New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Will I need new sharpening gear?

Posts

Will I need new sharpening gear?

#1

Will I need new sharpening gear?

AZ in Colorado Springs

I use the work sharp motorized sand paper system (heresy, here, I understand), which has worked well for the collection of chisels I have and for plane irons. The chisels seem not to hold an edge too long, but they're easily sharpened.

I recently sold a project and have a "few" bucks in hand so I ordered a couple of PMV-11 chisels from Lee Valley. Am I going to have to use stones or diamonds to sharpen this new steel?

Thanks

Re: Will I need new sharpening gear?

#2

Re: Will I need new sharpening gear?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Unless you are using garnet paper, which is highly unlikely, you will be using the same mineral on the sand paper as most sharpening stones are made from (aluminum oxide). It will sharpen PMV11 just fine.

Re: Will I need new sharpening gear?

#3

Re: Will I need new sharpening gear?

david weaver

You won't need new sharpening gear. I'd say that the chisels you have not holding an edge is chance of one of two things:

1) the chisels just aren't very good

2) they could probably use an extra degree or two in bevel

I don't know your experience level, so I won't make a rude assertion that it's probably your technique - #2 above makes for a poor wearing chisel regardless of technique.

I've tested several chisels in a rockwell tester and since learned to use all but one of the chisels that I originally thought were too soft. They turn out to be my favorites now. Both in japanese and western, I like the chisels that are a step back from the hardest available.

I think #2 is worth trying with what you have, find the angle where they hold an edge well. If it gets too far past 30 (like into the 35 territory), then it's getting to where it's not an ideal bevel to use them and I'd look for something that holds up well at 30 or so.

Re: Will I need new sharpening gear?

#4

Re: Will I need new sharpening gear?

TomD

You can be sure they power sharpened them when they made or formed them. The most drastic sharpening tools are basically sandpaper. You can swallow a chisel whole in a few seconds with one, or give the most delicate, refined, hair popping buff.

All kinds of sharpening have their pros and cons. I'm at the summer residence and all I have is an 800 and a 6K waterstone, better than having to cart something back and forth, or worry about it leading to a break-in.

Re: Will I need new sharpening gear?

#5

Re: Will I need new sharpening gear?

AZ in Colorado Springs

I appreciate the replies. It never occurred to me to try changing the angle on the edge. I'll experiment with some different angles and see how they perform.