New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Honing epiphany

Posts

Honing epiphany

#1

Honing epiphany

Ron Harper

I know. "Oh no! Not this again"

Bear with me. I am 71 years old been working wood for 40 of those years. Almost completely power tools till 5 years ago. Have tried every honing system out there and invested heavily in many of them . I belong to a group on Facebook that has lively discussions and pics and videos about hand tools. In the last year or so some pretty serious craftsmen posted that they use only two stones. Steve Branam posted a blog called "two stones snd a Strop". After he has his edge shaped he takes ten strokes on a coarse stone. Ten on a fine stone and five on a strop. i said "yeah, right,"

One day I had a little extra time, so I tried it. Uhoh! I could take full width end grain shavings in pine with a 3/4 in chisel honed to 30 degrees! Easily!

Rough estimate........ I have overspent on honing somewhere north of $500 bucks. Every time I need to hone it is back to the coarse for ten, fine for ten and strop for five.

Just try it.

Re: Honing epiphany

#2

Re: Honing epiphany *LINK*

JDK

Rob Cosman uses even less....a few strokes on a 1000 grit diamond stone and then some strokes on a 16000 grit Shapton. No strop. Every so often he needs to regrind his primary bevel on a coarse grinding wheel, and then it's rinse, repeat.

Paul Sellers uses three diamond stones (coarse, fine, super-fine) and a strop. He does not grind at all unless the chisel needs repair. His chisels develop a slight convex profile. It's quite impressive to see how well they perform.

I myself use three Shaptons (1000, 4000, 8000) and a strop after grinding a primary bevel. It takes only seconds to bring my chisels or plane irons (both A2 and O1) into razor sharpness.

Here is a video of Sellers and his method:


Sellers Sharpens a Plane Iron

Re: Honing epiphany

#3

Re: Honing epiphany

Brian Holcombe

It's interesting how sharpening evolves for the individual. For me I've worked it down to India stone, Soft Ark then Japanese naturals. I usually hop from the Ark to a stone from the Yaginoshima mine that is described as a 'Medium Finisher' if a sharper edge is wanted I progress through the remaining stones.

I always strop my edges with a plain strop.

The approach has proven itself very effective, and many times I simply use Ark and Yaginoshima then strop and go back to work.

So I have everything I need, fast and effective, easy to use, always at the ready, stays flat and I can scale the edge to what is needed.

Re: Honing epiphany

#4

Re: Honing epiphany

Ron Harper

I used Mr. Sellers technique for three years. Steve's Method takes half the time and produces no convex bevel.

Re: Honing epiphany

#5

Re: Honing epiphany

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Ron

I have discovered a magic pyramid. You pop the blade in and watch the lights. The first light has a purple hue, the second is red, and when the the final lights up with a blue glow, then you know the blade is screamingly sharp.

While the colours are building, it is also important to chant "Not another sharpening thread! :)

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Honing epiphany

#6

Re: Honing epiphany

david weaver

That's the way to go, 2 stones. Strop if needed, but little or nothing on the strop.

Sometimes one stone is better than 2, but I don't know of a one-stone solution other than the washita that works really well.

If you're grinding by hand, sometimes more than 2 is nice, though.

It's sort of strange how this gets press on a blog and it catches on (no specific reference to this post), I would imagine that it was the way to go for a long time. Friend's dad was a trade joiner in england. He had a carborundum stone and an arkansas stone in his box, both well used.

10 years ago, I couldn't find a use for the shapton 5k, just the 1k and 15k. It just takes the least amount of time to do it that way.

Re: Honing epiphany

#7

But if you sell stones

Ron Harper

You want folks to have a six or seven step process

Re: Honing epiphany

#8

Re: But if you sell stones

david weaver

You're right about that. A long progression is nice for finishing knives. I don't even like it for sharpening knives, but for finishing new ones, it's nice.

And I know it's common for people to get a honing guide and then go painfully through five or 6 over a period of several minutes or more and have to keep all of them flat and free of contaminants. I never liked that, because a lot of stones don't really stay that flat unless you're constantly flattening them.

My favorite saying about woodworking in general (and it fits planemaking, I don't know much about woodworking outside of planes and screwing around with scads of sharpening stone) is that bias is your friend. Short sharpening routines bias things in your favor. Making joints bias the mistake side of the work in your favor. Fitting wedges to planes and bedding irons (and even making the really good ones) requires biasing things in your favor.

Trying for perfection without bias in our favor is really difficult.