New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Soapstone as a sharpening stone?

Posts

Soapstone as a sharpening stone?

#1

Soapstone as a sharpening stone?

John O'Connell

I got a beat up slate colored stone with a bunch of tools at a sale. It was obviously used as a sharpening surface and was badly nicked out and hollowed. I just got around to flattening it with sandpaper on a marble base and the process yielded a grey fine powder dust which makes me think this material will be useless in sharpening carving knives and chisels which need to be razor sharp. A challenge for me in itself. Should I put this stone to use or carve it or something?

Re: Soapstone as a sharpening stone?

#2

Re: Soapstone as a sharpening stone?

TomD

What is the downside to using it? Was it oily, or did you think it was a water stone, which sounds right. Fire it up and give it a go. Take a simple and razor sharp blade and run it over it and see what happens. If it stays exactly as sharp, but it has a nice deposit of metal then it cuts. If it dulls the blade down, you can tell where it fits in the overall scheme of things. if it reduces the edge quickly then it cuts also.

Re: Soapstone as a sharpening stone?

#3

Re: Soapstone as a sharpening stone?

John in NM

Are you sure it's soapstone? They are extremely soft, and I would have guessed pretty useless for sharpening. Might make a decent strop though.

Re: Soapstone as a sharpening stone?

#4

Likely  a soft bond sharpening stone

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I think one would have observed the same result with a traditional water stone. The hardness/toughness of the bond can disguise the hardness of the abrasive particle. With the description provided it is impossible to tell what the stone is and hence, what it is good for.

If the motivation is to rescue previously used stones then one could simply try the stone in various applications to see what it is good for. Speculation is futile.

If the motivation is to obtain a stone optimum for this or that application then buying a new one of known provenance would seem a better path.

Re: Soapstone as a sharpening stone?

#5

Re: Soapstone as a sharpening stone?

david weaver

Are you in the US? There were a lot of substandard and fairly coarse slates that were put into sharpening duty in the past. They do make a decent stone ahead of something like a very fine stone if they are hard enough.

Re: Soapstone as a sharpening stone?

#6

Not if it's soapstone

John in NM

Soapstone is a schist of talc, which is the softest mineral and not even remotely abrasive. Conclusion is that this is either not soapstone or it was used with a mild abrasive charge as a strop (though that seems less likely than the first option).

There are other stones that could be mistaken for soapstone, it is likely one of those - though offhand I can't think of one that would make a decent whetstone.

Re: Soapstone as a sharpening stone?

#7

Re: Not if it's soapstone

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

We don't have a very quantitative description of this rock to provide any idea what it could be. I have some very soft abrasive stones that are easily shaped and misshaped, yet the stone contains hard particles that cut aggressively. They aren't very good for sharpening pointy things that will groove them but they cut knives quickly.