New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

hollow grind diameters

Posts

hollow grind diameters

#1

hollow grind diameters

Howard Pollack

I have 3 grinders, a 6" high speed cheapo, an 8" hand crank, and an old Wards 10" with a wet natural stone of some sort. I wonder which diameter is most useful for hollow grinds on chisels and plane blades. I'd appreciate your thoughts. Thanks. -Howard

Re: hollow grind diameters

#2

Re: hollow grind diameters

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have a 7" and that is what I use because that is what I have. Works for me. I don't think it matters much. The particle size and bond of the rock is greatly more important than the wheel diameter.

Re: hollow grind diameters

#3

Agree

John in NM

Wheel selection is probably the most important factor. Learning to use the grinder one has, through selecting a good wheel and learning not to burn an edge, will pay off more than which grinder one uses.

The hand crank can be useful for polishing an edge - I have one for that with a hard felt wheel. I use it when I need a super sharp edge (makes scary sharp look dull) like for hand planing difficult woods - such as bookmatched mesquite. The edge does not last long as it is somewhat convex, but it is easily renewed in a flash.

Re: hollow grind diameters

#4

Re: hollow grind diameters

Steve Elliott

I've used diameters from 6" to 10" and prefer something in the 7 to 8 inch range. The hollow lasts longer than the one from a 10" wheel but doesn't seem too deep like one from a 6" wheel.

Re: hollow grind diameters

#5

Re: hollow grind diameters

david weaver

Whatever one you like to use. I've had 8 and 10 inch wet grinders and a 6 inch dry grinder.

If you're sharpening on both sides of the hollow, the hollow lasts longer on a 6 inch grinder, and it's easy to notice.

If you sharpen a primary and then lift the tool a little to create a steeper microbevel, then it doesn't make any practical difference.

No difference in edge durability, either.

Re: hollow grind diameters

#6

Re: hollow grind diameters

TomD

I prefer larger wheels because they reduce the bevel less, though you will regrind a little more often.

You should understand that 6 inch grinders at 3600 exist to grind predominately high speed steel tool bits for lathes and milling machines, etc... Or at least that was the idea back in the day, that segment moves on quickly. But it isn't as though the 6" is most common and that is standard for our work, then the 8" and the, 10" are a little more specialized. No, none of these exist for the hand tool woodworking segment at all, that is why the stones are so important, because they weren't designed for us either, and need to be switched out. The size that does exist for these tools is more like 20 inches, but that isn't common.

The 6 inch diameter exists because it clearances for the tiny bits and small spindle sizes most commonly used. You virtually burn the steel off so that is why the stones are so hard, and the speed is so high.

So yeah, use what you like and all that, one kludge is as good as another. I like my 8 inch 1800 rpm well, and find it works fine. belts work better. None of this stuff is intended for us.

I am not as enamored of the soft bond stones as I used to be since they throw up a lot of very bad dust. The hard bond stones are fine if you know how to grind. They are a little slower, but at these speeds it doesn't mater much to me.

If you go larger and run at high speeds, be aware you have let a bigger wolf loose in the shop. Google photos of grinder accidents every so often to keep focused. So far Sawstop hasn't made these things safe for the children.

Re: hollow grind diameters

#7

Re: hollow grind diameters- thanks

Howard Pollack

Thanks everyone.

-Howard

Re: hollow grind diameters

#8

Trade - 8" or 10 "

Andrew F in Australia

Hi Howard,

Coming in late here.

Most trade shops use an 8" or a 10" grinder - bear in mind that as you dress it, it ends up becoming up to 2" smaller in diameter, so it's not an exact science.

There's all this comment about slow speed and high speed grinders. We use high speed grinders as a data point. No matter which one you choose, it boils down to technique. Pretend you're just trying to shave the surface of the stone with the chisel/blade, stop regularly to cool down and it doesn't matter.

Just dress the wheel regularly (every 10-20 tools or so) to prevent burning, especially if it's a grey stone, the white and pink wheels tend to be a bit more forgiving.

Regards,

Andrew F

Re: hollow grind diameters

#9

CBN

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Howard, first of all my preference is 8", for the same reasons as Steve - it is a good compromise of depth and longevity. I have a 8" dry grinder and a 10" Tormek (now about 8"). When the Tormek was full size the hollow created could be removed completely very quickly.

More relevantly, look into a CBN wheel for a dry grinder. It will last forever (or decades at the least), never require dressing (which means it stays the same size and does not go out of setting), and grinds cool and smooth.

I wrote of my journey here: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/WoodworkTechniques/UltimateGrindingSharpeningSetUp.html

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: hollow grind diameters

#10

Re: CBN

Howard Pollack

Derek- The 8" grinder is a hand grinder, would you use a cbn wheel on that? Not much chance of burning tools on it, but I guess the cbn wheel would stay true and be clean... Thanks.

=Howard

Re: hollow grind diameters

#11

Re: CBN

TomD

As far as replacement wheels and a wheel balancer are concerned I probably spent the cost of one of those wheels.