New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Making a New Handle - Japanese chisels

Posts

Re: Making a New Handle - Japanese chisels

#2

Re: Making a New Handle - Japanese chisels

TomD

First congratulations. I tried this when I was a lot younger than today, and got it about 98% right, the wrong part being a slight visible crack between the socket and the chisel shoulder. So I took it apart and that was that.

I have to say though, since that time I am far less appreciative of exotic handles. The final straw for me was that I went to a very well equipped store and had fallen in love with a set of boxwood handled thin push chisels. What I found as I examined set after set, in several different woods, was that the best set by far, and these were full weight push chisels to boot (the thins looked like something that would function just as well if made of 1/8" O1), were a set in white oak. The fancy chisels had at least 3 misaligned chisels per set. The white oaks were dead straight. I later coined the obscure term "tourist grade" to designate chisels made with the care these makers seem to think these chisels in exotic wood, or with sharkskin handles deserve.

Straw one was when I completed my fancy Oucii set in Mac Ebony, purchased in the early 80s, with the missing sizes for a set of 15, at the time only available in white oak,my least favorite wood by far. And they were way better. The same is true of plane blocks made in ebony vs white oak. ATMO.

Re: Making a New Handle - Japanese chisels

#3

Re: Making a New Handle - Japanese chisels

Brian Holcombe

Thanks Tom, using Japanese tools has certainly earned me an appreciation of appropriate choice of wood for handles. The rosewood, while beautiful, wears rapidly and makes a sharper sound when struck with a hammer.

I've recently started wearing hearing protection when chopping and it has increased my sensitivity of what is going on when the hammer strikes the chisel. I have gained a much better understanding of dead blow effect that happens when a good hammer and hammer handle are combined with a sharp chisel and appropriate handle. That effect is improved by the gumi (or goumi) handles over the rosewood.

My tool set is hopefully starting to look like something you could take to work as a temple builder in Japan without much ridicule.

Re: Making a New Handle - Japanese chisels

#4

Re: Making a New Handle - Japanese chisels

Roy Girolami

Brian, I have never re-handled a Japanese chisel but I have an observation about the ones I have. Back in the '80's I got interested in Japanese tools and bought a few chisels. I got some from the Japan Woodworker with what they called boxwood handles. I looked at these today and all of them show the pith in the end of the handle. They are Yoshitora brand and include temple carpenter chisels, a bench chisel and a mortise chisel. I don't know if the wood is gouge or boxwood, but none of the handles have ever split.

Roy Girolami

Re: Making a New Handle - Japanese chisels

#5

Re: Making a New Handle - Japanese chisels

William Duffield

We had the opportunity to handle John's new goumi chisel handle yesterday evening, and it looks like a very useful wood species.

John's original thread, showing the making of the handle from Elaeagrus multiflora, is here:

http://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/handtools.pl?pro=search;pmd=sread;srchid=7538SK5u95sWD4vguLZ1476992018;spage=1;sanc=481583;sbid=3000;md=read;id=481583#m_481583

I wandered out to my field this afternoon to examine my Elaeagrus bushes, hoping they were natsugumi, but I was disappointed. They are all E. umbellata, the invasive Autumn Olive, but I strongly suspected that. I may try turning a branch anyhow, just to test its properties. Some of the branches are 2-1/2" or more in diameter, which should be more than sufficient for a chisel handle. So, back to the field with my branch loppers and Silky saw.

I think choosing a branch with centered pith makes sense. All the natural splitting planes would be radial, and thus most effectively counteracted by the ferrule and hoop. There would be much less tendency to split off a segment from the side, where the compression of the metal bands would be less effective.

Re: Making a New Handle - Japanese chisels

#6

Re: Making a New Handle - Japanese chisels

Brian Holcombe

Good to know, I understand the goumi handles hold up very well and the ones I have (aside from those just made) have not worn much at all.

Re: Making a New Handle - Japanese chisels

#7

Re: Making a New Handle - Japanese chisels

Brian Holcombe

John mentioned to me that they may actually trim these plants so that their growth shoots straight up, and then you have nice straight runs to use for handles.

I'm curious to see how that olive looks when turned.

Re: Making a New Handle - Japanese chisels

#8

Re: Making a New Handle - Japanese chisels

TomD

That would be dirty looking white oak I think. I share your concern about noise, and what I did, which was tough on me at some silly level, was shift from laminated Japanese hammers to urethane plastic carving hammers. I found the 20 oz easily and was eventually able to add a 30 ounch which sees little use, but is well worth having.

I really liked my Japanese hammers, and have never liked the carver's mallet look, but the noise and dead blow effect are really good. If you get a mallet you won't need to change the handle material. Or whatever you decide you want with be great. I got one of those bronze carver's mallets. I like bronze, but hate mallets, it was a trade-off. First time I tapped an Ouchii ebony chisel with it, a large spall of ebony came off. This after 20 years of mashing with the metal hammers and urethane. Back to the store with that.

Another "advantage" with the urethane mallets is one doesn't need to prep the handles.

Re: Making a New Handle - Japanese chisels

#9

Re: Making a New Handle - Japanese chisels

TomD

I have all grades of Japanese chisels, and none of the handles have ever split environmentally, the only bad thing that happened was the ebony thing I mentioned. The white oak handles are also heart centered in better models. This is also a look thing. They just look better in the Japanese aesthetic where harmony in grain patterns is emphasized. It is how they do some posts.

Re: Making a New Handle - Japanese chisels

#10

Re: Making a New Handle - Japanese chisels

Brian Holcombe

The handles with centered core always feel differently to me than sections of straight grained material in use.

I don't have scientific evidence but they seem to further emphasize a dead-blow effect.

I've always assumed using pith centered posts was a matter of practicality more-so than aesthetic (though I do enjoy the aesthetic).

Re: Making a New Handle - Japanese chisels

#11

Re: Making a New Handle - bronze hammer bad?

Rum

That's an interesting observation. Any idea on why the bronze mallet would have caused more issues with making the wood split than iron?

Re: Making a New Handle - Japanese chisels

#12

Re: Making a New Handle - bronze hammer bad?

TomD

I don't think the material mattered. The hammers I was using were Japanese style like mini sledges. One end is plat, for hitting rounded things, and the other is rounded for hitting flat things. As well as other uses. The impact is much flatter, because either surface is nearly flat, so the weight is distributed. With the brass hammer the head is small and tight radiused, compared to wooden carving mallet (not a hammer). So it kinda split the chisel, it is like putting a ball bearing on the end grain, and hitting the bearing into the chisel with a hammer. But I figured it was designed for that so must be good, was all the rage at the time. In fairness the use was carving which may not be as titanic as hitting things for mortising. The Japanese style is pretty forceful not messing around.

With a urethane mallet it is a larger object, soft, so it gives a good dead blow, and is quiet.

Re: Making a New Handle - Japanese chisels

#13

Re: Making a New Handle - bronze hammer bad?

rum

Ah, that makes a lot of sense, thanks for the follow up. I was a bit stumped on why the material would matter given the choices :)

I kind of like the urethane ones as well, but wouldn't mind a nice rawhide one with a bit of lead in it (although i suspect that will be made not found).

Re: Making a New Handle - Japanese chisels

#14

Re: Making a New Handle - Japanese chisels

TomD

"The handles with centered core always feel differently to me than sections of straight grained material in use.

I don't have scientific evidence but they seem to further emphasize a dead-blow effect."

In golf there has been a lot of this kind of talk over the years, particularly relative to putters. People talk about the feel of steel that has been cast, vs. forged, and more recently of the feel of heads that have plastic inserts in the hitting surface. It turned out to be a little off mark, it turned out the thing that was being sensed was sound. That sound gave a better sense of "feel" and control. If golfers couldn't hear the putters they had little ability to tell them apart. I have one plastic dead blow hammer that is perfect for adjusting planes. These fancy brass or wood insert hammers come out, nothing has the feel of my plastic hammer. Of course, whatever it is, they were relying on it. Sound or feedback is not the key benefit of urethane. Well low decibel sound is.

As far as dead blow, to me that is variable with material worked. I like a heavy push for hardwoods, and a sharper blow for softwoods. I'm not saying there is some huge difference, but the duration vs velocity of objects does have an effect on penetration. There is often a threshold effect. But I have no idea what any of that would work out to, it probably does affect what hammer is in my hand at a given time.

"I've always assumed using pith centered posts was a matter of practicality more-so than aesthetic (though I do enjoy the aesthetic)."

In buildings like temples, aesthetics is practicality. I don't think the low cost bid was the issue. :) Heart centered posts are also more split resistant, or the split can be controlled. You get yields from smaller logs or the size you need at all, given the max size is the log. As you say the practical is there also.

Re: Making a New Handle - Japanese chisels

#15

Re: Making a New Handle - bronze hammer bad?

TomD

There are lots of rawhide hammers out there. Often leather stores have them. There was an idea at one time that Beryllium hammers were a magic deal for driving nails. The metal is super toxic, and I did grind some at one point, can't recall if I did it outside. It may be they were just mixing up the fact they don't spark in environments where that can be a career ender.

Shot and rawhide, I don't know how that would work, probably fine. I don't want the push over too long a period, but until one tries it...

http://www.ebay.com/itm/Garland-No-5-Rawhide-Mallet-Dead-Blow-Hammer-w-Leather-Tools-Lot-/152285841843?hash=item2374f189b3:g:DbQAAOSw-CpYBloQ

Re: Making a New Handle - Japanese chisels

#16

Re: Making a New Handle - bronze hammer bad?

rum

Yeah I have a couple of the leather working ones. They're a bit light for most chisel work though (really detailed stuff.. perhaps.. but I don't really use a mallet for those parts much anyway). They do have a bit of a deadblow effect though which is what got me thinking about adding a bit of weight and seeing how it would go.

Ideally I think you'd wrap the wet rawhide around the weight and then let it dry shrinking it in place.. hence the "need to make it". I suppose you could soak one and unravel it probably (depending on the glue used).