Genno Handle
Brian Holcombe
My white ash handle, was a tad short so it has now become a template. The new handle is in white oak.





Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Genno Handle
Brian Holcombe
My white ash handle, was a tad short so it has now become a template. The new handle is in white oak.





Re: Genno Handle - Design Critique
William Duffield
Very interesting, especially the offset grip. The occidental hammers and mallets I use and have made always have the grip in alignment with the center of gravity of the head. What is special about the use of the genno that makes the misalignment of the head and grip an advantage?
Since I'm left handed, actually trying yours out wouldn't provide me with any enlightenment. It is obviously optimized for use right handed. I wouldn't be able to learn anything useful even by trying out several, each with a different degree of offset.
Why did you decide to use oak instead of ash or hickory, which have better strength specs for the type of shock that a mallet handle (or baseball bat) is subjected to? I haven't swung a wooden bat since high school, but I remember that the force should be tangentially applied, so as to take advantage of the greater strength of the wood parallel to the growth rings, and thus minimize the chance that the bat will break. It looks like yours has been oriented so the force will be mostly tangential, which is an advantage, especially with oak. Or, were you shooting for rift sawn?
I see that one surface of the grip area is flattened. Is this face aligned with the flat face of the head or with the convex face? Is this done so you don't have to see the face of the head itself or the maker's mark to know which way you are holding it?
What holds the head in place without wedging the handle, or are wedges going to be installed later?
Questions and comments are intended to incite general discussion. Some more possibly pertinent images, not limited to Japanese tradition, can bee seen by searching images.google.com for "plane hammer".
Re: Genno Handle - Design Critique
Hank Knight
William,
Unless, I'm mistaken, which I often am, Brian's new genno handle doesn't appear to be "handed." It is offset fore and aft, but not port/starboard. This places the grip slightly ahead of the genno's center of gravity, not to the right or left of it; and the slightly curved design that swell's at the bottom makes for a very comfortable grip. It should function the same for righties and lefties. Apart from these ergonomic features, I don't know if there is a utilitarian reason for the design. I'd like to hear Brian's response.
Hank
Re: Genno Handle - Design Critique
Brian Holcombe
Such great questions, comments and observations! The design came by way of Stan Covington and so it is has been extensively tested. Stan worked in one of the top shoji shops in Japan.
The goal of this handle is to orient the hammer head so that the contact forces are directly down and accurately centered on a typical mortise or butt chisel handle. The overall length is determined by a blind swing, meaning that I position myself in my normal chopping stance and swing the hammer with eyes closed, the length which lands the hammer head exactly on the chisel is the proper length. It ends up being very close to the measurement from my palm to the inside of my bent elbow.
The handle is made with a curve to allow the head to land perfectly square on the chisel handle directing all force downward.
I have many straight handled hammers and this performs the absolutely outperforms them. The force applied all works to drive the chisel straight downward.
The easy test is to apply ink to the hammer face, use it and see where it marks your chisel handles and rubs off of your hammer face, both should be centered or there are forces being applied other than straight down.
I've been able to reduce the size of the genno that I use, backing down from 675g to 430g for mortising and using 350g and 225g for normal work.
In my efforts to optimize my hand mortising it has been incredibly helpful to take this approach, both lightening the work required by my arm and increasing the amount of force applied in the right direction have been positive improvements.
The handle is 'handed' it is adjusted on the right side of the back to reduce any twist that may be otherwise applied naturally in how I hold the handle. The flat back seems like it would be less comfortable but ends up being much more comfortable in use, spreading the force applied back to my hand over a wide section of my palm.
I used oak because it's a common enough choice by Japanese genno makers and a perfect sized stick was on top of the wood pile. Ash is a wonderful choice and was my prior choice. I'm curious to see the real difference between the two in use.
The best orientation is, as you mention having the flat sawn side running parallel with the forces being applied by the swing, however because the head is retained by the eye of the genno head alone, I decided to minimize the possibility of that connection loosening by choosing radial sawn wood. So it is a compromise between two different parameters of optimization.
The eye of the genno is shaped to compress the handle as it is installed retaining it without wedges. To properly function the tenon must be made oversized and tapered along the length so that it compresses as it is installed then expands once again as it exits the hammer head.
Re: Genno Handle - Design Critique
William Duffield
Brian's second photo confirms your observation. I agree, the handle is not "handed". It must be these progressive lenses that distorted my view.
Re: Genno Handle - Design Critique
William Duffield
Thanks for the very insightful answers. It always amazes me how much difference there is between Japanese and occidental woodworking techniques that have very similar results, at least in the highest quality work. I'm glad I studied physics in high school and college. It's important to the understanding of your explanation.
Do you do final shaping on the handle to fit your hand after you've installed the handle in the head?
I'm going to have to think some more about optimum growth ring orientation. I think maybe I misinterpreted your photo of the end of your handle, because the stresses should be applied to the hammer and the baseball bat in the same direction. This may be a moot point, as safety considerations have moved Little League bats from ash to Aluminum, and the Emerald ash borer has moved Big League bats to hard maple. My suspicion is that it's the pop flies and the grounders that tend to break bats, not the line drives. However, I'm far from an expert on that subject. As many statistics as are collected and analyzed on the sport of baseball, someone should know for sure.
I have a plane hammer (brass and lignum vitae) made in NH that I like, but whose handle is a bit smaller in diameter than optimum for my large hands. But its method of handle attachment is totally different than in a gennou, and it will be very difficult for me to remove the original handle. Maybe, I should just order a new head without a handle?
Re: Genno Handle - Design Critique
Brian Holcombe
You're right on the money WRT grain orientation but given that the head is held by compression I prefer to clock the grain so that the rings are running at a 45. That seems to be a common approach by most Japanese handle makers or at least the ones I wind up with as all of them that I own are done that way. If they're not then they usually pick a branch and center the pith which when sized to a tenon means that it is mostly going the wrong way.