New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Addendum to Derek's recent column in PW

Posts

Addendum to Derek's recent column in PW

#1

Ellis Walentine

Addendum to Derek's recent column in PW

Ellis Walentine

I much enjoyed Derek Cohen's recent "End Grain" column in the June issue of Pop Wood. The writing is charming and his points are well made, and taken.

To synopsize, if I may, the gist is that it makes the most sense to do a primary flattening of a board on a tailed jointer, as opposed to spending much precious time hand-planing warps and cups out of rough timber. He also makes a case for having equipment with matching capacities, or, rather, wonders why our jointer and planer width capacities are usually different (8" jointer vs 13" planer, for example), and how neither of them necessarily matches our bandsaw resaw capacity. This bears out my longstanding appreciation for my 10" Inca jointer/planer machines, which I've been using since 1979. If I were going to be outfitting a new shop, I'd probably go for an even more substantial 12" floor-model machine like the Hammer unit pictured in the article.

I did want to comment on Derek's recommendation to resaw away gross excess thickness rather than reducing it all to chips by endless passes through the thicknesser. While I agree with this, I think it's fair to qualify this with a suggestion that, unless you resaw equally from both sides of the board, you do run the risk of upsetting the moisture gradient in the board and creating some kind of undesired movement, most likely cupping. If you know that your lumber is nicely acclimated, you can often get away with it. Using a thickness planer, though, makes it possible to remove equal amounts of material from both sides by alternating them through the planer.

The other point I would make is in regard to the procedure of thicknessing the second side of the board (after jointing one face). As Derek suggests, the idea is to gauge around all sides of the board and plane to your lines with whatever combination of hand planes works for you. I would add a suggestion to first hand-plane shallow chamfers down to your gauge lines prior to jointing. The chamfers give a clear visual reference as you plane, so you don't have to spend time to constantly check your progress by looking at the edges. When the chamfers are gone, the board is thicknessed. It's a small trick, to be sure, but I thought it might be interesting to anyone who hadn't tried it.

Anyhow, thanks, Derek, for a useful and enjoyable piece.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Ellis

Re: Addendum to Derek's recent column in PW

#2

Thanks for the summary

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I abandoned Pop Woodworking a few months ago so I would not have seen his article.

We all have limited time so we must choose where to spend it. For a hobby we largely choose to spend the time on what we enjoy. So for example, if one enjoys making joints, carving, finishing, or anything else beyond stock preparation, one will have more time to do what they most enjoy if stock preparation is done with the aid of an apprentice plugged into the power grid.

I have an 8" jointer, 20" band saw and an 18" planer, the planer being a left over from the hardwood business. I never thought about the mismatch in sizes because it has never been a limitation. I think "flattening" on a jointer, or with a hand plane, is done more often than necessary.

Re: Addendum to Derek's recent column in PW

#3

Re: Addendum to Derek's recent column in PW

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Ellis

Thanks for the heads up and kind words. I have not received my copy of PW (I have a subscription), and so not seen it in print.

I did not set out to write an article, but emailed Megan (Fitzpatrick, Editor) in response to an article in a previous edition by Chris Schwarz. Chris had recommended a planer ("thicknesser" on my side of the Pond) as the machine to use if seeking to have the minimum of equipment. That is, to use it as a jointer with a sled, or after a jack plane. This is a common recommendation. I just wanted others to know that there was an alternative method, and one that I believe is actually easier. Megan liked the letter and asked to turn it into a short article. As is the case, there were a number of cuts to fit all I wrote into one page (never being one to use one word where several would do :) ). I hope that there was enough clarity remaining.

The other point I would make is in regard to the procedure of thicknessing the second side of the board (after jointing one face). As Derek suggests, the idea is to gauge around all sides of the board and plane to your lines with whatever combination of hand planes works for you. I would add a suggestion to first hand-plane shallow chamfers down to your gauge lines prior to jointing. The chamfers give a clear visual reference as you plane, so you don't have to spend time to constantly check your progress by looking at the edges. When the chamfers are gone, the board is thicknessed. It's a small trick, to be sure, but I thought it might be interesting to anyone who hadn't tried it.

I think this is a great tip, and it would have been one I included had the article been longer. Indeed, I wrote about it here 10 years ago, and it is on my website in a pictorial (and recall Larry Williams subsequently posting a link to an Old Tools post describing this tip a century earlier - just to prove that there is nothing original around) ..


Link: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/Furniture/AThicknessingTechnique.html

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Addendum to Derek's recent column in PW

#4

Re: In the states...

david weaver

...at least, we have enough of us who are fat (me included) that we could stand to do all of the dimensioning by hand just to keep us from turning into a tub of jello.

The planer vs. jointer if you only have one piece of equipment is probably something that won't be settled, who knows? If I couldn't plane square, I'd want a jointer.

By this time next year, I hope to have no power tools in my shop (except maybe drills, one router and a track saw), but I will probably keep a thickness planer on the off chance that the mrs. wants me to build something I don't want to build.

Hand jointing and rough sawing boards is one of my favorite things to do in the shop - thickness planing, if I have to do it, I view as exercise and a chance to get better at it, but it's not as enjoyable as the jack-try jointing (I have no power jointer and never had a good one even when I had one). A stick that can go in the power planer with a jack/try (maybe something four feet long and 7 -10 inches wide) is only a couple of minutes of planing.

I'm glad I'm not a beginner with the need to go through reading about all of this stuff again.

Re: Addendum to Derek's recent column in PW

#5

Re: In the states...

John in NM

One method of exercise I've been using is splitting wood with two 6 lb mauls and some wedges for the really stubborn stuff. Highly recommended :D

I suspect vigorous planing tops any other shop task for endurance though - kind of like cycling for the upper body.

Re: Addendum to Derek's recent column in PW

#6

Strongly disagree - Driving a stake through Krenov

TomD

On the whole match up thing, I started out along that line because of the Krenov books. I remember going to Mahogany Materpieces at one point and lusting after their cast iron over under planer/jointer, up to 24" in width!!!

But over time it really hasn't mattered. Even a guy like me who gets a fair amount of his wood with his 36" bar Alaska mill, the vast majority of my material fits on my 8" jointer. Elis has mentioned his excellent Inca 10" well with the rebating facility on a standard jointer, you can easily joint 10 inch boards.

In the real world the cost of widening a planer seems to be less than the cost of widening a jointer with it's long tables. (most of the euro machines I have seen that are matched are short jointer machines, even in the house prices range). So there will always be a temptation to go wider with the planer. Krenov's ideas preceded the easy availability of cheap portable planers. They could make much wider, cheap, portable planer type low cost planers, if the demand was there. Krenov also does not seem to have used planes for breaking out wood, with his skills he could have easily prepped anything in the size range he worked, on his bench, and worked from a wide planer alone. Instead he had the Quixotic combo of a full size bench, small hand planes, a decent jointer, and a nearly useless planer. Read the memo Jim!

The real test of how this sorts out is also in Derek's response. Get woodworkers over here to shelve the word jointer, an move to the words planer and thicknesser that are descriptive of the actual functions, and we will be moving ahead. The idea that the jointer is the name, is based on the practice of edge jointing rough boards then passing passing panels through the planer, without ever flattening one side on a "jointer". That is somewhat rare these days in fancy circles, though it is still an option for sleeve storage.

Re: Addendum to Derek's recent column in PW

#7

Re: Strongly agree! - Buy my Inca 10"

TomD

It's spring, everything Ellis says is true. On the off chance someone wants to buy an Inca 10 inch in Toronto, planer only function 250 Canadian, all parts for planer seem to be present, but sold as jointer only...

Re: Addendum to Derek's recent column in PW

#8

Re: Bevelling edges

TomD

Cool trick, though to me you need to know where to plane the bevels to, which if that was not a problem, why is just shooting for the line a problem. Also at a 45 degree bevel you are dropping to the line 44% faster than when just planing, which is what it is, as the kid's say.

I think I would prefer to pursue David Charlesworth's approach. He has noted that when you use a standard knife gauge to mark thickness, that is leaves a beveled edge on the side of the mark we are shooting for. He has suggested having on gaugerr set up with a reversed blade so the hard line is on the size we are cutting to. That makes the gauge a little lest self registering, but it is a neat point one could use in a number of situations...

If one gave a toss. In the real world, the first face can be planed without any fancy marking tools, or rules, or whatever. Some kind of guideline is important in say soundboards where the boards are carefully prepared to 1/10 of mm. Though even in that case, feel is a better guide than numbers, unless you are measuring modulus. In most cases the second side doesn't really mater. Which is why a lot of old furniture was made in ways that concealed the fact that the second face had been left unplanned. But maybe there is a practical stopping point short of a 1 thou tolerance, but not rough either. About the only place I can see a huge problem is in drawers where the second face is naturally the outside of the sides, and may be a part of the drawer fit. But even there it is workaroundable.

The main point is that machining the second face just makes most steps easier. So why not. But does it need to be machined to a thou. You can get real close by simply observing parallelism. Beyond that you can use feel. It is easy to tell when you enter the line boundary, then you know from experience how many more passes you need. In other more demanding cases you may have already moved to calipers. But rather than creating extra steps, one can rely on feel or simple marks and end up further ahead in the long run. The whole world isn't flat for that mater, at some point the training wheels have to come off for projects that are impractical to measure.

Re: Addendum to Derek's recent column in PW

#9

Re: Addendum to Derek's recent column in PW

Curt Putnam

In a one machine OR the other, it is worthy to note that jointers use up more floor space but are quieter. Portable planers with their universal motors are screaming banshees. Whether or not it is correct I plane each board in a set as little as possible to get it flat. After the entire set is done I find the thinnest board and then plane the others to that. As far as the symmetry thing goes I have a 6" jointer and a 13" planer. Preserving thickness allows for taking the glued up 12" board (half panel) and running it through the planer again to re-flatten.

Re: Addendum to Derek's recent column in PW

#10

Ellis Walentine

Not Jim's fault

Ellis Walentine

Let's give Jim a break here. Granted, for most purposes, it really doesn't matter whether your machines have same or similar capacities. It is a treat, though, to be able to resaw 10" stock, flatten it on a 10" (or better) jointer, and plane it to thickness on a 10" planer. That was the intent of my post. I thought about this a lot in my early days, before we had a 16" jointer and a 24" planer and a two-drum finishing sander. Even then, our capacities were all over the place, and we were using whatever machine we needed to get on to the next step of the job.

JK will be remembered for a lot of positives and negatives, but I have always appreciated his best lessons.

Re: Addendum to Derek's recent column in PW

#11

Re: Strongly disagree - Driving a stake through Kr

david weaver

I have done work with the thickness planer and no jointing. The bench I built last year ... Never face jointed any of the ash and it went together fine. Saved time, too.

Re: Addendum to Derek's recent column in PW

#12

Re: In the states...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

...at least, we have enough of us who are fat (me included) that we could stand to do all of the dimensioning by hand just to keep us from turning into a tub of jello.

The planer vs. jointer if you only have one piece of equipment is probably something that won't be settled, who knows? If I couldn't plane square, I'd want a jointer.

By this time next year, I hope to have no power tools in my shop (except maybe drills, one router and a track saw), but I will probably keep a thickness planer on the off chance that the mrs. wants me to build something I don't want to build.

Hand jointing and rough sawing boards is one of my favorite things to do in the shop - thickness planing, if I have to do it, I view as exercise and a chance to get better at it, but it's not as enjoyable as the jack-try jointing (I have no power jointer and never had a good one even when I had one). A stick that can go in the power planer with a jack/try (maybe something four feet long and 7 -10 inches wide) is only a couple of minutes of planing.

I'm glad I'm not a beginner with the need to go through reading about all of this stuff again.

Well, I'm not fat - quite trim actually. I run every day - and I do not need the extra exercise. I doubt that planing will keep you fit ... probably lead to a coronary if you are over weight. Still, I am now officially an Old Fart (66 years in January) and spent 20 years jointing and thicknessing with planes (with just the use of tablesaw for ripping) before I invested in a thicknesser-planer and a jointer. The reason for buying machines is simply that there is no pleasure in roughing out timber, especially the concrete I use, and I can find no religious reason not to do so.

It struck me many years ago, when I discovered this rabid banshee called a lunchbox planer, that it was not only a recipe for tinnitus, but completely antisocial. Please reply if any of your neighbours disagree.

Now I do not know what you refer to as "rough sawn", but what I have is out of a saw mill, and complete with twists and cups. Removing these with a jack plane is definitely doable - I've done it enough to develop tendonitis several times - but I will leave it for the young guns. Instead, with the maturity and wisdom becoming my age, I now concentrate my efforts on the important part of furniture building ... not that I have abandoned the scrub, jack and jointer, just that I bring them into the game tactically.

I received a couple of complimentary magazines in the mail today - thank you Megan! - and had a chance to review my article. It reminded me to mention that the strategy I outline there is just another option. It is always good to have options.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Addendum to Derek's recent column in PW

#13

Re: In the states...

david weaver

Pace depends on planing. I guess compared to some americans, i'm not that fat, but I am enough overweight that I could do something about it. I already do cardio exercise, however, at a 160 target heart rate for 150 minutes a week. There's no risk of a heart attack.

I can't speak for a guy who weighs 300 pounds and doesn't do any exercising.

As far as making exercise out of it, you'd have to plan ahead of time and wear a heart rate monitor, but I would bet I could meet the target heart rate if I had the work lined up ahead of time, either to joint or thickness. I'm sure I could work my two planes for a half an hour session before sharpening (jack and try plane), both my heart rate and the time interval between sharpenings would benefit from heavy shavings.

I have no issue with a plug in thickness planer. Mine is no louder in total than the DC580 planer a friend uses (at least before he changed the head to a spiral head) and ear muffs here are often on sale at HF for $2.99. I wouldn't use them to fire artillery rounds, but they offer plenty of hearing protection for a thickness planer. Nobody else in the house has complained about my planer, I don't use it with the door open so I doubt the neighbors know it exists.

And it has two great benefits over a more expensive planer. 1) I've never had to run 220v electricity here, which wouldn't be a huge deal since my panel is in the same garage where I work - but I don't even need to consider it, and 2) I never feel like I have to give a $350 planer too much respect in taking it easy or worrying about breaking it. Just run it hard and let it go.

But I still can't see any reason why the average person can't dimension their boards entirely by hand. If output rate is given as a reason why not, that's just plain BS. Most people only build a couple of things per year, and they spend far more time watching TV or wasting time - far less satisfying than getting the circulatory system going. You also build skill doing the rough work, which nobody likes to admit. Sawing and planing always build skill and speed elsewhere. Now, if people don't have the desire or skill to do it, that's fine. The oft-made suggestion of lack of practicality has much more to do with lack of skill. It's also extremely easy to plane panels, etc, within a hundredth of their desired size. I sized some cabinet sticking last week and did something I would never otherwise do, which is measure the thickness of a few sticks in four places. I face jointed the sticks, and then marked them for thickness and thicknessed them with a try plane (narrow wood thicknesses just as fast, in this case the sticking was wide enough that it needs two passes). The result of marking for 0.75 was somewhere 0.74-something, and no measurement off of the calipers differed by more than 5 thousandths around the board. The shavings I took were thicker than the variance.

Re: Addendum to Derek's recent column in PW

#14

Re: In the states...

david weaver

Splitting wood is extremely satisfying!!

It takes some planning with the jack plane to keep the pieces flowing on the bench, but if planned out well, it's like any other exercise (if you make it like such) where you can choose to either do it at half level to keep from getting tired, or you can push it and push through the tiredness to keep your heart rate up. Other than finishing and face jointing, though, it's pretty hard to keep up the heart rate.

Same with splitting, especially if you have big rounds, but splitting works better if you have a setter to keep you swinging.

Henry Ford put together excursions or camps for white collar people to get out into the woods and swing axes, etc as a recreational activity. I can understand why.

Re: Addendum to Derek's recent column in PW

#15

Re: Something is wrong..

david weaver

...in planing if hand or wrist problems come up from planing by hand.

One of the reasons I abandoned doing anything other than copying what people a couple of hundred years ago figured out is that a lot of the modern planes are really uncomfortable to use with a standard bench. Wrist soreness, awkward proportion, etc. The original handles on old try planes and jack planes let you plane with nothing but fatigue.

Some of the more modern freelancing designs that amateurs do are even worse. If most of us are honest, we will admit we've made tools before understanding design and came up with tools that are outright painful to use.

I have mild arthritis in my hands, doing something like coping out a plane handle for a couple of minutes really makes my hands feel like they've been bruised all over, but planing with properly designed planes never causes anything other than being tired.

Re: Addendum to Derek's recent column in PW

#16

Hyperbole ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

... is the use of exaggeration as a rhetorical device or figure of speech.

You are entirely too serious, or literal, about this topic. TGIF. :)

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Addendum to Derek's recent column in PW

#17

Re: logical fallacies *LINK*

Steve Voigt

I was wondering what sort of logical fallacy it is to dismiss someone's argument by claiming they are "too serious." So I consulted the Master List (link is below). At first I thought it was #66, Paternalism, but then I realized that #92, Tone Policing, was the better fit. ;)

Getting back on topic (but still relating to logical fallacies), it is interesting to me how this discussion can unfold with no reference to price. For some people money is no object, and good for them. But if you want to work wood and have limited funds, the following are good to keep in mind:

- For under $100 (if you are resourceful), you can get a vintage jack and jointer and flatten/thickness any size panel, to a level of finish that would require a 5-figure investment if done by machine.

- As machines go, lunchbox planers are cheap, and with 12" or 13" capacity, they will handle the majority of boards one is likely to use. Excluding glued-up panels, of course. A comparably priced 'lectric jointer is going to be in the 4"-6" range, and thus far less useful. So, for someone who has $300-$400 to spend on a machine, the lunchbox planer is unquestionably* the better buy.

- If you have a LOT more than that to spend, it might make sense to get a jointer rather than a planer, to get a combination machine, or to "match capacities." But only if you are fabulously wealthy like Derek! :D

* "unquestionably" = arguing from authority, another logical fallacy. ;)


Master List of Logical Fallacies

Re: Addendum to Derek's recent column in PW

#18

Re: logical fallacies

david weaver

One of the things that always confuses me on the sliding scale of "what's important" in woodworking is the assumption that the finished amateur furniture is of some sort of paramount importance.

It's not important that we build anything, and probably near 100% of us would have more money in our pocket if we didn't. the talk of "getting on to the important" makes no sense. None of it is really very important unless it is a means of income (then it becomes very important, and I don't really know very many people building furniture for income).

None of us is really noted for furniture making, and i can go to three dozen dealers near home who have goods 150 years+ old that are better design and proportion than most of what I see made on here, and it sells for about the cost of materials for us to make something. If what we make doesn't end up with a relative, nobody will put any additional stock in any of it - it certainly won't be worth anything substantial. We make it almost 100% to please ourselves.

But comments on what we "need to do" and what's "important" is gripped on to by beginners, and I have no clue how many times I've seen that it's either "impossible" or "irrational" to rip wood by hand, or joint wood by hand, or that it leaves you only making simple furniture because you only have time for the "important stuff". Almost all of those comments are made by people who don't know how to dimension furniture by hand.

I can't really defend cost, I could afford nicer things, more space, better equipment, cleaner shop etc, but personally, it's not very fulfilling for me to work that way. There is some satisfaction in not spending the money, though, to me at least.

Re: Addendum to Derek's recent column in PW

#19

Hey John, is that...

Brad Chenoweth

one maul for each hand? ;>)

Re: Addendum to Derek's recent column in PW

#20

Getting good at the basics

Brian Holcombe

I decided that an apprenticeship in my own workshop was important for me to be able to work at a high capacity.

One learns a lot about wood by dimensioning by hand.

People talk about sawing to the line, I learned about sawing to the line by sawing over a thousand half-laps and miters by hand. All can be done by a machine, but then when I get onto the fibe work I have confidence to hit my mark.

This also helps refine tool selection.

Re: Addendum to Derek's recent column in PW

#21

Re: Strongly agree! - Buy my Inca 10"

Jake in Comber, Ontario

Tom, If you're serious, how do I contact you about this?

Re: Addendum to Derek's recent column in PW

#22

Re: Getting good at the basics

david weaver

The only person I've seen talk about that consistently is Warren, that the work isn't wasted time, it's an opportunity to build skill.

I'd bet that anyone who couldn't cut tenons as a beginner, if they did several projects with hand tools only - projects that didn't have a tenon - that they'd find they could saw a tenon after that pretty closely.

It also teaches you key parts of work. You can make a table with four legs that aren't perfectly identical and perfectly square in every way, but when you dimension by hand, you know what parts of the leg need to be square and which to ensure you get that way.

The guy who taught me to woodwork early on uses only power tools. we didn't get something milled correctly on $20K worth of power tools, and I still don't know what it was, but the base of my first book case is out of square because of it. I guarantee that would never happen with hand tools.

The hand-eye transfers over to every saw cut, chisel cut, and progression into carving that you would want to do (cutting mouldings, can't forget about that - that's far better when you don't have to rely on table saw cove cuts or moulding bits that work on a router table). Even a simple moulding cut by hand looks better than a repetitive looking machine-made moulding.

I would be willing to bet that if we took two woodworkers and gave one access to hand tools only, and the other access to both hand and power tools, that at the end of a given interval, the hand tool only woodworker would be building more interesting pieces. And they'd get to carved elements and interesting mouldings and joints a lot sooner.

Re: Addendum to Derek's recent column in PW

#23

Re: Getting good at the basics

Brian Holcombe

Exactly my same experience with machine tools in the spectrum of affordability to the hobbyist and also those machine tool operations which require multiple opposing reference faces.

I worked as a fabricator for a period of time ( hard to imagine I know, but I had an obsession with TIG welding as a youth) and we used to work via partial assemblies that would all come together in the end. This is much more easily done, in wood, with hand tools because the tools are mobile.

Re: Addendum to Derek's recent column in PW

#24

Re: Not Jim's fault

TomD

Not an intended knock on Jim. As I may have said, the tools that hopped over this were after his time. I'm 56 and I don't care if I ever acquire any new basic tools from here one in. It is perfectly possible that something better will come along, maybe those carbide spiral heads are better, don't care. Once he had his preferences, and laid them out for all to see, that's fine, but I am nor surprised that the tools most of us have are different. The engineering, the marketplace and the logic don't really support the plan. Let's say you do resaw a 10" panel, in Jim's work that would have probably ended up book matched, and you need a 20 inch planer to touch it, or you just do it by hand. (of course most of his pieces were smaller than the example.

I never met Jim, but I re-read his books often, and I think I may have the earliest and favorable review of his books on Amazon.

Re: Addendum to Derek's recent column in PW

#25

Re: Strongly agree! - Buy my Inca 10"

TomD

proaconstrictor a la yahoo.ca