New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Design forum for furniture

Posts

Design forum for furniture

#1

Design forum for furniture

Svante

Hi,

WoodCentral is great for handtools.

Any suggestion of forum for fine furniture design?

Regards,

Svante

Re: Design forum for furniture

#2

Re: Design forum for furniture

TomD

The furniture Society might be a good place, but I didn't find a forum unless it is behind a pay wall. It would be easy enough to create a forum but getting people to actually use if and at the level you want is a trick.

Re: Design forum for furniture

#3

If you have a design you want critiqued,

Chuck Nickerson

George Walker's Design Matters blog is a good place to start.

Email him your sketches and he'll blog them up so critiques appear as blog comments.

Re: Design forum for furniture

#4

Re: Design forum for furniture

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

A couple of folks - Brian Holcombe, Bill Tindall, and Derek Cohen in particular - post their work in progress here, and there's always an element of design in their posts and the ensuing discussions.

I've always been puzzled that design discussions often kind of peter out quickly, while technical discussions can go on for days.

Re: Design forum for furniture

#5

Ellis Walentine

Here's what I suggest...

Ellis Walentine

Look no further for design discussions. You have my attention, and probably a lot of others'. How would you kick off a discussion? Try it and see what happens.

We used to run a Critiques forum where people could post pictures of their work for constructive criticism. It's a tough go -- hard to figure out how to put your criticisms diplomatically, and deflating for the poster. Didn't fly.

If you'd like to discuss design principles or specifics regarding a particular piece you want to make, throw it out there. This is a very supportive and constructive place to trot out your questions. No bad questions here.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Design forum for furniture

#6

Re: Design forum for furniture

Brian Holcombe

I agree with the sentiment that this can also be a good place to discuss design. You have a wide variety of people who make both Traditional/historically accurate work and original/contemporary work.

Re: Design forum for furniture

#7

Clint Searl

Re: Design forum for furniture

Clint Searl

Unlike the layout of dovetails, design cannot be measured empirically; it's always in the eye of the beholder. The comments on the recent post of the beetle cabinet illustrates the futility of ever reaching a common opinion. Anyway, most people are blind to good design.

Re: Design forum for furniture

#8

Re: Design forum for furniture

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Well, I'm in. Design involves several levels. It is not simply the aesthetic that is admired on the outside, but also the construction on the inside. There is the elegance of joinery that harmonises with the design. I'm a minimalist at heart, so I do not like excess fat on a piece of furniture. Others will have a different interest. This is good - different points of view, different input.

I'm happy to expand the design area to more than furniture. Tools could be included as well.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Design forum for furniture

#9

Re: Here's what I suggest...

Curt Putnam

I used to run a photo critique group on Flickr and still do part-time. It's simply a case of tight moderation and not being afraid to ban those who flaunt the rules. Comments "such as " you should burn your camera and never take another picture" that the offender jumped on quickly. Either the offender apologized and corrected their actions in the future where they were banned for life.

Teaching people how to put forward a critical comment in a positive light is not easy. I've had to resort to a formula which is to comment on the most positive thing first and then lead gently into the critique and try to end with a positive.

The folks who inhabit this form are for the most part quite polite, thick-skinned, Mature and their knowledge is to be desired. I look forward to participating in any design discussions (mostly lurking and learning.)

Re: Design forum for furniture

#10

Re: Here's what I suggest...

William Duffield

Start a post here, or on Messages or on Turning, and start the Title with "¿Design Critique? - "

Post additional rules/guidelines/recommendations, and provide a link to them periodically or whenever there is a question about them. We should continue the discussion of what guidelines are appropriate.

You could volunteer to be the moderator. You already know how tough a job it is. :D

I like the idea of including tools in the design analysis. It always helps when designing tools to discuss potential additional uses, as well as materials and construction methods, and even aesthetics.