Question for you kanna mavens
Hank Knight
Some years ago I attended a workshop in Maine taught by Craig Vandal Stevens. He is a user of Japanese tools and had several kanna in his kit that were very impressive. During the workshop, one of the students acquired a new kanna and Craig set it up for him while the rest of us looked on. The plane had a double iron. The first thing Stevens did was toss the cap iron and remove the pin that wedged it in place. He then scraped the sole to create some relief behind the mouth and very carefully pared the width of the mortise (I don't know the proper name for it) that holds the iron to allow it to advance properly through the sole. Finally, he rounded the corners of the iron on a power grinder and sharpened it.
Some time later I requested, and my wife gave to me as a gift, a nice new kanna. That was 5 or six years ago, maybe longer. New Japanese planes arrive as kits that require the set-up I watched Stevens perform. I've come close several times, but I've yet to muster enough nerve to start reshaping the sole and paring the mortise on my plane. It's still sitting in its box. I did, however get as far as removing the cap iron and pin.
Hence my question: Is that a good idea? Craig Stevens certainly knows about Japanese planes, and he had no hesitation or even a comment about discarding the cap iron and pin. Since then, however, I have observed many other kanna users who have retained the cap iron. Is the cap iron on a Japanese plane necessary? Desirable? Does it function like a chipbreaker on a Western plane? What are the downsides of removing it? Craig Stevens' planes certainly seem to function well without the cap iron and pin. I'm about to work my nerve up to making another run at setting up my plane, but I'm confused about the cap iron. I would appreciate your thoughts and advice.
Thanks.
Hank




