Re: Hikouki Kanna - Spring and Track
david weaver
That dai is so exceptionally cleanly cut that I could cut ten of them and not make one any more crisp than that.
I'm going to draw fire for being connected to suggesting beech for a dai, but I have two thoughts about that:
* when white oak isn't available, it's quite nice to make planes with. The idea that it's not durable enough in a group of planes that are tuned regularly, sometimes multiple times in a day in heavy work is strange because we use it in western planes that we may not tune at all for years.
* most of the people who suggest it's unacceptable for a dai are just repeating something they heard someone else say.
(and a third thought, you can always buy white oak later if you can manage to wear out the beech dai over time).
I have made two smoothers out of cocobolo. They would've been better aesthetically if I just made them out of beech. The density of tropical woods is nice in a western smoother, but it doesn't offer anything in a japanese smoother.
Hard maple sucks for making a dai, too - found that out by experience. It's just not a favorite for planes in general, even though it's harder than beech (the heart of the beech tree might be as hard, but the sap is definitely not as hard as hard maple).