New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Repair of a R. Sorby handsaw...

Posts

Repair of a R. Sorby handsaw...

#1

Repair of a R. Sorby handsaw...

John Aniano in Central NJ

Hello All,

A few weeks ago I visited my local flea market in central NJ. As I was rounding the last aisle and was about to head back to the car I spotted a few handsaws on a dealer's bench. A quick look showed that one of them was really nice, a 26" Robert Sorby (ca. 1870 - 80 according to Simon Barley's wonderful book on British saws). There is an imprint of "CAST STEEL" on the blade, but it is faint. Still has the nib!




Has an arrised (sp?) handle - which is has an angular, peaked shaping on the top of the handle rather than the usual rounded treatment. A bit of bargaining with the dealer, and the saw was mine for $30. He told me it was old and that it was special because of the teeth. Alrighty then!

When home, I did a bit of clean up with a razor blade and some 600 grit paper and camellia oil to get rid of most of the surface rust. I chose not to remove the handle so I cleaned around it. The saw nuts were pretty buggered up - didn't dare risk it...

One of the saw nuts was MIA, so a replacement was in order. I gently pressed out the saw screw and measured the thread which was a "convenient" size of ~0.157" (~4mm) with ~22 tpi. Not having such a tap around, I made one with my South Bend lathe. (Yes, I know this is a woodworking forum, but this is a wood cutting saw I'm restoring...).

Used some W-1 water hardening steel rod, cut the 22 tpi threads in the usual manner on the lathe, tapered it like a regular hand tap and hand filed the cutting flutes with a 3-cornered saw sharpening file. Then hardened the tap with a propane torch, quenching in water and tempered it to a dark yellow color with an alcohol lamp.

Used the South Bend to turn some brass rod to the proper diameter of the saw nut recess, cut it roughly to the correct thickness with a hacksaw and hand filed the tapered sides of the saw nut. Holding the nut in a collet, I drilled out the center hole on the lathe and then, carefully, using the new tap, cut the 22 tpi threads into the saw nut. Had to clean up the existing screw's threads a bit with a fine file, but playing around a bit, got the old screw and the new nut to mate. Then held the saw nut blank in a shallow wood fixture and filed it to the correct thickness. Also created the slot using two slitting files.



Had to modify a screwdriver to fit the new nut's slot and mounted the new saw nut to the handle.


When all assembled, the drawfiled brass surface looked rather glaring, so I used some "Silver-Black" to tarnish the brass. I've yet to joint and sharpen the blade.


Over and out!

Re: Repair of a R. Sorby handsaw...

#2

Ellis Walentine

I'm sure this saga isn't over yet

Ellis Walentine

Thanks, John, for the beginning of a wonderful restoration essay. I'll look forward to seeing the next installment.

Please tell more about your decision tree as you rehab this saw.

Ellis

Re: Repair of a R. Sorby handsaw...

#3

Re: Repair of a R. Sorby handsaw...

Hank Knight

Great save, John. Looking forward to the next chapter. I think you need to bash your new saw nut a little so it matches the others. :)

Re: Repair of a R. Sorby handsaw...

#4

Great Story -- Can't wait ..

Ron in Sterling, CT

for the next chapter. As I said in the thread above, tool restoration projects can be very rewarding, especially if it is a tool which you can use

Ron

Re: Repair of a R. Sorby handsaw...

#5

Re: I'm sure this saga isn't over yet

John Aniano in Central NJ

Hello Ellis,

A decision tree, huh? I wish I had such discipline! Well, I usually try to follow the maxim of doing no harm. Or at least, as little harm as possible. If I can repair a saw by making a new saw nut, I find this preferable to replacing both the screw and the nut. If there are some small chips to the handle horns, I'll usually ignore them, unless it really interferes with use down the road. An acquaintance locally who also likes to collect handsaws goes through the trouble of stripping the handle and refinishing with multiple coats of Waterlox, replacing all parts with new, highly cleaning the blade, etc. if it brings him joy, so be it. I'd rather bring a tool back to a usable state and leave the patina for me to appreciate and for others after me to possible learn from.

Many of my regular woodworking tools still have paint splatters and wear marks/stains on the handles. Why do I have the right to remove these? If needed for use, I'll deal with this sort of stuff, but otherwise, they remain as part of the tool's history. Maybe the next owner will remove them, that is their prerogative.

I own a Kenon tenon saw and basically have done nothing to it other than applying camellia oil to the blade to prevent rust. The saw is from ca. 1790 - it is pretty rare - it is probably the oldest tool I own and I'm not about to do anything to it that might harm this little piece of history. I have plenty of other saws with less pedigree that are fine users. I keep the Kenon just for inspiration.

Two years ago I found a nearly pristine "Ward" 16" handsaw - a real cute example, again, with nib intact! Went for $20 at the Harrisburg Brown Tool Auction and tool sale because the super thin blade is violently kinked and anyone I've shown it to says it is beyond repair. So, it too, is used for inspiration. The handle is beautifully shaped and finished, you can still see the rasp marks from the maker. It was probably kinked early in its life as it shows almost no other wear. Again, all I've done is oil the blade to prevent rust.

So, that said, the Sorby is not in the same league as a Kenon so I'll most likely joint and sharpen the saw. It has crosscut teeth so this should be exciting- I've not sharpened anything but rip teeth for years so I'll have to get out my magnifying glasses and refer to my copy of Johnson's Saw Dictionary for guidance!

John