Re: Making a New Handle - Japanese chisels
TomD
"The handles with centered core always feel differently to me than sections of straight grained material in use.
I don't have scientific evidence but they seem to further emphasize a dead-blow effect."
In golf there has been a lot of this kind of talk over the years, particularly relative to putters. People talk about the feel of steel that has been cast, vs. forged, and more recently of the feel of heads that have plastic inserts in the hitting surface. It turned out to be a little off mark, it turned out the thing that was being sensed was sound. That sound gave a better sense of "feel" and control. If golfers couldn't hear the putters they had little ability to tell them apart. I have one plastic dead blow hammer that is perfect for adjusting planes. These fancy brass or wood insert hammers come out, nothing has the feel of my plastic hammer. Of course, whatever it is, they were relying on it. Sound or feedback is not the key benefit of urethane. Well low decibel sound is.
As far as dead blow, to me that is variable with material worked. I like a heavy push for hardwoods, and a sharper blow for softwoods. I'm not saying there is some huge difference, but the duration vs velocity of objects does have an effect on penetration. There is often a threshold effect. But I have no idea what any of that would work out to, it probably does affect what hammer is in my hand at a given time.
"I've always assumed using pith centered posts was a matter of practicality more-so than aesthetic (though I do enjoy the aesthetic)."
In buildings like temples, aesthetics is practicality. I don't think the low cost bid was the issue.
Heart centered posts are also more split resistant, or the split can be controlled. You get yields from smaller logs or the size you need at all, given the max size is the log. As you say the practical is there also.