New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Wiley - I Finally Copied Your Jack Plane

Posts

Wiley - I Finally Copied Your Jack Plane

#1

Wiley - I Finally Copied Your Jack Plane

david weaver

Wiley - if you recall the propotions of the mathieson Jack that you sent me. I took the opportunity to remake a jack for myself and copied the proportions of it (I had made a couple previously, but one is more of a closed-handle fore, and the second I made the handle too big for me and I'll have to find it a home).

It's funny, the 17" mathieson fore has almost identical proportions, except that it's much fatter and wider, and the handle is right on the back of the plane due to clearance issues with a closed handle.

At any rate, I used the handle off of your jack as the template and pretty much have a straight up copy for proportions.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2yYnjUhVvzk

(plane in use is sometime just after 7 minutes - very comfortable proportions, a plane that will never cause pain in use. Brian Holcombe is already using a jack that has these same proportions and layout - I noticed when I made his and another one for Chris Griggs, that I was shipping off nicer planes than I was keeping. So, I guess I've copied it a couple of times before, but each time, I never got to keep it long enough to appreciate it).

Thanks again, by the way.

Re: Wiley - I Finally Copied Your Jack Plane

#2

Re: Wiley - I Finally Copied Your Jack Plane

Kees

I used a picture from one of David's posts on woodcentral as a template for my jackplane handles. I didn't realise it was a plane from you Wiley! So thanks from me too.


img

Re: Wiley - I Finally Copied Your Jack Plane

#3

Re: Wiley - I Finally Copied Your Jack Plane

David weaver

That's definitely the same handle pattern. Those look great! I'm sure they work well, too.

Re: Wiley - I Finally Copied Your Jack Plane

#4

Re: Wiley - I Finally Copied Your Jack Plane

Kees

There not too bad ;)

I'm still searching for th eideal camber. The often proclaimed 6" to 8" for a jackplane seems a bit too much for me. I now have the smaller jack set at 8"and intend to use it for scrub like work, mostly across the grain, and the larger jack has rather less camber. That seems like a nice compromise and leaves me in control over the plane in "with the grain" work, instead of hanging on for dear life.

Re: Wiley - I Finally Copied Your Jack Plane

#5

Re: Wiley - I Finally Copied Your Jack Plane

david weaver

I'd offer a suggestion, but I have no clue what camber my jack planes have. I just clip the corners on the grinder and then round everything to what looks good by eye (and what projects in the middle of the plane). I have different camber on the two jack-ish planes I've kept, though. The heavy closed handle jack has a shorter radius than the one in the video (I just don't know what that radius might be).

They really work a charm, though.

Re: Wiley - I Finally Copied Your Jack Plane

#6

Re: Wiley - I Finally Copied Your Jack Plane

Kees

In reality I do them by eye too, it just talks easier with a number, so I drew some curves on a piece of paper and compared the irons to those curves.

Re: Wiley - I Finally Copied Your Jack Plane

#7

Re: Wiley - I Finally Copied Your Jack Plane

david weaver

I like the more gradually cambered jack (which is the one in this video) for most things, too.

I've got a continental smoother somewhere with a really sharply cambered iron, but it's extremely uncommon that I have a use for it. It's got a nice soft freres iron that taught me a lesson, though (one of those types that when you hone it, you are almost sure it won't hold an edge, and then it does so, beautifully).

More gradual camber like on this jack is still plenty fast enough for saw marks, but you can get a decent degree of flatness laterally and get continuous shavings through the plane rather than wasting time just cutting peaks off of subsequent swipes.

Re: Wiley - I Finally Copied Your Jack Plane

#8

Re: Wiley - I Finally Copied Your Jack Plane

Kees

Here's a picture from another angle. Lousy Iphone pic, sorry. I avoided using sandpaper, just rasp work, a scraper and burnishing a bit with a stick of wood. In a better picture you could probably see a little bit of facetting still.


img

Re: Wiley - I Finally Copied Your Jack Plane

#9

Re: Wiley - I Finally Copied Your Jack Plane

david weaver

I do the same thing to finish. I have used a curved scraper a few times to reduce the faceting (it does by a lot), but am sometimes too lazy to find it. I like the card scraped handle, it's not perfectly smooth at first but use will make it smooth. Easier to protect the lines on the side of the handle without sandpaper ( I think George mentioned to me that he wrapped sandpaper around something to finish handles - but that may have just been a suggestion when I was asking how to protect the lines). I protect the lines now by using a single cut metal file to get up close to them.

Your two samples of beech look very different from each other. (the handle in that picture looks very good, by the way. Very crisp and the lines don't have any funny spots.

Re: Wiley - I Finally Copied Your Jack Plane

#10

Re: Wiley - I Finally Copied Your Jack Plane

Kees

Thanks. And indeed the beech I used was quite a mixed bunch, not really premium wood.

Re: Wiley - I Finally Copied Your Jack Plane

#11

Re: Wiley - I Finally Copied Your Jack Plane

david weaver

Mine varies a lot, too, but it came from the same place all at once, so it's more of a color variance.

My couple of small european beech sticks look different, and I got two green sticks off of ebay, and they are not as nice as the stuff that came from horizon.

Yours doesn't look bad, just different.

Re: Wiley - I Finally Copied Your Jack Plane

#12

Wow!  I sent David a lemon, and

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

he has made lemon chiffon pie! A wonderful looking and acting plane, and Kees' planes are likewise fabulous. Credit to Alex. Mathieson, of course, plus David and Kees.

The entire jack/fore plane continuum (and I suppose one could add the scrub) is some of the most satisfying in all of planing IMO. I prefer the longer end--17" to 20" give or take--and cambers of 1/32" to 3/64" on a 2" to 2-1/4" wide iron. But surely it all depends on how steep are the hills and valleys in the rough stock you're dealing with. What I have received, rough-sawn, is pretty tame, so a longer plane and lightish camber get it ready to try plane quick.

Beautiful planes, David and Kees!!

Wiley