further defense of fine grits
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
If I was doing the initial shaping of plane blades a coarse wheel would be preferred. But for most of us the grinder is being used to restore the hollow after it has been ground away as part of routine sharpening. It is this task that I will focus on.
Background: I have hollow ground chisel and plane blades for many years. I have demonstrated it many times at club functions. My shop is used for club projects and I commonly invite participants to bring a plane blade or chisel to sharpen if they want to learn how. It is common that after a short demonstration someone that has never hollow ground is successfully sneaking up on a plane blade edge with a hollow grind. Nothing burns easier than a thin Stanley block plane blade yet I have never seen one, or anything else, even slightly discolored on my equipment with my technique, even in the hands of someone learning to hollow grind.
I have a 7” 3-phase grinder with a VFD that controls the rpm to any value from 0-3600. When I started out, or when I am starting someone out, I slow it to approximately half speed, though for myself I usually operate at max speed in many cases. I have a 60 and 120 Radiac pink wheel, H bond, mounted. I rarely use the 60 grit side. Both wheels are crowned. The rest is large surface area and butts nearly against the wheel. The rest is smooth and waxed to enable the tool to be slid across the rest with little resistance.
Heat: Ideally the abrasive particle is sharp. When sharp it mills a shaving from the metal and the heat from the work of milling the shaving is largely absorbed by the chip and ejected from the metal. A dull particle ploughs across the metal doing more work and generating more heat that is not effectively removed by the chip.
It follows that the secret to cool grinding is to be grinding with sharp particles. An abrasive that fractures to maintain sharp edges is important. A soft bond that wears to expose new particles is also important. The ejected worn particles accumulate around the grinder and for some that could be a problem. I isolate the grinder from the woodworking area (it is actually near the lathe where some particles of grit are not worrisome).
The goal: Once a straight square edge is established on a plane blade or chisel it is desirable to not loose this reference when grinding the hollow. When reestablishing the hollow, grinding should extend almost to the edge. If grinding extends past the edge it could result in a long session at the next stone to re-straighten the edge. Hence, in my hands, control of material removal is of upmost importance. The rate at which material goes away is never something I find lacking.
The Norton 3X: This wheel is not a cool grinding wheel by my standards. Anyone that thinks these relatively hard wheels grind cool have never experienced a cool grinding wheel. Further, it is not a wheel that makes any sense for most to buy. Why, gets us into a discussion of seeded gel (“ceramic”) abrasives. They enable a wheel to be made that holds its shape, lasts longer and grinds quickly, properties that are important in production grinding or maybe even for those grinding a lot of lathe tools. The Norton 3X wheel is 30% seeded gel abrasive. If you need this material buy an industrial wheel that is an SG wheel. It will be more expensive, but if you need the properties of a SG wheel then buy one, not a consumer product cheapened to make it affordable in woodworking stores.
As an aside, I found that I could buy ½” x 7” surface grinder wheels cheap. To explore wheels I bought a lot of them, in all sorts of particle sizes, bond hardness and particle composition. I settled on a combination of small particle size and as soft a bond as I could find which is usually H.