New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Depth Stop on Moving Fillister Planes - how High?

Posts

Depth Stop on Moving Fillister Planes - how High?

#1

Depth Stop on Moving Fillister Planes - how High?

david weaver

As I'm planing out trim pieces to go from the carpet to the floor and from separate floor services, I got out a wooden moving fillister plane that I haven't yet used. Long story short, I had a common us maker fillister that was a bit worn out and sloppy and replaced it with a little used english maker plane.

When I went to set the depth for a rebate for the carpet (7/16th high), the depth stop on the plane couldn't come remotely close to that. It ran out of travel around 1/4th of an inch. I lost my temper and turned it out, figuring if that's all the higher it will go, I will take it off of the plane (that part is true).

The other plane I had (which I should have kept) had much more travel.

Is there a typical amount of travel a moving fillister has on the depth stop (especially the type that are screw adjust)? what good would it be if it's only 1/4th of an inch? It has to be common to cut 3/8th or 1/2" high rabbets to nail T&G in the back of the case.

The wood I'm working is second growth oak, which is fairly hard, and though I sold my old fillister plane, I still have a metal one, and I used that. For bulk work and a heavy cut, though, a wooden plane is at least twice as easy to use.

I will have to repair the plane that I mauled, the threads are certainly stripped now, but it's of very little use with that kind of depth limitation. Taking it apart will answer the question of whether it was jammed or actually at the end of travel.

If you have a woody fillister, can you do me a favor and see what the maximum height of the depth stop foot is above the plane sole?

(there are other options for this, of course - but I'd rather not set up the power router table for this work, and just using a rabbet plane in wood that is hard even for oak, it's slow going. )

Re: Depth Stop on Moving Fillister Planes - how High?

#2

5/8"


Re: Depth Stop on Moving Fillister Planes - how High?

#3

Thanks, Larry.

david weaver

Thanks, Larry.

Re: Depth Stop on Moving Fillister Planes - how High?

#4

Greenfield = 11/32

Neal in South Carolina

And it would be difficult to increase it very much. Maybe get it to 3/8, but for more than that it would probably be easier to find another plane.

Re: Depth Stop on Moving Fillister Planes - how High?

#5

Re: Depth Stop on Moving Fillister Planes - how Hi

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Clark & Williams is 1/2" plus a little.

Wiley

Re: Depth Stop on Moving Fillister Planes - how High?

#6

Re: Depth Stop on Moving Fillister Planes - how Hi

Steve Elliott

Plane by J. Miller goes to just over 15/32".

Re: Depth Stop on Moving Fillister Planes - how High?

#7

Thanks, Guys...

david weaver

Thanks, guys. I'm surprised that the foot doesn't go higher.

I broke my screw yesterday below the thumb screw, but it will be a good spot for silver solder should I choose to fix it. As of now, I just removed the foot - it's easier to hit a depth mark working to a line for me, and no burnishing from the

I probably don't understand where the moving fillister would've been used in large case work vs. a larger plane (in this case, a groove about 1/2 by 1/2, which looks like only a few of the planes would do).

Re: Depth Stop on Moving Fillister Planes - how High?

#8

Re: Depth Stop on Moving Fillister Planes - how Hi

steve voigt

My Greaves fillister (definitely a cabinetmaker's fillister; it's bedded at around 53°) will cut a 9/16-deep rabbet.

Are you sure there's not something obstructing the screw from being used all the way?

Re: Depth Stop on Moving Fillister Planes - how High?

#9

Re: Depth Stop on Moving Fillister Planes - how Hi

david weaver

Yeah, it's up all the way. I could put the foot back on and measure it, it's probably a little more than 1/4th, but it's well short of 1/2. I don't build a lot of accurate furniture, so maybe I'm expecting to do something with it that isn't commonly done.

I know the last one that I had would cut a 5/8th by 1/2" rabbet as that was the last size that I cut with it (to nail in tongue and groove board).

(I know it's up all the way because I took the foot off of it now and took it apart last night. Strange setup, it probably has 3/4ths of an inch of travel, but a large amount of that travel would have the foot below the sole. )

Re: Depth Stop on Moving Fillister Planes - how High?

#10

Re: Depth Stop on Moving Fillister Planes - how Hi

steve voigt

OK, one more thought. My plane has a two-piece foot; I'm assuming yours is the same. look at the brass piece that the foot threads into. On my plane, the hole is distinctly off-center. If I removed it (which means undoing the two screws at the top and unthreading the lead screw until it's out) and flipped it upside down, it will fit fine (I've tried it) but I would lose close to 1/8 of travel. So maybe yours is upside down?

Re: Depth Stop on Moving Fillister Planes - how High?

#11

Re: Depth Stop on Moving Fillister Planes - how Hi

Warren in Lancaster, PA

If the sole had been damaged and cut down to get good wood, the plane would have lost depth capacity. If you can add to the sole, you could gain capacity.

Re: Depth Stop on Moving Fillister Planes - how High?

#12

Re: Depth Stop on Moving Fillister Planes - how Hi

david weaver

I'll have a look at it again tonight, I don't remember seeing anything amiss last night (the carrier is symmetrical and the screws can only go in one spot on the foot on mine).

But I broke that lead screw off at the thumb handle, so getting it all out and apart will be the next important project.

It is still a far nicer plane to use in oak in bulk work than a metal rabbet plane, even though there are some fine premium metal rabbet planes out there, making 20 feet of deep rabbets in oak with them is pure torture. It seems four times as hard, no matter how many times you stop to wax.

Re: Depth Stop on Moving Fillister Planes - how High?

#13

Re: Depth Stop on Moving Fillister Planes - how Hi

david weaver

Unfortunately, this was an unused english plane. But your idea is a good one and I may go with it in the future, anyway, I should have plenty of iron and nicker to add an eighth.

Re: Depth Stop on Moving Fillister Planes - how High?

#14

If you can't raise the bridge

Neal in South Carolina

Lower the river. That's a good idea. If I ever need more capacity, I'll do that. Much easier than trying to modify the depth stop. I don't think mine has lost much off of the sole, as the depth stop will only extend about 1/16 past the bottom of the sole but more capacity could be useful. The nicker will be a challenge, but I'll burn that bridge when I get there.

Re: Depth Stop on Moving Fillister Planes - how High?

#15

Re: Not that it matters too much..

david weaver

..but as I struggle with a way to get the threaded rod out of my moving fillister, the one I broke off in anger, I thought I'd look for a junker to cannibalize some hardware.

And then I saw a fairly ratty Barton moving fillister sell for $120 on ebay!!!

The plane that I sold, I had originally gotten (dried out, but complete) from the old fine tool journal newsletter tool sale for $25 - it needed to have the boxing reglued, and it needed to have some pitting ground out of the iron, the side trued, and a fresh coat of oil and wax, but when I sold it on ebay, someone paid $100 for it in a straight auction.

Things have really changed! Maybe there was a blog post about moving fillisters, and I missed it, don't know. Sure do miss the old fine tool journal newsletter tool sales, though.

If anyone has smart ideas about getting an overtightened brass screw out of a moving fillister plane, I'm all ears. I can't quite get a grip on the nub with pliers and it's too far down in the plane to notch the top easily.

Re: Depth Stop on Moving Fillister Planes - how High?

#16

Re: Not that it matters too much..

steve voigt

Dave, did you pull the the two wood screws out of the top plate? That would be my first move. You may be able to lift the whole assembly up a little. Second, take out the fillister screw that holds the steel-shod foot to the lead-screw assembly…you may be able to operate the screw from the inside (for example, wrap some tape around some needle-nose pliers). While you're at it, check and see if flipping the brass piece upside-down will buy you some more adjustment room. I'm still betting that someone flipped it the wrong way around before you bought it.

Last thing: It would take Hercules to actually break the leadscrew. The knob is normally pinned to the screw with a very small pin, 1/16 or 3/32, thereabouts. Dollars to donuts you just sheared the pin. They usually did a pretty artful job of making the pin inconspicuous, and corrosion and age make it even harder…anyway, you should be able to get a tiny punch, or just a dowel pin, and drive out the pin remnants, get a new pin at the hardware store, and be back in business. Worst case scenario would be to take it to a local machine shop, but I doubt you'll have to.

Re: Depth Stop on Moving Fillister Planes - how High?

#17

Re: Not that it matters too much..

david weaver

You're right, I broke the connection between the turning knob and the screw. I had it at full tension against the top (I didn't see it and didn't take the time to look to see that I could take a screw off of the foot).

It's under a lot of tension against the top and that makes it hard to turn. I'll probably take another whack at it this weekend. Thanks for the suggestions.

Re: Depth Stop on Moving Fillister Planes - how High?

#18

Re: Another data point

david weaver

Out of curiosity, I purchased another moving fillister, a griffiths that looks to be unused (I'm a fan of griffiths stuff though it usually costs more).

It arrived yesterday from the UK and the first thing I did was check the range on the depth stop. It goes up more than 3/4ths of an inch, more than twice what the other plane that I have went up (I still have yet to repair that one because I haven't been able to get the tension back off of the screw by turning the stub where it broke off - I'll eventually fix it).

I'm still puzzled as to why the depth stop on the first plane would only go up less than 3/8ths of an inch and have so much less travel, the first is a beautifully made plane with a long depth stop foot that has steel sweated on to the bottom of the brass - it was just designed without much travel - I guess with the assumption that you'd take off the depth stop if you were going to go deeper?

I accidentally acquired a third by misjudgement with Ebay's "offer" system, so I'll see what that one does (in terms of depth) and then figure out what to do with the extras.