We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
My intention with this tread is to show some of my work and briefly describe the design thoughts. I do hope others will follow...
I had some nice olive ash boards with an uncommon figure that I wanted to build a chest of. Although it would make the project much more complicated I decided for inclining sides to make it more dynamic. To keep the figure flowing from one drawer to the other was also a main criteria.
It was a difficult piece to build but drawing it first in Sketch up made it easier to get all dimensions and angels right. The chest was finished with two coats of diluted blond shellac and wax.
I think your drawer and box layout is exceptional, very nicely done there. I also think that the work is nicely done, it looks very clean and well executed.
Now for the critical parts;
- It's my feeling that both sides should be angled in, and the angles of each side slightly more steep (closer to 90)
- If we use a historical example as a basis for comparison, tapered cabinets are common in the Ming dynasty and they typically include a lighter appearing base, not so much the stretcher but the leg itself, then they support that leg with brackets. They're however, typically using frame and panel construction which lends itself to lighter feet.
- A plinth type base could also work and appear lighter. I think that appearing lighter is good in this case as it seems that the base outweighs the top in proportion.
- I'd like to see the dovetails as half blinds to remove the visual clutter of seeing the tails on the drawer faces.
It looks a well crafted piece. I do have comments on the design ..
You chose a highly figured wood, and with the through dovetails on the drawers, the overall construction creates a very busy look.
I find the open, suspended shelves to be jaring. In fact all the open shelves add to the busy look. I would make the back of the open spaces dark to match the drawer pulls. The suspended shelves should continue the width of the opening. They should also continue the theme with the heights increasing towards the bottom. I think that the resulting "dark holes" will focus attention on the figure without making it overwhelming.
While we mostly prefer symmetry, the asymmetrical sides is interesting. I would not change it. This chest will need a sympathetic surrounding. What I would do is change the base. It is too heavy looking and must be lightened up, again the take the atention away from this area and back to the figure. What to do? One idea that comes to me is to add a narrow plinth that tapers in the opposite direction. It might use legs only on the left side (which is currently slanted). Try it tapering the other way as well. This could balance the current slant and add a novel profile.
Normally I don't go for sloped sides at all, but I think you get away with it due to the asymmetry of the case. If both sides were sloped it would just look like every other piece that does it (and there are lots of them). You took a bit of a risk, but I think it worked well for you.
The through dovetails don't bother me. I notice things like that more with very plain wood. I wouldn't care for it in a more traditional piece either, but it works on a contemporary one.
I like the drawer pulls.
The only thing I would suggest trying is to have the base legs on the left follow the line of the case side above it. Because the pic is small, I can't tell if you did that or not, but I would have tried it. Might have looked awful, might have looked right (I have to see this stuff to decide usually )
Interesting piece. I agree with John and Derek that the asymmetrical slant to the sides is a good design element. I'd have been tempted to find subtle ways to emphasize that more - perhaps, as others have said, with the treatment of the base.
I like the bookmatched effect of the grain on the deep drawers, in contrast to the bulls-eye grain of the groups of shallower drawers. The change in grain "rhythm" is neat.
I can't quite tell whether the piece tapers in its depth top to bottom. It looks like it does in the overall shot, and then the details don't look like it.
My wife says I have an engineer's brain; and certainly, I'm always aware of practical elements. So I have a couple of reactions that focus on the practical, but affect my judgment of the design. I think this is part of the artriture/furniture debate; pieces that look great (or interesting) but don't work (or look like they'd work) in real life cause me to turn away.
How tall is it? When I look at it, it gives the impression of being tall, and a practical part of my brain immediately wonders how easy it would be to get into the top drawers.
And, like John, I like the design of the drawer pulls considered by themselves; but the shallow drawers look relatively narrow, and the deep drawers look like they'd be heavy (whether they actually are or not, of course, depends on contents). Two pulls on a drawer require two hands, which then means putting down whatever you planned to put in there. If the drawers are narrow, a single centered pull is enough. And, for the deep drawers, the single pulls look insufficient to the visual weight; and, since they're off-center, I get the feeling (accurately or not) that the drawers would jam on opening. Top pulls on drawers that deep would just aggravate the jamming (although it's a problem: your drawer fronts feature the grain, and pulls in the field of the drawer face would get in the way). So the pulls, in this application, wind up looking awkward. For both drawer types, larger pulls, centered on the width of the drawer (and at the top edge, as you have them), would look more functional and less "I'm pretty but frustrating."
I'm undecided on the shelves. When I see cantilevered shelves like those, I immediately imagine a small swimming pool at the bottom, and mice challenging each other to dive off the open end...and then a more practical part of my (there it is again, the engineer's) brain pictures stuff on the shelves falling off. This concern may be partly a matter of my native-Californian-and-still-here status; we always think about earthquakes.
But I know that type of shelf is part of the contemporary vocabulary, so I try to banish the mice and the earthquakes in looking at them. And then I notice that the free ends are aligned vertically, and, in the photo at least, appear to be alone in that status, in that part of the piece; and end in a location with no obvious relationship to anything else in the piece. If the chest is tapered in its depth, then there may be optical illusions affecting that perception. But they might have worked a little better if the free ends lined up with something; and, if the right side (as we look at it) of that opening is slanted, as it appears to be in the photo, then maybe - maybe, not sure - slanting the shelf endings to fit would have worked better.
I live in an 1895 house, and it's interacted with my existing tastes; which is a way of saying that I'm not, in general, personally fond of modernist work. So I myself would never own a piece like this one. But, stepping away from my own tastes, I think you've done a good job with the overall design.
I'll never be able to look at Krenovian shelves again without thinking of your diving mice. And that vision will probably distort my thinking about Quaker locks, where I will also be seeing mousy diving boards.
My problem with that sort of shelf is not aesthetic; it's just structural. As long as they are only holding small works of art, or especially if they are designed to hold one particular work of art, I have no problem, but heavier things, like books, need support at both ends. Since support an only one end is insufficient, it usually means you would need a thicker back. Also, it obviates the possibility of adjustable shelves.
Location, Location, Location
Heck with the engineering. I think it is well balanced and the doors and drawers are well arranged. You did and excellent job of choosing and arranging the figured elm. The color, pattern and size of the Art Nouveau wall paper doesn't really work with it. It needs a location with open space to the left and a massive stone wall (or fire place) to the right.
Regrettably, something like this would not find a place in my home, either, since it is much older even than Bill's. It would need ogee bracket feet and frame and panel doors to fit in, and I can assure you I would not do something like that to it.
Should I the sound effects in my imagined mouse-diving contest - gleeful little cries of, "Go for it, Squeak!" and the crowd cheering when a mouse makes the dive and (on purpose, of course) belly-flops?
I just may have watched too many children's movies with my boys when they were young, and warped my brain. Heck, we still watch some movies that are nominally children's movies; they're often more fun than the crash-n-burn junk that is so often offered as "adult" fare.
I'd never heard of Quaker locks until today - neat little device! Of course, they work only on people who don't know about them, or only if you use a regular lock on the drawer below.
Back to Svante's chest of drawers - I recognize, Svante, what you were working on there with the alignment of the pulls. The vertical alignment of the pulls on the deep drawers with the outer pulls on the shallow drawers is interesting, and makes the deep-drawer pulls startling when considered alone, and then harmonious when considered with the shallow drawers. But, having made that decision, would it have made sense to align the inner pulls on the shallow drawers? As it is, the two tiers of shallow drawers are visibly un-coordinated, even though the deep drawers visibly coordinate with the shallow ones. Your piece is so significantly about the tension between symmetrical and asymmetrical geometry that placing the pulls on the shallow drawers asymmetrically - with the inner pulls aligned with each other vertically, in the two groups - might have been a nice fit with the design theme. And the placement of the bulls-eye in the grain would work with that, too, since it's off-center.
OK, self, stop looking at the piece and get to work on your own stuff.
I'm not very good at providing the sort of criticism you have asked for as I have a tendency to put too much meat in the hamburger*. So with that qualification ...
Your execution of the piece looks flawless and I find the design itself intriguing, however --
to my mind the top is far too light for the scale of the piece. I believe the piece would look better with a thicker top that incorporated a shadow detail like that between the case and plinth.
the "eye" in the top bank of drawers is growing on me, and the grain match to the deep drawer is pleasing, but I think the deep drawer itself would look (and function) better if it were a door concealing a shelf rather than a drawer.
I'm finding the grain match left to right in the middle bank of drawers distracting. The flow is just not there. Apart from that the overall configuration of the bank is pleasing. I especially like the negative space created by the open shelf. As with the top bank, I think the deep drawer would work better as a door to a shelf.
However, the lower bank of "drawers" doesn't have it. The piece you've chosen for the drawer face appears unbalanced -- sort of just hanging there. If anything it looks as though it really belongs in the middle drawer bank mating with teh left hand drawer face. Also the construction makes the element look like two pieces which jars with the other banks of drawers which appear to be single units. I feel that the lower bank would look better without the vertical between the left side of the drawer box and the top of the element, a piece that seems to break the space above the drawer. Alternatively the deep drawer could be replaced by a full height cabinet door, with the shelf arrangement retained on the left. As with the other two drawer banks, I feel a cabinet door would be a better choice compared to a deep drawer.
Overall, the proportions of the piece look a bit off to me. The graduation in height between the bottom and top banks of drawers looks too extreme, giving to the impression that the shelf above the bottom drawer is "wasted" rather than "negative' space. In part i believe thsi impression is reinforced bt teh vertical which breaks the space into two pieces. The drawer graduation in the middle and top drawer banks looks right, but in the bottom bank ...
To an extent I'd describe the case itself as "minimalist", while the plinth and feet as more "brutualist". The legs in particular are, to my mind, too heavy, especially compared to the slim case sides. A similar comment applies to the cross rail.
Overall I like the form and in this case the exposed dovetails on the drawer fronts adds to the design. I'm not sure about the middle column of drawer pulls -- my mind wants to regiment them into a straight line. I think it would look better if the pulls in the center were in a straight line under the pulls on the top bank, with the right hand pulls adjusted inwards to balance with a corresponding move of the right hand pulls in the lower and top banks.
Lastly, can I congratulate you on having the courage to place your piece out there for comment and criticism. I hope the comments help you refine your design sense and produce even more intriguing pieces in the fture.
* Years ago I was introduced to the hamburger concept of criticism.
As you know a hamburger consists of a meat pattie between two pieces of bread -- the bun.
It's said that when the Japanese provide criticism they leave out the meat -- the criticism is all the nice squishy bits,
In contrast the Germans are said to leave out the bun altogether -- their criticism is all over cooked, and thus hard to swallow, meat.
Keep in mind I have never been accused of having good design sense
Anyway, where the yellow lines in the picture are, the horizontals don't go all the way across. This gives an effect of a teetering stack of boxes (in my mind). I would go with that effect and re-enforce it. In the bottom section (red lines), I would put a full drawer on the left, and two shelves on the right.
This piece is lively and vivacious, with striking color, swirling grain and contrasting pulls.
It is a very useful piece of furniture--it will hold a lot. I believe the piece will show its best nature when the open spaces have articles placed in them. It needs to be shown doing its work. I would suggest adding books or curios, or whatever you intend in the openings. Then these negative spaces will be made positive and whole by the things you want near to hand. To my eye, this cabinet wants something up top to set it off as well, vases on top, or a framed picture above it. In short, this is not a piece of studio minimalist furniture—I see it as a workhorse, and not a quiet workhorse. It wants to hold its objects, display them, be a key part of a room.
You said you would like others to join in. Perhaps I will as I have time, referencing pieces I put in the Gallery of this site. These are all prototypes, risky things. I mostly like them, but each has things I would do differently or not at all. I once had a professor of engineering who did a lot of consulting, and he said he had the ambition to launch a magazine called ‘Failure’, which would focus on things that went wrong. This he thought would be a great contribution, because all other publications do nothing but brag, as though nothing ever went wrong. But there was a problem: no one would ever fess up to their failures! What is in my mind is to bring out an example, and show what went wrong (in my mind), what I would do differently.
I assume this is an exercise in the jarring, so commenting on it being jarring misses the point in two ways: One it was the point; Two how does one separate bad design from intentionally jarring elements. For instance I don't much like the base feet, and I agree with the point about the top lacking weight... But then again, whatcha gonna say.
In most pieces photographed and even moreso on the internet, getting the feel of the piece across in photos is tough. Normally in the room presence will be greater. I get a bit of that feel in the detail picture, and it made me think, maybe one needs 6 pictures a few more of which deal with the richness that is also there.
Is it pretty much as we see it, or does the "joke" extent to drawers that open and contain no space, or have bottoms that fall out? Are the canti shelves actually really strong (goodness know someone will try to use them as a ladder). An interesting question with stuff like this is what is the most likely major injury the piece could inflict. I recently got some piece of shop furniture with coupons of metal that make me shrink as I pass by, knowing only too well the huge hunks of flesh they might excise. But no, they are just that little bit low where one can't actually get a foot or shin at them.
Overall a very cool piece, it has some of that in the know with the joke aspect to it, while retaining (one supposes) a great deal of practicality. It would be very dependent on location, to feel right.
We still watch animated movies. Just the night before you posted your mouse allusion we were watching "How to Train Your Dragon," excellent "crash and burn" fare.
I was somewhat disappointed that I did not get any tips of furniture design forum. My initial idea was to get impressions from others - not to show my own furnitures. So I had low expectation when sending the photos to the forum.
But I am overwhelmed by effort and insight of your comments!
This piece of furniture is difficult to make justice on a photo. The slant of both sides are 1:20 so it is not asymmetrical as it looks on the first photo. I am encluding a new ont that hopefully shows the slant better. There are no slant top to bottom. The height is 90 cm equals to 36 inch.
After finishing the piece I was very happy with it and only had one issue. If I had placed the handles of the drawers more towards the center, the handles to the right of the upper drawers had been in line with the handles to the left of the lower drawers.
Now, after reading your posts I have realised that there are much more areas that can be improved. If I ever build another cabinet I would have made the following changes.
- A thicker top board would probably made the furniture more balanced
- Half blind dovetails are also really nice but I can't - it took so long time to get my through dovetails decent so probably I will skip that.
- For the back I would probably have tried something with less vild pattern
- I was very happy with the base but after your comments I also realise it is a bit heavy.
So thank you for the comments! It certainly have improved my way of looking at furniture design. I will probably bather you with more photos, but now it is time for someone else.
Disclaimer: Some of the comments I have not fully understood due to my shallow level of English, so I probably need to read them some more times to fully understand.....
Although it is obvious that your craftsmanship is exceptional, I will add my voice to those who find the piece unpleasant to look at and executed with choices (primarily the shelves and the through dovetails on the drawer fronts) that I would not have made. Exposing the dovetails on the drawer fronts detracts from the flow of the grain patterns you so carefully matched across the piece, and breaks up the aesthetic magic of a beautiful species of wood.
The piece has a "fun-house mirror" quality that I don't think I could live with for more than a few hours. It does come down to a matter of taste, of course, and for some the piece will certainly have appeal. I am not one of those people. A house filled with such furniture would quickly drive me mad.
Even so, the operative Internet expression is YMMV, especially given the high-quality of your skills and execution, and the excellent choice of the material. My opinions are my own.
Thanks for bravely posting your piece. I have a modern design sense and will offer my observations from that perspective.
-I agree with others that the use of the negative spaces (open compartments) and shelves create tension. This adds energy, but I'm not fully convinced it is fully balanced (see next comments).
-**Perhaps the most useful thing I can offer is a exercise I learned during art training early on (before I chose to follow pursuits I'm better suited to...). One of my teachers recommended closing one's eyes, opening them, and observering where one's eyes go to on a piece. For me, my eyes drop consistently to the lower left opening. And then start to move back up the piece.
-Depending on your intentions and the environment for the piece, this could be good or bad, depending on what objects the openings housed. In particular, I think it could work well if there was a strong vertical element on the right side of the large opening such as a tall bright vase or similar. However, I 'm having a hard time imaging what could be placed on the shelves to balance and harmonize the tensions. Would love to hear your ideas here. Thus, I'll also echo that the environment of the piece will strongly affect its success.
-The 'busy' grain is intense, but largely works for me. The opposing "C" produce an interesting flow from top to bottom
-I do not mind the through dovetails and in fact think they complement the grain. Through dovetails on a less textured piece would be more distracting to me. The pulls are another strong element for me.
-The tapered sides and asymmetrical elements provide a tension that is mostly balanced by the overall form. I enjoy pieces that have both, ideally resulting in a natural, balanced tension.
-undercutting chamfers or tapers on the base could lighten the appearance of the base.
-The execution looks to be top-notch.
I do hope the above is useful and thanks again for bravely offering all of us something to thing about.
Thanks for your engagement. The placement of the drawer pulls, thicker top and the rearrangement of the lower part is certainly an improvement. The only thing I am hesitating a bit is the rebate of the top.
It takes long time for me to design a new furniture. I make a first sketch - forget it for a month - redraw it - forget it and redraw. After a year and a dozen iterations I am so tired of it so I start building. The lesson learned it that I should also include a design review on wood central......
Thanks for having the temerity to offer up your excellent piece for critique, and for considering the suggestions of this group. I always welcome this sort of exchange of ideas, and I'm heartened when no egos are bruised.
By all means, let this be an invitation to you and others to trot out design concepts for input. It's particularly refreshing when the piece is novel, as yours is, and not encumbered by historical referents that bias the discussion.