New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Curly maple + scraper plane = no tearout

Posts

Curly maple + scraper plane = no tearout

#1

Curly maple + scraper plane = no tearout

Hank Knight

Love it.

[URL=http://s50.photobucket.com/user/hankknight/media/Chest%20of%20Drawers/image_zpsmvzwdg0s.jpeg.html][/URL]

Re: Curly maple + scraper plane = no tearout

#2

Re: Curly maple + scraper plane = no tearout

david weaver

I guess nobody likes scrapers! I just sold my last one on ebay this weekend (the small LN), but will say that when they are set up properly, they are a treat to use.

The ones with modern irons really will hold their burr for a long time, too, almost like a plane.

A decade ago or a little more when I got into this hobby, I started with a 63 degree mujingfang plane and a scraper, and safe to say, I preferred using the scraper - it actually seemed easier to push.

The small LN scraper is really a dandy little plane, too. Not that I'm trying to enable, but it's got all of the bells and whistles and you can keep advancing the lean a little bit each time the burr gets tired, just like the big one. And it's easier to push because the cut width is small.

Re: Curly maple + scraper plane = no tearout

#3

Re: Thanks for posting, David

Hank Knight

I was beginning to think my post was going to be an orphan! :D I've had this scraper plane for a while, but could never get it to work very well. With this big curly maple projct going, I decided it was time; so I spent the morning truing up the blade, sharpening it properly and setting it up to take a shaving. It was well worth the effort! I feel like I have a new tool in my arsenal. I've had my eye on the L-N cabinet maker's scraper plane for a while. Your comment about the small scraper plane being easier to push may have pushed me over the edge - I'm an easy pushover! ;)

Re: Curly maple + scraper plane = no tearout

#4

Re: orphan posts..

david weaver

...of course, you started the post with a picture of you actually doing something.

that's the kiss of death on forums. People see you did some actual work and they run the other way :b

Now, if you'd have related your scraping through statements like "in theory", I think you'd have had a lively string of hypothetical arguments.

:)

Re: Curly maple + scraper plane = no tearout

#5

Re: orphan posts..

Hank Knight

:D :D :D

Re: Curly maple + scraper plane = no tearout

#6

Re: orphan posts..

David Charlesworth

They are indeed great tools, just lots of things that can be got wrong in the preparation!

I think this was the thrust of the demonstration in my DVD, "Five Topics".

best wishes,

David

Re: Curly maple + scraper plane = no tearout

#7

Re: orphan posts..

Hank Knight

Thanks, David. I need to check out your video. I'm sure It would be helpful.

Re: Curly maple + scraper plane = no tearout

#8

Me too.

Tony - Memphis

I had mine to "sing".....once. It was a beautiful moment and made up for all the frustration leading up to that moment. But, alas, it was just a moment...and n'er again has she sung. What a moment that was though!

I have been pretty much nothing but frustrated with mine. Need to master that thing though. I know it could be a useful tool in the arsenal. Had I known how it was going to be.....

Tony

Re: Curly maple + scraper plane = no tearout

#9

Re: Me too.

Hank Knight

Ah, but the siren song was so sweet, it draws you perpetually back in the hope of hearing it again. :)

Re: Curly maple + scraper plane = no tearout

#10

Re: Me too.

David Charlesworth

If you know exactly what is required, and pay attention to each step, it should work well, every time.

Best wishes,

David

Re: Curly maple + scraper plane = no tearout

#11

Every time a coconut!!

David Charlesworth

In fact as my father was fond of saying, "every time a coconut!"

David

Re: Curly maple + scraper plane = no tearout

#12

Re: Coconuts - Had one today! - Getting Better!


Re: Curly maple + scraper plane = no tearout

#13

Re: Every time a coconut!!

Tony - Memphis

Had to look that one up! I like it!

So, does your video you mentioned outline those steps for the scraper?

I've enjoyed 3 of your books and your planing video - thanks!

Tony

Re: Curly maple + scraper plane = no tearout

#14

Re: Every time a coconut!!

David Charlesworth

Tony,

Yes detailed steps for scraper plane set up are described in my DVD "Five Topics".

David