New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Turned handle of Elaeagnus multiflora... *LINK*

Posts

Turned handle of Elaeagnus multiflora... *LINK*

#1

Turned handle of Elaeagnus multiflora... *LINK*

John Aniano in Central NJ

Hi All,

Spent a bit of time the other day investigating a wood specie I was unfamiliar with, and wound up with a nice chisel handle in the process.

In private communications with Brian Holcombe on his descriptions of making a new genno hammer handle, he mentioned a wood called “gumi” which Brian said:

“Gumi is short for Natsugumi, its genus Elaeagnus multiflora. It’s also known as the silverberry tree. It’s very similar to boxwood but not exactly the same, it’s ‘the’ handle material for chisels, meaning it is the most prized, but not used for planes.”

My wife and I have a fruiting shrub in the backyard called a “sweet scarlet goumi” – I wondered if it was the same plant, which it was. Back in 2012 and 2013, I pruned a few large branches/trunks off our ~15 year old goumi bush, noted that the wood was hard and creamy colored, so, for curiosity sake, I had ripped the sections in half to facilitate drying, sealed the ends and then promptly forgot them…

After speaking with Brian, I looked back through my pile of wood scraps, found the goumi pieces and quickly noticed that some had spalted, primarily from the ends. Looked a bit like the bluish splotching that occurs in American holly but was brown streaks in the goumi. Two larger pieces had no splotching, so I gave one to Brian and kept the other. I have no idea what time during the year I cut these – in the future, I’ll have to take more care to prevent spalting by harvesting at the proper time and maybe with a spray of bleach before sealing the ends for drying. (Any tips or suggestions on this topic would be appreciated!)

As Brian had indicated, the non-spalted goumi looked remarkably like boxwood. It planed easily and left a nice finish. The growth rings were more widely spaced than is typical in boxwood since the latter is very slow growing by comparison to the goumi.

So, I made a traditional English turned/octagonal handle one might see on a tanged chisel. I know this is the hand tools side of things, but here goes anyway…

I used a brass 5/8” hex compression nut for the ferrule. I located the center points on the goumi blank and turned a short ~3/4” diam tenon at the butt end to hold the piece in a Beale ER collet. I used my South Bend metal lathe and it’s usual tool bit setup for the ferrule fitting portion of the turning shown here.


I turned the ferrule mounting tenon to ~0.025” over the ID of the threaded brass nut. Using a crescent wrench, I threaded the nut onto the tenon making sure there was no binding.


Then I mixed up some 5-minute epoxy, slathered it on both surfaces and used the wrench to fully seat the nut to the goumi blank.


After lunch, I set the blank back in the lathe, and using the compound rest, turned the hex facets off the brass nut forming a round ferrule. (This is easier to do in a metal lathe than by hand in a wood lathe.)


Then I set up a small hand turning rest and continued with regular lathe tools (gouges, skew and 3-point tool) to shape the handle. The wood was then sanded with 120 and 220 grit paper; the brass was sanded to 600 grit.


Off the lathe, I held the handle in my workbench leg vise and using a low angle block plane, planed off the facets to make a nice, slightly tapered octagon. Used 45 and 90 degree squares & calipers to ensure the facets were centered and tapered (0.5mm) as I wished. Then I cut off the waste and trued up the butt end.



In the images above, the larger of the two is the new goumi handle. The smaller is a commercial English handle of boxwood. See that the growth rings are much tighter on the boxwood vs. the goumi.

All in all, the wood worked very much like a slightly softer boxwood. I was able to dent the goumi with a boxwood piece, not the other way around, so seasoned boxwood is harder than the goumi I had harvested.

Elaeagnus angustifolia or Russian Olive, and Elaeagnus umbellate or Autumn Olive are both invasive plants here in central NJ. They have tasty reddish orange fruits that ripen in the late Fall and are in the same family as the goumi Elaeagnus multiflora wood I had turned. Perhaps, harvesting the wood of these invasive species might be able to “make lemonade out of lemons”. I’ll have to harvest some of these shrubs this Fall when their leaves have dropped.

Over and out.


Elaeagnus species overview

Re: Turned handle of Elaeagnus multiflora... *LINK*

#2

avoiding the blue (or brown)

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Indeed a nice handle and a thorough description of the process. I appreciate the time you took to compile it.

"I had ripped the sections in half to facilitate drying, sealed the ends and then promptly forgot them… "

The forgetting part could be the source of the discoloration. Ripping into "boards" would have been helpful too. The secret to keeping these easily stained species white is to get them dry as quick as possible. The bark must come off and I would not advise sealing the ends unless drying thick pieces. Lumber can loose moisture out the ends up to 10 times faster than out the sides so preventing this avenue of escape slows drying. Lots a free air circulation is essential during the initial stages of drying.

Modern lumber manufacturers dip green lumber in fungicide. I have not tried it but a dip in some garden or orchard fungicide spray could prevent mold staining.

That said, staining by mold has no significant affect on a chisel handle. The discoloration will soon be overcast by hand grunge on a user chisel, unless one remembers to wash your hands before woodworking.

Because I was lazy I turned round, mildly barrel shaped, handles for the chisels I made. I have come to prefer this shape. It is comfy in the hand and the diameter of the barrel can be matched to the size of the chisel, with bigger handles on bigger chisels.

For those that don't have this bush, dogwood seems to be as good as it gets for chisel handles in my hands.

Re: Turned handle of Elaeagnus multiflora... *LINK*

#3

Re: avoiding blue (or brown) stains when drying...

John Aniano in Central NJ

Hi Bill,

Thanks for the suggestions regarding quickly drying this wood. I always assumed one wanted to have the wood dry slowly. I'm always learning new things, thanks.

These goumi "trees" are really just large bushes, so there are few large diameter logs. At best, there might be some 4" or 5" diameter branches or trunks. Simply halving or quartering them should suffice. I'll look into some possible fungicides that might work, but your rapid drying suggestion might be the best solution.

As for the handle shape, I, too, often do an elongated oval, but one with an especially nice neck that merges into the ferrule. My example is from a "Shaw - cast steel" firmer gouge - one of the first antique tools I ever bought nearly 40 years ago. However, practically speaking, handles with flats like this octagonal example, won't roll off the workbench. The fully round turned handles always seem to take a trip to the floor...

John

Re: Turned handle of Elaeagnus multiflora... *LINK*

#4

quick but not too quick

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

4/4 poplar can be, and is, kiln dried right off the saw in 5 days if the drying conditions are carefully controlled. I offer this example to help calibrate fast drying, in this case of a species that gives up its water readily. Oak will not survive such a rapid drying schedule without fracturing, in contrast. But even oak can go from the saw to 7% in 30 days or less.

Having no experience with this wood I can't speculate how fast it can be dried. But any wood will survive drying where the temperature is not greater than about 90 degrees, typical humidity of a non-desert climate, and free air circulation on all sides. It is critical to get the bark removed from split limbs and good air circulation is a must.

Drying half a limb is challenging. The half round will want to split into something approximating a quarter round. As pieces dry watch them closely. If checking on the outside begins, slow the drying. Checking of the center is normal and usually can not be prevented. The center is juvenile wood and it shrinks so much it usually fractures no matter the drying.

Before I left for vacation I set out some 4/4 cherry shorts to dry indoors, about 80 degrees, 50% humidity and good air circulation on all sides. These pieces are were air dried about as much as they were going to be in 4 weeks. There was no checking.

Re: Turned handle of Elaeagnus multiflora... *LINK*

#5

Coralling chisels

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Corralling chisels on the bench is facilitated by this rack I built some years ago. I haven't ever had one roll off the bench in any case.


Re: Turned handle of Elaeagnus multiflora... *LINK*

#6

Re: Turned handle of Elaeagnus multiflora...

Brian Holcombe

John,

Beautiful work, that handle is really spectacular! It was my pleasure meeting you in person and thank you for your generosity.

Also, sorry that I managed to miss this post for a few days now.

Here are a few photos of a handle, in Japanese gumi. The gouge is made by Hidari Konobu.



Here the center of the branch shows in the handle, this is considered the most ideal orientation in Japanese chisel handles.


Re: Turned handle of Elaeagnus multiflora... *LINK*

#7

Re: Turned handle of Elaeagnus multiflora...

Warren in Lancaster, PA

There are a number of small trees and large shrubs which yield interesting wood in small pieces. A few genera come to mind: Viburnum, Kalmia, Rhamnus, Cornus, Amelanchier,Oxydendron, Syringa, evenRhus.

I have used a number of timbers for chisel handles, but have settled on beech as my favorite.

Re: Turned handle of Elaeagnus multiflora... *LINK*

#8

question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Curious about your beech preference. I don't have much experience with beech. I have only used it for making some kitchen "tools"- stirrers, scrapers and the like- and some turned trinkets. It holds up well for something that gets wet or even washed.

I used dogwood for chisel handles based on my experience using dogwood wedges for wood splitting. One can pound the daylights out of them with a 10 pound sledge hammer. In this application it holds up better than beech which tends to split under this abuse.

Dogwood was historically used for shuttle cocks, I am told. Hence, it seemed a good choice for impact resistance and split resistance. I find dogwood a dream to turn. Small (about 2 +/- inches) stems and branches will dry whole without splitting, a significant advantage. However, one would need to live where it grows for it to be a practical choice. Beech seems to grow everywhere.

I suspect in reality that a well cared for chisel handle could be made from about anything. I have a mortise chisel with a walnut handle that is doing fine.

Re: Turned handle of Elaeagnus multiflora... *LINK*

#9

Re: Dogwood anthracnose

Hank Knight

I agree that dogwood makes excellent chisel handles as well as mallets and just about anything else that is subject to striking abuse. Ordinarily, dogwood has a pretty bland appearance. It starts out almost white and ages to a light cream or tan color with very little in the way of interesting grain features. Dogwood anthracnose, a disease caused by the fungus Discula destructiva, has devastated the dogwood forests in the East. Columbia, SC, my hometown, had many beautiful dogwoods 20 years ago. 50% or more of those trees have fallen to anthracnose and many more are suffering from it and will eventually die. Interestingly, the disease stains the heartwood of the tree a deep reddish brown. The stain makes for interesting turnings as it provides some striking, random coloration through the wood. Here is a mallet I turned from a dogwood trunk that died from the disease in my yard:

[URL=http://s50.photobucket.com/user/hankknight/media/DogwoodMallet-3.jpg.html][/URL]

[URL=http://s50.photobucket.com/user/hankknight/media/DogwoodMallet_1A.jpg.html][/URL]

The disease doesn't seem to affect the durability of the wood. I've pounded a lot of things with that mallet and it still looks pretty good.

Re: Turned handle of Elaeagnus multiflora... *LINK*

#10

Re: question

Warren in Lancaster, PA

The thing I like about a beech handle is the feel when it is struck. It absorbs shock, but is not spongy. Firm, but not jarring. I like it better than having a leather washer at the bolster. Woods like hard maple, boxwood and dogwood tend to transmit the shock to the user's body. It is not a big difference, just the kind of thing one notices when hitting chisels all day long. In a similar way a wood floor is not as tiring as concrete, but for short periods it doesn't really matter.

Re: Turned handle of Elaeagnus multiflora... *LINK*

#11

Re: question

Hank Knight

Hi, Warren,

I think the answer to your question is a matter of personal preference. I have one of those "Wood Is Good" polyurethane mallets. The big marketing point for those is that the polyurethane head has some give and deadens the blow. Supposedly it is better for you because it doesn't transmit all of the shock of the strike back to your arm and elbow. I never liked the thing. I much prefer the feedback I get from the sharp rap of a wooden mallet or a steel hammer on a hooped chisel. I can't recall ever using a beech mallet, so I can't offer you a comparison. Dogwood is very hard and certainly gives you a lot of feedback when you strike something with it. That has never bothered me. My current favorite mallet is one of those acrylic infused maple ones sold by Blue Spruce Toolworks. If anything, it's harder and less shock absorbant than dogwood. I love it. I have used it for long hours at a time with no adverse effects. Others' mileage may differ. It's all in what you like.

Hank

Re: Turned handle of Elaeagnus multiflora... *LINK*

#12

P.S.

Hank Knight

I was thinking mallets, not chisel handles, in my post above; but I think my reply applies to chisel handles as well as to mallets.

Re: Turned handle of Elaeagnus multiflora... *LINK*

#13

Replaced rosewood with Goumi today

Brian Holcombe

One of my rosewood handles finally gave up the ghost. The wood is beautiful but is truly horrible for a striking chisel handle.

I replaced it with some of the Goumi that John gave me.



Some of the bark is retained on this handle which was shaped with planes, chisels, knives and spoke shaves.

In a chisel this size it takes a good hit to chop, and I've had the experience of chopping to the point where the rosewood finally failed, removing it, replacing it and going back to work chopping and the Goumi is a significant improvement both in how it feels to chop with and how effective the chopping is.

My hammer handle improvements have been sniffing out the weak link, which was the rosewood handle.

Re: Turned handle of Elaeagnus multiflora... *LINK*

#14

Re: Replaced rosewood with Goumi today

John Aniano in Central NJ

Hi Brian and Hank,

First, nice job on the new handle Brian; glad I could have helped in some small way!

Hank, I'd love it if there was some sort of anthracnose that might get rid of or control the Russian olive plants that are taking over the un-mown fields in my area of NJ. In just a few years, they have taken hold on the landscape.

I scouted out several larger ones on the edges of my 2 acre field today. I'll mark them with some orange tape so I can harvest them in the winter. There are some Bradford pear tree seedlings as well, and when small and without leaves, would be somewhat hard to distinguish from the Russian olive. So, in a few months, I'll have a good supply of this material...

John

Re: Turned handle of Elaeagnus multiflora... *LINK*

#15

Re: question

William Duffield

Another reason for using Cornus for shuttles is that it takes a high polish and individual wood fibers don't separate or split out, which means it won't "pick" the threads being woven.

I've made mallets and chisel handles from many different woods, including dogwood, hard maple, red oak, bloodwood, purpleheart, cocobolo, black locust, live oak, bitter orange, and a few others. My favorite for chisel handles is the Maine ironwood or hornbeam Lie-Nielsen uses in their chisel handles. For mallets, I prefer hophornbeam. I cannot recommend red oak or black locust. For hammers and axes, I prefer air dried hickory.

Re: Turned handle of Elaeagnus multiflora... *LINK*

#16

Re: Replaced rosewood with Goumi today

William Duffield

If the damage done to Bradford pears by ice storms is any indication, I think they would split too easily to be a good choice for striking tools.

Re: Turned handle of Elaeagnus multiflora... *LINK*

#17

Re: question

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have used dogwood and persimmon for mallets for almost 40 years. I don't know why you would disparage beech chisel handles if you have never tried them.

Re: Turned handle of Elaeagnus multiflora... *LINK*

#18

Re: Replaced rosewood with Goumi today

MHank Knight

John, I can send you some kudzu. It will overwhelm the Russian olive in no time. :D

Re: Turned handle of Elaeagnus multiflora... *LINK*

#19

Re: question

MHank Knight

Warren,

I dont think I disparaged beech as a chisel handle material. I certainly didn't intend to. I was merely sharing my preference for handles that provide a crisp feedback when struck. Beech may or may not fit this description, I just don't know, having never tried it.

Hank