New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Remembering tool alternatives

Posts

Remembering tool alternatives

#1

Remembering tool alternatives

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I'm installing trim on our auld haus remodel of the moment, and found myself having to back some of the trim - hollow it out behind, in the middle - to accommodate irregularities in the sheetrock finish. This was a fairly common practice when trim was 6-8" wide. The edges, after all, are the only "show" points on the trim (ends of head casings count as edges here).

I used a routah on one door's trim, but I hate the noise and dust. I then tried the scrub plane, which worked, but was a touch slow. Then I thought to get out a gouge*. Wow! Five minutes later, I had what I needed!

I need to remind myself that planes are not always the best solution to a problem.

*Carving gouge, because that's what was sharp. I really need to set aside a day for a sharpening fest, and get the several carpenter's gouges in my toolkit sharp.

Re: Remembering tool alternatives

#2

Re: Remembering tool alternatives

William Duffield

Remember that scrub planes are set up to plane across the grain. You should be better off with a jack plane set up with a much less aggressive (flatter) camber.

Re: Remembering tool alternatives

#3

funny you should say that

ian neuhaus

I use mine planes the other way round.

I find the scrub too short for most cross grain work preferring to use a cambered blade in a #5 or #6.

Where I find the scrub excels is rapid stock removal along the grain -- reducing a 2 x 4 to a 1-1/2 x 4 in a few minutes. Of course, once I'm close to the line, I switch to the #6 for the lat few mm.

Re: Remembering tool alternatives

#4

Re: funny you should say that

William Duffield

Of course, you should do what works for you. I'm only pointing out theoretical generalities, based on the light weight and narrow blade of the scrub plane, and the worst case rough lumber starting condition. I'm well enough off I usually don't have to buy lumber that rough, and I can start with a try plane, or even a forked tailed apprentice.