New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Question for you kanna mavens

Posts

Question for you kanna mavens

#1

Question for you kanna mavens

Hank Knight

Some years ago I attended a workshop in Maine taught by Craig Vandal Stevens. He is a user of Japanese tools and had several kanna in his kit that were very impressive. During the workshop, one of the students acquired a new kanna and Craig set it up for him while the rest of us looked on. The plane had a double iron. The first thing Stevens did was toss the cap iron and remove the pin that wedged it in place. He then scraped the sole to create some relief behind the mouth and very carefully pared the width of the mortise (I don't know the proper name for it) that holds the iron to allow it to advance properly through the sole. Finally, he rounded the corners of the iron on a power grinder and sharpened it.

Some time later I requested, and my wife gave to me as a gift, a nice new kanna. That was 5 or six years ago, maybe longer. New Japanese planes arrive as kits that require the set-up I watched Stevens perform. I've come close several times, but I've yet to muster enough nerve to start reshaping the sole and paring the mortise on my plane. It's still sitting in its box. I did, however get as far as removing the cap iron and pin.

Hence my question: Is that a good idea? Craig Stevens certainly knows about Japanese planes, and he had no hesitation or even a comment about discarding the cap iron and pin. Since then, however, I have observed many other kanna users who have retained the cap iron. Is the cap iron on a Japanese plane necessary? Desirable? Does it function like a chipbreaker on a Western plane? What are the downsides of removing it? Craig Stevens' planes certainly seem to function well without the cap iron and pin. I'm about to work my nerve up to making another run at setting up my plane, but I'm confused about the cap iron. I would appreciate your thoughts and advice.

Thanks.

Hank

Re: Question for you kanna mavens

#2

Re: Question for you kanna mavens

Brian Holcombe

Hank, I prefer to keep the chipper it's a huge help on boards with grain reversals. It can help you tune your chip and eliminate tear out.

Here is a shaving from my Kunio plane, the chip exits like this, I didn't stretch out the shaving.


Re: Question for you kanna mavens

#3

Re: Question for you kanna mavens

david weaver

Functions the same way as a western plane, and will allow you to take heavy shavings without significant tearout. If you can always plane downgrain, then it's not really necessary.

What's not much fun is taking the cap iron out and leaving the pin in and taking heavy shavings - they get stuck on the pin.

If you want to remove the pin, you can always put it back in later. If you have trouble with tearout, then it would be a good time to return the pin.

Re: Question for you kanna mavens

#4

Re: Question for you kanna mavens

TomD

It is actually a pretty easy process, setting up a Japanese plane. I built my first one that I still use out of white oak (US kind) around 1979. I bought a scraper, but didn't really like the way it worked, so as an experiment I relieved the plane on a router table, it was a visible excavation, you could even see little burn marks from the router. All it proved was that it isn't critical. A simple way to do it if you have a fine set plane is to just take one cut from the mouth off the back, that gives you your relief. And you can so the hollowing with a cabinet scraper, or you can follow the indicated process with the correct tools, I am have done both. But the stuff isn't there when you take it out, what maters is you have a contact points at two points and a smooth flow of material between these.

I agree with what has been said that you can use the plane with the single blade, this is the traditional set-up, they didn't traditionally use double blades, but apparently adapted them from Chinese or western example. What they did do traditionally is change their tools to deal with the change in available wood, so if you are planing junk you need a plane that makes a nice job of that.

The simplest way for a hack to get the plane taking the shavings you see in the pics, finer than the one David showed (and it is a boon to have a plane that does a good job and removes wood) is to do the wave form them sand the plane bottom on some PSA on a reference surface. Yes it is an insult to suggest the same, but that is how I have set up planes for myself and others that won planing contests. It is like the crutches we were discussing on the main board, you can try scraping it perfectly, and if that isn't perfect first time out, reach for the PSA.

The main thing I learned from seeing a pro do it, is that it is like watching John Henry drive railway spikes. They pretty much beat the Kanna in there like splitting wood. The ones I made from just my best guesses and through poor workmanship were relatively loose, and worked great. The one I have since made work a little better because the blade is worked so hard it is very firmly held, and it returns to that precise setting with relative easy. So don't be shy, get that blade in there, bang it out, and then pare off the inked marks and it will eventually seat perfectly. If when you hammer the blade home it does not tighten, then you are probably fetching up on the bevel, pretty obvious when it happens but just to mention it.

Re: Question for you kanna mavens

#5

Re: Question for you kanna mavens

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Hank,

As the others have said, the chip breaker does perform this same function on a kanna. However, in doing the initial setup, the main blade is first fitted without the chipbreaker installed—the chipbreaker is not necessary to holding the main blade in place. Hence, some people (like Craig) use the kanna without the sub-blade (as it is sometimes called).

The main blade is lightly sprung within the abutments. Several years ago, I was curious about this and tested a half dozen Mosaku and a couple of other blades, and found a consistent spring or curvature of 1.5 to 3 thousandths amplitude along the length of the cutting face, unrelated to the hollow (ura). This spring, which you do not want to lap out by the way, will hold the main blade tightly in the abutments.

So you get the plane working first with the main blade, without installing the chipbreaker. Now, as to fitting the main blade to the bed, people who do this a lot use paring chisels. However, if you don’t do it regularly, I suggest doing the fitting with a rasp or float or scraper. You pencil the blade back with a soft pencil, insert it till it won’t go further, then pare down or rasp down the high spots; then iterate so that the blade progressively inserts further, until it is in cutting position.

The fit should not be tight until the last, say quarter or half inch, otherwise the kanna will deflect and possibly split. Bear in mind there is very little meat under the main blade, and a tight fit can make a bulge in the sole right behind the mouth opening, which will result in baffling and erratic planing—for this reason, it is good to remove a little material in this area, using a scraper plane (I have also used a very finely set shoulder plane, cutting cross grain). The last thing that should touch the wood you’re planing is the iron—the plane is riding on a ramp just in front of the mouth, then the iron cuts and there should be a slight clearance behind the iron so the heel is not dragging. [Note: this is for a smooth plane, not a shooting plane.]

The chipbreaker is fit to the main blade, by adjusting the ears. The ears are hammer adjusted if necessary until the shipbreaker occludes all light between it and the main blade, without rocking.

A zillion more things could be said—I’ll look for detailed instructions tomorrow.

Wiley

Re: Question for you kanna mavens

#6

Re: Question for you kanna mavens

TomD

"However, if you don’t do it regularly, I suggest doing the fitting with a rasp or float or scraper. You pencil the blade back with a soft pencil, insert it till it won’t go further, then pare down or rasp down the high spots; then iterate so that the blade progressively inserts further, until it is in cutting position."

It has long been my contention that the purpose of the crossways relief on the back of the blade, there are some fanciful alternative suggestions, is to ensure one has a lengthwise high spot to pare. It is tough to pare a full width shaving that is in the 10s with any chisel, but removing the same shaving form a transverse curve is relatively easy. The work is also reminiscent of scraping a bed on a mill or lathe. They don't try for full bearing, they go for the number of dots they get in a scare inch. It isn't necessary to have perfect bearing, a realatively small number of perfect points will work rather well, and over time because better bearing.

"The fit should not be tight until the last, say quarter or half inch, otherwise the kanna will deflect and possibly split."

Most of my planes have use Japanese white oak, but I have used stuff like cherry, maple, beech (works well), and white oak. I have never split any of them, and I work them hard. One wants to make sure they are held front and back of the blade, not by the sides, unless the blade is in sideways. Also remember there is virtually nothing you can do wrong that can't be fixed.

"The last thing that should touch the wood you’re planing is the iron—the plane is riding on a ramp just in front of the mouth, then the iron cuts and there should be a slight clearance behind the iron so the heel is not dragging. [Note: this is for a smooth plane, not a shooting plane.]"

Well said, an exception being jointers that may touch or very nearly touch at three points. This is not as big a deal as it might sound as they are normally set up to take one shaving thickness.

Re: Question for you kanna mavens

#7

Thanks, everyone

Hank Knight

Those are wonderfully helpful and encouraging replies. I'm going to give this a shot as soon as I finish my current project which has been derailed for a couple of weeks. I'll let you know how it works out. Thanks again.

Hank

Re: Question for you kanna mavens

#8

Re: Breaker

TomD

"Does it function like a chipbreaker on a Western plane?"

This has been answered, but to quibble a little:

- How does the breaker on the western plane work, anyway? Until recently people seem to think it was set fairly loose and didn't do all that much, whereas the Japanese breaker is independently adjustable, and there are lots of pics of it being set till it shoots the shaving straight up in the air, something one rarely sees on western planes (I don't think I have ever seen it). It is pretty hard not to set the breaker tight to the edge, or even past it, and to see what happens when you have it in various states, because you can't just align it and leave it, it is tuned with every use

- Does the breaker on a Japanese plane form the basis for the depth adjustment on the main blade. No.

- Does the breaker on a Japanese plane stiffen the main blade. The main blade is often as thick as a western combo, so it really isn't required.