New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Butler's Desk - Build

Posts

Re: Butler's Desk - Build

#2

Never seen joinery like that

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

referring to PIC 2. Anxious to see where that is going.

Why the massive "rails" (horz. pieces), if we can call them that.

The legs look heavy for the size of the piece, but having never encountered a Butler desk I don't know what the final effect will be.

Re: Butler's Desk - Build

#3

Re: Never seen joinery like that

TomD

It would be at the right stage for a joinery on a table where the legs were later tapered, but not sure whether that is where this is headed, since the design influence often has some Japanese to it.

Re: Butler's Desk - Build

#4

Re: Never seen joinery like that

Brian Holcombe

Thanks for the questions Bill!

I debated the legs quite a bit, they will have a round over on the outside corner. They're heavy, same with the skirt. hopefully it will not feel exceptionally heavy when the case is attached.

My experience with these style tables without lower stretchers is that if people lean against them it puts a huge amount of pressure on the joinery. I built the joinery to account for that.

The benefit is that even without the rear stretcher seated with wedges the table is solid.

Re: Butler's Desk - Build

#5

Re: Never seen joinery like that

Brian Holcombe

No plans to taper them, with a heavy round over they won't look heavy, at least I feel the desk I have made for myself does not appear overly heavy.

Re: Butler's Desk - Build

#6

Re: Never seen joinery like that

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I would have no reservation assembling a dining table of much greater size with rails that deep using simply a M&T joint, and I have. It's how tables have been made for centuries in the US and I suppose many other places. Centuries old antiques show that a straightforward M&T is sufficient for a table or anything resembling a table.

But, I can imagine that joints that complicated are fun to make once you get good at it. Did you come up with this joinery or is it common somewhere?

Re: Butler's Desk - Build

#7

Re: Never seen joinery like that

Brian Holcombe

The rails are 3.5" tall, so not huge. Dining tables like you are talking about have a solid skirt around the entire perimeter, this does not because it has drawers in the front.

I've built a similar table in the past and wanted this one to be a bit stronger against racking in the front because it will be carrying a cabinet as well.

This is my design, it's similar to Roubo's bench leg joinery but with a few additions. My dovetail tapers to self tighten the joint, my tenon is wedged to lock the joint and haunches were added to make the engagement the full height of the skirt.

Re: Butler's Desk - Build

#8

Re: Butler's Desk - Build

Hank Knight

I like the joinery a lot and agree with Bill: it must be fun to do.

Re: Butler's Desk - Build

#9

Re: Butler's Desk - Build

Brian Holcombe

Thank you!

That's very true, I enjoy the heck out of cutting some crazy joinery. It can be very challenging which helps me maintain my thought-free mind of concentration.