Addendum to Derek's recent column in PW
Ellis Walentine
I much enjoyed Derek Cohen's recent "End Grain" column in the June issue of Pop Wood. The writing is charming and his points are well made, and taken.
To synopsize, if I may, the gist is that it makes the most sense to do a primary flattening of a board on a tailed jointer, as opposed to spending much precious time hand-planing warps and cups out of rough timber. He also makes a case for having equipment with matching capacities, or, rather, wonders why our jointer and planer width capacities are usually different (8" jointer vs 13" planer, for example), and how neither of them necessarily matches our bandsaw resaw capacity. This bears out my longstanding appreciation for my 10" Inca jointer/planer machines, which I've been using since 1979. If I were going to be outfitting a new shop, I'd probably go for an even more substantial 12" floor-model machine like the Hammer unit pictured in the article.
I did want to comment on Derek's recommendation to resaw away gross excess thickness rather than reducing it all to chips by endless passes through the thicknesser. While I agree with this, I think it's fair to qualify this with a suggestion that, unless you resaw equally from both sides of the board, you do run the risk of upsetting the moisture gradient in the board and creating some kind of undesired movement, most likely cupping. If you know that your lumber is nicely acclimated, you can often get away with it. Using a thickness planer, though, makes it possible to remove equal amounts of material from both sides by alternating them through the planer.
The other point I would make is in regard to the procedure of thicknessing the second side of the board (after jointing one face). As Derek suggests, the idea is to gauge around all sides of the board and plane to your lines with whatever combination of hand planes works for you. I would add a suggestion to first hand-plane shallow chamfers down to your gauge lines prior to jointing. The chamfers give a clear visual reference as you plane, so you don't have to spend time to constantly check your progress by looking at the edges. When the chamfers are gone, the board is thicknessed. It's a small trick, to be sure, but I thought it might be interesting to anyone who hadn't tried it.
Anyhow, thanks, Derek, for a useful and enjoyable piece.
Ellis Walentine, Host
Ellis
). I hope that there was enough clarity remaining.





