New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

The Butler's Desk - Get's Detailed

Posts

The Butler's Desk - Get's Detailed

#1

The Butler's Desk - Get's Detailed

Brian Holcombe

Good morning! I've been whittling away on the Butler's desk and wanted to share the progress I've made. At this point the overall design is visible in it's near entirety, with the drawer pull recesses cut, the chamfers applied and the finish now also being applied.

https://brianholcombewoodworker.com/2016/07/21/butlers-desk-gets-detailed/

Click the above link for the full story




Re: The Butler's Desk - Get's Detailed

#2

Re: The Butler's Desk - Get's Detailed

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The chamfer details were a nice finishing touch.

The text description of the drawer stop was not sufficient that I understood how it was made nor where it is located.

Garnet shellac is commonly used on walnut . I find the result attractive.

Re: The Butler's Desk - Get's Detailed

#3

Re: The Butler's Desk - Get's Detailed

Brian Holcombe

Thanks Bill!

I did not want to provide much on the stop as it is still in my test phase. I'm about 50% convinced by it.

Re: The Butler's Desk - Get's Detailed

#4

Re: The Butler's Desk - Get's Detailed

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I'll look forward to a separate post on this feature, how ever it turns out.

BTW, how does one grip the lid to open it? I has a delightful look opened and most would likely leave it that way.

Have you tried Garnet shellac on walnut and not like it, or not tried it? The last I bought was a lot less "garnet" and undesirably orange.

Re: The Butler's Desk - Get's Detailed

#5

Re: The Butler's Desk - Get's Detailed

Brian Holcombe

Bill, I plan to just use the key to open it, I like the handle free look. I saw an old Danish wall system that used this setup and I thought to use it.

I'll post up some details on that probably in the last post. And hopefully by that point I've figured out the stay by then. If not I'm going to dedicate some time to milling a stay out of brass and I'll detail that process.

Re: The Butler's Desk - Get's Detailed

#6

Re: The Butler's Desk - Get's Detailed

Brian Holcombe

WRT Garnet Shellac, I have not tried it. I've been pretty fond of blonde shellac on walnut, since it does look similar to oil finish, but I'm not opposed to trying garnet.

I am somewhat opposed to an orangey finish, however.

Re: The Butler's Desk - Get's Detailed

#7

Drawer stop

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


This stop has been used for centuries. It may lack novelty, but for the hidden engineering in furniture I find that property a compelling advantage.

Re: The Butler's Desk - Get's Detailed

#8

Re: Drawer stop

Brian Holcombe

The purpose of the stop in question is not to make a hard stop, but a soft stop which can be passed over with a little additional pressure to open the drawer fully.

Re: The Butler's Desk - Get's Detailed

#9

Re: Drawer stop

Sgian Dubh

Interesting Bill. I normally fit that kind of drawer stop with the grain rotated through 90º, meaning what hits the back face of the drawer front is end grain. To be honest, I don't think there's much in it, but early in my career I was informed the 'end grain as a stop' preference was because it's tougher than long grain, less likely to wear or collapse. Nowadays I suppose fitting them end grain forwards is essentially just a habit. Slainte.

Re: The Butler's Desk - Get's Detailed

#10

Interesting point on stop orientation

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

You always have a refreshing insight. I can't wait for your book.

The robustness argument is dubious given that the grain of the drawer it is stopping runs in the same direction that is claimed to be vulnerable. If damage was a valid concern I would rather have it on the stop than the drawer. The failure I typically see is that the stop glue fails and the stop is gone. Hence I always nail them.

A potential advantage of end grain orientation is that the stop location will not change with humidity because the stop will not change in length. However, my drawers are not fit to a precision where this factor becomes significant.

In the past I oriented as you describe but simply lost track of this detail in the current case. However, the glue is more apt to hold over time if the grain of the stop matches the grain of the divider.

Now I am hopelessly confused. >(

Re: The Butler's Desk - Get's Detailed

#11

Re: Interesting point on stop orientation

Sgian Dubh

This will confuse further then Bill. Here's a drawer stop where the end grain faces up, i.e., the long grain direction is vertical. It's essentially an L shaped piece of wood that drops into a stopped groove, see the images below. I'm not convinced this pattern is any better than the simple form you showed - it's quite a bit of work compared to simply nailing or screwing a stop in place, but I suppose the technical complexity might be something to endlessly bore on about to easily impressed admirers if that's your bag, ha ha.

As to the bookie-wookie, I've just heard via email they're working on it (no details on progress nor problems mentioned), so fingers crossed that it's essentially going okay, and will actually come out in the not too distant future. Slainte.

 photo DrawerStop_zpsszdmz3fl.jpg

 photo drawer-stop-vertical-600px_zpsdk77a48a.jpg

Re: The Butler's Desk - Get's Detailed

#12

not my cup of tea

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

That option didn't confuse me a bit. It was immediately rejected for it would be a challenge to get accurately located with no compensating benefit other than the vain one you proposed. I have enough challenge building stuff as simple as I can.

So many things to build, so little time to learn.

Re: The Butler's Desk - Get's Detailed

#13

Easy to locate

Denny

Bill, if the stop drops into a slot, its easy to adjust the final fit just by leaving the stop a bit long and then planing the stop to fine tune the fit before you glue it in.

Re: The Butler's Desk - Get's Detailed

#14

I suppose so....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

...but my definition of easy is to locate the drawer to its proper depth and then simply butt the stops, one on each side, against the inside drawer face with a rub joint. I usually just wedge the drawer in place with thin wedge(s) driven in the gap around the drawer prior to rubbing in the stops.

If the drawer bottoms and case back are not yet installed it is always possible to do the stops this way.

Re: The Butler's Desk - Get's Detailed

#15

Wearing

David Charlesworth

This style is shown in Robert Wearing's book, "The Essential Woodworker".

It is rather time consuming and the slots must be machined before glue up!

I show a simpler version in my "Drawer Making and Fitting" DVD.

Best wishes

David

Re: The Butler's Desk - Get's Detailed

#16

A suggestion

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I believe the objective of this forum is for sharing ideas on building stuff. Sgian, as usual, provided a model for how to respond with an idea. He could have said, "buy my book to see another way to do a drawer stop". But in the spirit of the Forum he provided sufficient detail to explain the alternative. His response was informative.

Re: The Butler's Desk - Get's Detailed

#17

Re: A suggestion

Sgian Dubh

" He could have said, "buy my book to see another way to do a drawer stop". Not really Bill. The manuscript I've produced (which I'm hoping will actually turn into a book now that my maunderings are with a publisher) has nothing to say on drawer stop forms.

I do recognise the implied complaint you made to David. On the other hand, I believe he is best known for making his living through his teaching, writing, DVDs, and the like on furniture making, so I can also understand the reason for his post. It could be argued that the information I provided in a couple of my posts on drawer stops might be well illustrated in the DVD David mentioned. I'll leave it at that, and avoid trying to justify one position over another. And I suppose this post could be classified as not advancing the craft of woodworking at all, being merely vacuous verbiage. Slainte.

Re: The Butler's Desk - Get's Detailed

#18

Post

David Charlesworth

Thanks Richard.

I do not have CAD anymore or the skills to easily post pictures or photos.

The method I referred to was devised by my friend Terry Sawle.

It consists of a hardwood peg/post/section, fitted into a mortice, each side.

Say 25mm by 5 or 6mm by 10mmdeep. These are best made with a router but could be hand morticed.

The front face of the post can be adjusted with a small bull nose or shoulder plane.

You will appreciate that the work must be very accurate, with drawer front thickness being fixed before creating the mortices!

The result is very neat and strong.

Pinned and glued rectangles were what I was taught, but they have a crude feel and are not that easy to manage. (We beveled the back corners).

I hope this provides the details missing from my earlier post.

Best wishes,

David

Re: The Butler's Desk - Get's Detailed

#19

Self stopping drawers

Brian Holcombe

David,

You have a video on a chest you made that tapers back to front causing the drawer to stop at about 3/4 of the extension. I thought that was pretty ingenious.

Re: The Butler's Desk - Get's Detailed

#20

Re: Self stopping drawers

David Charlesworth

Brian,

Researching this was difficult, very few references, but one from early 20th century and of course Krenov.

I suspect that it was done by only a few craftsmen. Alec McCurdy being one.

It is not so much a stop as a warning not to pull the drawer all the way out and drop it on the floor!

Best wishes,

David

Re: The Butler's Desk - Get's Detailed

#21

Question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"Pinned and glued rectangles were what I was taught, but they have a crude feel and are not that easy to manage. "

Crude they are but who ever sees them? :) However, I understand that the Studio Furniture trade builds to a more refined standard than building to hold your socks.

I don't understand the "not easy to manage part". What's not easy to manage? I find the blocks trivial to locate and stick in place awaiting a couple of brads when the glue sets.

I think there is something to be said for waiting to locate the exact position of the drawer front until everything is finished. (Depending on I don't know what in my mind) I diddle with the drawer location until it looks right which may be with the drawer exactly in the plane of the front or not. In the case of the recent piece with its arced case front porfile I think it would have been hard to predetermine the optimum location for the drawer front until the drawer was fitted and the case finished.

Re: The Butler's Desk - Get's Detailed

#22

A perilous goal

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

While such engineering could be achieved in the controlled environment of the shop, or museum, I doubt that case goods are stable enough in the real world to make this kind of fitting practical in a case piece of any practical size. Krenov pieces are tiny and he could get away with proposing engineering that would not successfully scale to a chest of drawers for blankets and shirts (in my opinion).

I have seen first hand how my case pieces move in response to high humidity. "Piston fit drawers" and drawer retraction constrictions sound to me like artificial building challenges, parlor tricks if you will, that are going to fail in use sometime in their life. Furniture with a sticky drawer is going to be tossed by some future owner unless the builder is famous enough for the owner to tolerate a piece of furniture that has lost its functionality.

Re: The Butler's Desk - Get's Detailed

#23

Re: Another Stop

William Duffield

If you expose the end grain of the stop to the drawer, it is more likely to split at the brad (half gone :D).

If you need to trim it (with a shoulder plane, as one of our friends across the pond suggested) face grain would be easier than end grain.

I worked on a kitchen cabinet job where the drawers were completed after the cabinets were installed and inaccessible from the back, and thus the stops needed to be adjusted on site by one of the apprentices in the shop. I invented and produced a handful of these cams from quarter inch plywood and a small FHWS.

It took a lot less time to shape them and instruct the apprentice in their application than to drive all the way in to Conshohocken and install something simpler myself.


The diagram shows them installed between the cabinet guide and the drawer side, but they could as easily be installed on the top of the drawer blade and index off the drawer front. You install them with the screw and turn to adjust. When they are right, scribe the flat side of the cam onto the cabinet. Unscrew the cam, apply some molding and trim glue, screw it back down and rotate it until your scribe lines up.

Re: The Butler's Desk - Get's Detailed

#24

Re: A perilous goal

Brian Holcombe

The chest in question was fairly small IIRC.

I consider it a tool to use when appropriate. A small chest may be perfect for such a thing. Seems like it would combine nicely with a flat bottom drawer in a case which does not permit a traditional stop.

Re: The Butler's Desk - Get's Detailed

#25

Re: A suggestion

George Bustamante

Mr. Wearing's book is excellent; as are Mr. Charlesworth's articles and videos.

I am happy that Mr. Charlesworth offers his advice on this forum.