Curly maple + scraper plane = no tearout
Hank Knight
Love it.
[URL=http://s50.photobucket.com/user/hankknight/media/Chest%20of%20Drawers/image_zpsmvzwdg0s.jpeg.html]
[/URL]
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Curly maple + scraper plane = no tearout
Hank Knight
Love it.
[URL=http://s50.photobucket.com/user/hankknight/media/Chest%20of%20Drawers/image_zpsmvzwdg0s.jpeg.html]
[/URL]
Re: Curly maple + scraper plane = no tearout
david weaver
I guess nobody likes scrapers! I just sold my last one on ebay this weekend (the small LN), but will say that when they are set up properly, they are a treat to use.
The ones with modern irons really will hold their burr for a long time, too, almost like a plane.
A decade ago or a little more when I got into this hobby, I started with a 63 degree mujingfang plane and a scraper, and safe to say, I preferred using the scraper - it actually seemed easier to push.
The small LN scraper is really a dandy little plane, too. Not that I'm trying to enable, but it's got all of the bells and whistles and you can keep advancing the lean a little bit each time the burr gets tired, just like the big one. And it's easier to push because the cut width is small.
Re: Thanks for posting, David
Hank Knight
I was beginning to think my post was going to be an orphan!
I've had this scraper plane for a while, but could never get it to work very well. With this big curly maple projct going, I decided it was time; so I spent the morning truing up the blade, sharpening it properly and setting it up to take a shaving. It was well worth the effort! I feel like I have a new tool in my arsenal. I've had my eye on the L-N cabinet maker's scraper plane for a while. Your comment about the small scraper plane being easier to push may have pushed me over the edge - I'm an easy pushover! 
Re: orphan posts..
david weaver
...of course, you started the post with a picture of you actually doing something.
that's the kiss of death on forums. People see you did some actual work and they run the other way 
Now, if you'd have related your scraping through statements like "in theory", I think you'd have had a lively string of hypothetical arguments.

Re: orphan posts..
Hank Knight

Re: orphan posts..
David Charlesworth
They are indeed great tools, just lots of things that can be got wrong in the preparation!
I think this was the thrust of the demonstration in my DVD, "Five Topics".
best wishes,
David
Re: orphan posts..
Hank Knight
Thanks, David. I need to check out your video. I'm sure It would be helpful.
Me too.
Tony - Memphis
I had mine to "sing".....once. It was a beautiful moment and made up for all the frustration leading up to that moment. But, alas, it was just a moment...and n'er again has she sung. What a moment that was though!
I have been pretty much nothing but frustrated with mine. Need to master that thing though. I know it could be a useful tool in the arsenal. Had I known how it was going to be.....
Tony
Re: Me too.
Hank Knight
Ah, but the siren song was so sweet, it draws you perpetually back in the hope of hearing it again. 
Re: Me too.
David Charlesworth
If you know exactly what is required, and pay attention to each step, it should work well, every time.
Best wishes,
David
Every time a coconut!!
David Charlesworth
In fact as my father was fond of saying, "every time a coconut!"
David
Re: Coconuts - Had one today! - Getting Better!
Re: Every time a coconut!!
Tony - Memphis
Had to look that one up! I like it!
So, does your video you mentioned outline those steps for the scraper?
I've enjoyed 3 of your books and your planing video - thanks!
Tony
Re: Every time a coconut!!
David Charlesworth
Tony,
Yes detailed steps for scraper plane set up are described in my DVD "Five Topics".
David