New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Wood movement

Posts

Wood movement

#1

Wood movement

Joe Grittani

Greetings from the sunny beaches of Dayton Ohio -

A friend is making kitchen counter tops out of kiln dried cherry. Neither of us has a moisture meter and he's wondering how much expansion/shrinkage he should allow for. The tops will be made up of three boards totalling 26" wide and 1 1/4" thick. The top will be flat grain rather than edge grain strips, so tangential shrinkage is what he's concerned about.

Can anybody give us an educated guess? Every calculator I look at requires moisture content and we don't have it. Again, kiln dried by a reputable hardwood supplier and his house is ALWAYS heated/air conditioned so not susceptible to violent humidity swings.

Thanks in advance.

Joe Grittani

Re: Wood movement

#2

Very difficult.....but

Brian Roberts

check out the following:

http://workshoppages.com/WS/Articles/Wood-Movement-Charts.pdf

Be sure to read the directions on each page....one is for movement in decimal inches....the other in 64ths of an inch....both for a 12 inch panel.

Re: Wood movement

#3

and here is....

Brian Roberts

the place to find the info the other pages refer to:

http://www.fpl.fs.fed.us/documnts/fplrn/fplrn226.pdf

Re: Wood movement

#4

Re: Wood movement

Sgian Dubh

Allow up to 3/8" change in width between 7% and 13% MC, a fairly normal annual wood MC range in many residential properties. If the wood was recently kiln dried in the USA, it will probably have been dried to a target 7% MC ±2%, so it's likely it's not too far away from that 7% target MC, unless the wood's been stored in something like a steam room or other very humid environment since kilning. Having suggested 3/8" change in width, it wouldn't surprise me if the seasonal change was less for a variety of reasons. I use a spreadsheet I made up and known typical species expansion/contraction factors to estimate likely movement. Slainte.

Re: Wood movement

#5

Some data

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

First a comment: The tabulated data is at most a rough guide and in my experience substantially overestimates the changes that occur after kiln drying. The tabulated data is derived from an average of lumber from many trees. I have seen the range among the sample given as 30% of the reported average. Furthermore, the data is the shrinkage from an air dried state of 20-30% moisture content (I can't remember the exact value) to zero divided by the moisture lost. In other words it is an average value for the shrinkage as the wood cells collapse the first time from swollen to as small as they get. The cells don't ever again respond to moisture changes as much as they do in the initial drying.

Data: I have a flat sawed 12" piece of walnut in the shop that I have followed for years as the shop humidity ranged between 40 and 60%. The width of this sample changes +/- 1/32" from the average.

I have wood counter tops in the kitchen. The situation is immovable rock- 42" wood- stove- 42" wood- rock, i.e. the stove and 84" of wood are sandwiched between rock. Right now with humidity in kitchen 55% there is a 1/8" gap on each side of the stove and the wood is tight against the rock. I can't recall the gap being much bigger in the winter when the humidity drops to 40%,, certainly not over 1/4". The gap has never closed when the humidity has drifted up to as high as 70%. I keep the counter top oiled with vegi oil that I am sure slows moisture transport into/out of the wood.

A friend has a 24" wide maple coffee table with a bread board end. It moves about 1/8".

That said, you have not provided enough information to provide guidance. What is the history of the lumber after it was purchased? (The National Hardwood Lumber Association specification for KD lumber in the US is 7% moisture content as you can count on your lumber having been at this specification if manufactured at a reputable mill. It will never again be this low unless it is moved to Arizona). What will the top be between as it expands and contracts? What is the risk of underestimating expansion, or shrinkage as you have not stated what the concern is. If the risk is expansion can the top be trimmed if it ever gets too big, without a lot of fuss?

Bottom line, you are probably worrying more than necessary. If the lumber has been sitting around a while in the Ohio summer it will likely never be any wider than it is now and the top may shrink an 1/8" in the winter. Keep it oiled if it is a functional top.

Re: Wood movement

#6

I anticipate serious problems

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If I understand correctly the top will consist of 3- 8" wide boards. It may be located such that one side has restricted air access, or one side gets wet in use. I predict these 8" wide boards will cup in service.



It would be better to assemble the top from strips 1-2" wide as shown in picture. (this top is maple)

BTW, I had cherry tops in our previous house. They were oiled and used for baking and cooking. They became almost black with age. This time around we went with maple.

Re: Wood movement

#7

Re: Wood movement

don stephan

Bruce Hoadley's book Understanding Wood is an important addition to any woodworker's bookshelf for any number of topics, including moisture and seasonal movement radially and tangentially. It includes a chart for many common woods and sample calculations for seasonal movement. Many public libraries probably also have copies.

Re: Wood movement

#8

Also

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

if the cherry were ripped to 1-1/4" net widths, each strip could be rotated to obtain vertical grain (as it appears Bill has done), while still preserving the desired thickness. Of course, the kerf and jointing losses would have to be made up with a few inches of additional 5/4 or 6/4 cherry.

Wiley

Re: Wood movement

#9

Re: Wood movement

TomD

What I do is seal the end grain with boatbuilding epoxy, it won't shift much after that. In reality moisture exchange will occur no mater how you seal it, but this seems to moderate the time curve for seasonal change. The other thing I do as the guy with dozens of projects going at one time is I bring wood indoors for months, stick it under a bed or sofa, and then process it at mean moisture conditions. I do have several moisture meters, they are pretty cheap these days, though I can't think of too many situations where they have been useful. For me it is more the process, as in setting wood aside, processing at mean, sealing as required, knowledge of wood movement, etc...

Re: Wood movement

#10

Re: Wood movement

Tony - Memphis

I made a table top using cherry (3/4"+ stock). Mine came via the mail, so there is no telling what state is was in. It is 30" wide and from season to season, it moves about 1/4". It did shrink maybe 1/8" afcter construction, so even in the summer, the breadboard ends hang over a bit. That counter will be really nice looking in a few years.

(I'm in Memphis, TN and the shop and house are conditioned).

Tony