New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Crown compass plane

Posts

Crown compass plane

#1

Jack Guzman from Maine

Crown compass plane

Jack Guzman from Maine

Windsor chair builders that post videos and books I have learned from don't usually use this little tool for hollowing chairs. I bought one when I was starting out on a recommendation from the man who got me started. Fred Chellis. A former instructor with Michael Dunbar's Windsor Institute. Unfortunately,Fred died last year.

I started by following the methods taught by Dunbar,then Curtis Buchanan. I started with a gutter adze I modified from a flea market find. I got so I could do a fair job of roughing out a seat with it. Later after watching Curtis and then Elia Bizzarri. I abandoned the gutter adze and did most of my roughing out with a scorp. I found I did a cleaner job of hollowing with this method and it wasn't more work than with the adze. But a few seats back I picked up this poor neglected plane and tried it out in place of the scorp. I like it better. I get better control and I find I get alot less tearout so cleanup is easier. I still use the scorp but only for getting areas I can't get with the plane. I also use a small travisher that I cut the handles off of to get into tight curves and a larger travisher for smoothing out my plane marks.

I was surprised at how well the crown plane does the job. It is a bit more effort doing initial hollowing but it is good exercise. No harder than trueing up a twisted board with hand planes.

It is a light little thing but is capable of big bites. The curved surface of the seat bowl needs very little smoothing when it is set to take a light shaving.

One picture is of the plane in a seat I just hollowed out with it and the other is of the four tools I use most for hollowing seats.

Re: Crown compass plane

#2

Re: Crown compass plane

Bruce, a MN Galoot

That looks like just exactly what I need for the chair I'm working on. The ones I made in the past have been ground out with a side grinder and sandpaper (a disk with about 6 rocks on it). That method lacks control and finesse.

Are the planes commercially available or did you make it? It appears to be rounded in both directions on the sole. Is that the case?

Re: Crown compass plane

#3

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Crown compass plane

Jack Guzman from Maine

Crown is a brand name. The plane is made by the Crown Plane company of Bath Maine. Available online. Yes it is rounded both ways. I think I bought mine from Highland woodworking. They list it under "chairmakers tools".---Jack

Re: Crown compass plane

#4

Re: Crown compass plane

TomD

I always loved that plane, though I never botherd to buy one, and the compound curvature in two directions has not drawn me on to make one. I learned also from someone who learned from Dunbar (though I make no claim to have learned that much). He used the adze, scorp, plane, travisher, which never made much sense to me (though Ihighly regarded this guy's craftsmanship generally). I do think the cutting should start with something like an adge, any concerns about finish should be something that skill would overcome. There is a lot of material to remove in saddling a chair, or making a cello, or whatever. I have seen jazz guitar guys use those thumbnail sized finger planes to do a large job of hollowing, eventually developing RSIs. It would be cool to know how it was actually done as piecework by the none too well off. If you make your living as a knight of the round chair, it is hardly a hand to mouth existence...

Re: Crown compass plane

#5

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Crown compass plane

Jack Guzman from Maine

The problem with an adze is that you have to be very careful in your cuts. It is easy to create a gouge deeper than intended.My homemade adze is a clumsy tool. I find it easier to remove smaller amounts of material at a time. Less things to repair. Some day when I can afford it I will buy a nice hand adze and practice with it til I can use it without worry.Meanwhile that plane is just right for the job.

Also,the wood I use for my seats is white pine.It is easy to carve,very soft. If I decide to make a seat out of a hardwood I will have to use an adze.---Jack

Re: Crown compass plane

#6

Re: Crown compass plane

William Duffield

Is Crown Plane still in business. I see nothing on their website less than a decade old, except a couple of links replaced by hackers.

As with most skilled hand woodworking, I think the concept Chriss Schwarz calls "Coarse, Medium, Fine" is especially applicable to carving the bowl of a Windsor chair seat. The coarse work is often done with a bowl adze or a large gouge and mallet. Medium work is often done with a scorp or inshave. The fine work is often done with a travisher. This is the stage where I think Jack's Crown compass plane would work well. Since the curve of the bowl is not the same all over, a compass plane or a travisher can still leave facets.

There's nothing wrong with leaving some faceting, but if you don't like it, you can smooth the surface further with curved scrapers (maybe not so well in pine) or even sandpaper.

I bought a Lie-Nielsen 100 1/2 Squirrel tail convex sole block plane for this purpose, but the 3" radius in the width leaves more facets than I prefer.

Jack, what tasks do you do where you find you needed to cut the handles off of the travisher? Were the handles too low and running into the seat itself, or was something else getting in the way? I was watching Peter Galbert and Claire Minihan using the travishers they developed, and haven't seen any place on a chair seat that the handles don't clear the work.

Re: Crown compass plane

#7

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Crown compass plane

Jack Guzman from Maine

The travisher I cut the handles off was a small flea market find. I don't think it was designed with chair saddling in mind. The handles didn't curve upward like a chairmakers travisher does. They were level with the body and they hit the seat. It has a tighter curve than my other one so I can use it against the back of the seat where the curve is deeper.

The radius on the crown plane is relatively shallow so it doesn't leave alot of furrows on a concave surface such as the bowl of a seat. I also have a small squirrel-tail double curved plane. I tried it out early on but I found it to be too small to be useful here.---Jack

Re: Crown compass plane

#8

Re: Crown compass plane

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I have the curved squirrel tail plane, too, and I agree with your assessment. It's too small for a chair seat, too many facets left over.

Re: Crown compass plane

#9

Re: Crown compass plane

Steve Voigt

William,

Crown plane is still in business. If you click on the "purchase crown plane tools here" link, it takes you to an etsy store.

The company was founded by Leon Robbins, and he sold it to another guy, whose name I can't recall at the moment. That guy posts a lot on Instagram, so he's definitely still making planes. The planes are laminated, machine-made planes.

Re: Crown compass plane

#10

Re: Crown compass plane

Steve Voigt

Jack,

Looks good. I would like to try making a compass plane, so thanks for the info. I have a travisher I made, and it works well, but I am much more a cabinetmaker than a chair maker, so maybe I would find the plane more intuitive.

Regarding adzes, I have heard a few good things about Kestrel adzes, and I believe they sell the blade only, or maybe a kit…anyway, that might be a cost-conscious option.

Re: Crown compass plane

#11

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Crown compass plane

Jack Guzman from Maine

Before I got the crown I built a compass plane. I took a small woodie smoother and curved the sole both ways and ground the iron to match. Surprisingly it worked pretty good. At least until I could afford a scorp. All I did was eyeball the curves.---Jack

Re: Crown compass plane

#12

Re: Crown compass plane

TomD

I never had that much trouble with the guttering adze. Mine was one that Country Workshops sold, at the time it was sold handleless, which saves some money. So you may be correct about the tool making a difference. I don't do enough guttering for the difference to be me. And I also am willing to stop short. If one gets 50% or 75% of the material out with the adze, it saves a lot of planing, and makes for some practice that should eventually get one somewhere if one was doing the work on a regular basis. I do have a project coming up, a Nakashima chair, but that is shallower an cherry, so it may end up getting done more cautiòusly.

Re: Crown compass plane

#13

Re: Crown compass plane

Keith Newton

Jack, do you push this plane when using it, or pull it toward yourself?

I made one many years ago, with a big horn on the front so I could add more power to my left hand. As it turned out, I could get a lot more power by pulling it toward me, with my right hand on the front handle, by at least a factor of 2x.

Re: Crown compass plane

#14

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Crown compass plane

Jack Guzman from Maine

I wrap my hand around it and push it with the heel of my hand. ---Jack