Some Thoughts on Scraper Planes, etc
Christopher Fitch Memphis
I meant to type up this reply a few days ago but I was busy.
In any case, here's my thoughts on your question (I noticed over on your power tools post that you have the Veritas Holder).
I have a decent amount of scraping tools: A variety of Cabinet Scrapers, Two Scraper Planes, and a few other scraping tools.
- First I have the Veritas Scraper Holder. This is a fine tool that I've had for a while. It is versatile and really helps with holding scrapers. It holds quite well and you can even vary the curve you want on the scraper itself by turning the knob in the center. Of course it has a large benefit in that it uses standard card scrapers and you can just take it out if you need to. You said you have this so you should know all about it. I've mentioned these details in case anyone else is interested.



- Second I have the Veritas Cabinet Scraper that is similar to the old Stanley Scraper. Another fine tool. It's meant for scraping wide surfaces. You can vary the curve on the scraper with the knob.


- I have the Lie-Nielsen Cabinet Maker's Scraper Plane which is similar to the Stanley No. 85. Beautiful and well-made tool. Handles tilt so you can get right against a side while scraping.

- I have the Veritas Scraping Plane that is similar to the Stanley 112. You can buy a heavy blade that cannot be curved. Easily adjustable.

With all this, here's my thoughts after using all these items for a number of years. if I just had to have one tool, it would be the Veritas Scraper Holder. It's worked well for me. I know you mentioned you still have issues. I can't really offer anything in regards to that since it's worked fine for me.
If I had to buy something else in addition to the Veritas Scraper Holder, I'd get the Veritas Scraper Place. It's a plane...and it's easy to use. I used it a week ago to scrap some knotty cedar and it worked fine. It is a bit heavy but that's not an issue for me. It's easy to adjust and the blade is easy to maintain.
I'd say you can do the bulk of your scraping with that and then use your scraper holder for local areas and a bare scraper for tight spots.
I would not get the other two tools. Please note they are both good but I never use them.
The Veritas Cabinet Scraper is a bit unwieldy compared to the Scraper Plane. It's heavy for it's size and I find it harder to control in use compared to the plane.
The Lie-Nielsen Cabinet Maker's Scraper Plane is a well-made and beautiful tool with excellent handles. However, it's a very very specialized tool that has very limited usefulness, at least for me. You could use it as a general scraper plane but you cannot curve the blade and you have to contend with the corners on the blade. Also, the blade is smaller and you would need to work alot to cover the same area is a regular scraper plane. Unless you have a need for it, I advise against it. If you do need its unique abilities, then you won't be disappointed in it.
I don't have anything to say about the Lie-Nielsen Large Scraper Plane other than two things: I'm sure it's well made and you *cannot* curve the blade like you can with the Veritas version nor can you have a thinner or thicker blade option like the Veritas (this is what caused me to buy the Veritas over the Lie-Nielsen years ago).
That's about all I can say...hope this helps