New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Butlers's Desk - Miter Edge Dovetails

Posts

Re: Butlers's Desk - Miter Edge Dovetails

#2

Re: Butlers's Desk - Miter Edge Dovetails

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Your joinery is indeed flauntable. Will you plane off the scribe lines at the miter? They strike me as distracting from the perfection of the joint.

On the side there appears to be a glued up panel that I might have though was the top except the piece already has its top. Whatever it is, and presuming it is a panel for somewhere, I would have glued it sap to sap, leaving what will be a lighter colored area symmetrical in the middle.

Re: Butlers's Desk - Miter Edge Dovetails

#3

Re: Butlers's Desk - Miter Edge Dovetails

Brian Holcombe

Thanks Bill! The gauge marks are gone from the front currently (I'm a few weeks ahead IRL, but it takes me some time to write up everything).

There are two panels there, one is book matched, that will be the cabinet back. The other is getting sawn up into a shelf and small sliding doors so one edge of sap will be gone. I did not book match because I don't like planing book matched panels if I can avoid it.

Re: Butlers's Desk - Miter Edge Dovetails

#4

that was a useful tidbit

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"I did not book match because I don't like planing book matched panels if I can avoid it. " I thought the problem was my lack of planing experience.

I find panels made up to at least look book matched look best so I just sand them. Those two boards joined with the sap streak running down the middle would look stunning. Once can always sand outside and that is what I do.

Re: Butlers's Desk - Miter Edge Dovetails

#5

Re: that was a useful tidbit

Brian Holcombe

Hopefully my approach will play through to a nice appeal. If not, then I'll be gluing them up a second time. The shelf won't matter, it is unseen for the most part, but the sliding doors must look good when the desk is opened.

If you click the link in my original post you'll see the book matched back panel. I did not know if this desk will always be against a wall so I wanted that panel to look good.

I plane book matches, but much easier to plane sequenced boards and anymore I find sequenced boards more appealing in cabinet work.....but I'm on the fence about the sapwood.

Re: Butlers's Desk - Miter Edge Dovetails

#6

Re: that was a useful tidbit

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I would not, and do not, use sapwood in formal pieces. But I will use it if I can make an attractive contrasting pattern with it in an informal (modern) piece.

See the cabinet side for example


Re: Butlers's Desk - Miter Edge Dovetails

#7

Re: that was a useful tidbit

Brian Holcombe

That looks nice Bill! I like those spear tip drawer dividers as well.

Re: Butlers's Desk - Miter Edge Dovetails

#8

pointy dividers

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I saw this style on a Chester County, PA piece. Something of the kind is essential when there is a profile on the front of the case side. They usually attract some scrutiny from woodworkers for they are not commonly encountered.

Re: Butlers's Desk - Miter Edge Dovetails

#9

Re: pointy dividers

Brian Holcombe

I believe they're fairly common on sashimono as well, since it is desirable to be able to apply a continuous chamfer.

I strongly considered using spear point miters for the butlers desk center divider along with housed tenons, but ultimately decided on the sliding dovetail. If it were for me, I think I would have used the spear point miter, but It's not for me and the end user wanted a clean case.

I always debate how much visible joinery to incorporate and lately I've been thinking that less is more. I have it on the skirt and at the corners and IMO that's probably more than enough.