathroom as a worst case scenario test pilot for residential projects.

Re: Making Shoji

#4

Ellis Walentine

Question

Ellis Walentine

This may sound like blasphemy, but I'm wondering about a simpler way to make shoji. I need to make five panels for our house and can't afford the time to make such complicated joinery.

Ellis

Re: Making Shoji

#5

Re: Question

Brian Holcombe

Howdy Ellis,

I think the double tenons are fairly critical so I would stick with them, they really make a strong joint.

The time consuming part for me is material prep, I cut the joinery at a rate of approximately two hours per panel. Wasting material between the tenons is probably the most time consuming part of the tenons.

Re: Making Shoji

#6

Clint Searl

Re: Question

Clint Searl

Assuming half-lap joints: 1. Route appropriately spaced grooves across wide boards; 2. Rip the boards into lattice width members; 3. Put 'em together...Easy as that--five in a day.

Re: Making Shoji

#7

Clint Searl

For the suggestion of, but...

Clint Searl

And if the panels don't have to be translucent:

Or for a minimalist approach that's translucent. Rice paper laminated on 1/8 acrylic.


Re: Making Shoji

#8

Won't save much time

Brian Holcombe

That's good in theory, but in practice you're making a headache by cutting the grooves for half-laps before finish planing. Also, there is a good chance they will warp when cut to size.

The half lap joinery goes by extremely fast, it's one of the fastest parts of the project.

The longest part of kumiko is preparing the kumiko which is fairly time consuming but not tedious. I cut them to basic thickness then take passes until they're right on my number. The planing finishes them while bringing to thickness.

The next step is to edge joint the kumiko, a process I do individually. Alaskan yellow cedar is very stable in use, but tends to move when cut, so they need to be jointed after cutting.

I butt the planing beam up against my stop, hold it in place with hold fasts, then use the side of my bench to joint the kumiko, followed by cutting them to exact width. The end result are straight pieces.

A lot can go wrong when cutting material to 1/4" x 1/2" x 60".

Re: Making Shoji

#9

Re: Question

TomD

Main joints can be biscuits, cut them with the big biscuit, but so the biscuit sticks out.That way you get more engagement, without affecting the looks. Last step during glue-up is to grab the B with pliers and pull so it fills the slots and the look will be like tight splines, though you can't really see it.

Next decision is to decide what "paper" you will use. Real paper is sorta a bad deal, because it has minimal structure. It was supposed to be replaced frequently so in our sealed houses it just gets dirty. One option is translucent plastic. If you go that route, you can glue the wooden pieces butt style with epoxy and the whole thing goes a lot faster. That will be an uptick on most sushi restaurants.

Re: Making Shoji

#10

Re: Won't save much time

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I think that for a guy who doesn't do much hand work this stuff does take a lot of time.

About five years ago I was chatting with a fellow woodworker who had just made a new set of sash for a historic house. He told me quite a bit of how he made the stuff. Making this jig or that jig took "no time at all". Setting up this machine for this operation etc was "a snap". After hearing five minutes of all his time saving methods I asked what he charged. It was more than double what I charged for the same work by hand. It could be that he actually made the sash faster than I would and that his hourly rate was just that much higher. However I got the idea that his shop was at least 20 times as large as mine, his tool costs probably a much higher multiple yet. Somebody has to pay for all this crap.

I'm sure the guy had the skill to make the sash by hand, albeit slowly. But getting a sash saw ready to make a cut is very much faster than "no time at all", Taking a chisel out of the box doesn't take but a tiny fraction of "a snap". With hand work there is a lot less fiddling around; you make your cuts and move on.

Re: Making Shoji

#11

Re: Won't save much time

Brian Holcombe

Thanks Warren! In chatting with a Japanese Tea House carpenter who apprenticed under another Japanese Tea House carpenter living and working in America he told me that the fellow did all joinery by hand and finished every surface by hand plane.

In doing so he could setup and cut the joinery for seven shoji panels before lunch. That may seem like a farce to anyone who needs to setup a table saw for every cut, but I can see how it is feasible, especially with an experienced maker who is not wasting time.

It is exhausting how many times people suggest using machine tools to me. I've yet to see where they are truly faster in joinery work.

I'm sure they are faster for production work, which is why they're used for it, but I'm not doing anything near production work so a 'run' for me is a few pieces or in this case a few panels.

Take the double tenon as an example, with jaguchi (mitered shoulder edge):

If one wants to break down the operations to machinable tasks that means setting up a saw for four separate cuts (and test cutting for each) to make the tenons. Followed by setting up a mortising machine to remove the waste between the two tenons, or cutting it out with 2-3 additional cuts on a table saw.

Then setting up a crosscut saw for the back, then setting up a tablesaw for the jaguchi.....and making certain that the shoulders all line up....which requires more test cutting.

I'll be long finished with those cuts by the time this all comes together.

Re: Making Shoji

#12

Power tool alternative

Jim Matthews

I researched the same when building sliding doors for our unheated "Florida room". While I prefer Brian's approach, which has centuries of refinements bolstering it, I kept my link to a method that uses simpler joinery with a router and laminations.

Note that either method will require stable, straight grained stock to keep the panels planar.

http://www.instructables.com/id/Shoji-Screen-Closet-Doors/

Re: Making Shoji

#13

Re: Won't save much time

Hank Knight

I think most of us (probably all of us, if we're honest about it) who have developed a reasonable familarity and proficiency with hand tools have found that hand tools are much more efficient for one-off or small batch joinery than machinery, not to mention the fact that there are some joints you just can't make with standard woodworking machines.

Re: Making Shoji

#14

Re: Won't save much time

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I agree, Hank, that there are many instances when hand work is more efficient for small batches and machine work for quantity. For instance it makes a great difference whether one is making four feet of moulding or 4000 feet. Making four tenons is faster by hand, 400 is faster by machine.

In the case of sash making that I mentioned above, though, the machine guy was making sash for a whole house, twenty four windows or so. His price for making them by machine was higher per unit than mine made by hand.