Re: Another question and comment about sanding
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
Why did you use a power sander and not hand sanding- a practical as well as philosophical question?
Let me counter one potential response from the start. I have never seen any evidence that there is any difference in appearance in a planed vs sanded surface after a finish is applied that has the typical build of a shellaced, lacquered or varnished surface. So I don't accept that there is any practical final appearance advantage of one over the other unless the finish is minimalist and not typical of high end Period Furniture.
Personally I get as much satisfaction refining a surface to be finished with a sanding block as with a block plane and more so than with a scraper. I don't get any personal satisfaction from scraping. But then I don't like sharpening or using scrapers.
A sanding block enables one to become as engaged with the developing surface every bit as much as with a plane, and maybe more so. While sanding up the grit progression I am scrutinizing every detail of the surface, looking for duller spots or defective grain that need to be refined. By the end I know the details of the surface of that piece of wood every bit as well as the planer, and for me that is what it is all about.
Hi Bill
I did a lot of planing throughout with a double iron. This planed against the grain without tearout, leaving a good finish. It still required some scraping to produce an even surface ...

It is relevant to clarify that the aim of the last session was to level (make coplanar) the 8 drawer fronts. Although I worked to lines traced from a template I used for all the drawers, it is not possible to produce exact replicas with hand planing. There will always be some variation. This is most noticeable where the drawers join, where the levels did not match. In other words, the drawer fronts required fine tuning. Some needed a little removed in spots, and others (such as displayed) required flattening across the width.
The small Palm Smoother came out now to concentrate on smaller sections. For the most part it did a good job, but it was obvious when it hit reversing grain - as one expects not just from Jarrah, but also as the boards are bowed with the grain, effectively altering the grain direction. That was when the coarse scraper came out. This was smoothed off with a card scraper, then sanded, and then scraped again. (I chose not to explain this before since it sounded more complex that I imagined anyone would want to hear).
The sanding I did was with a hand block, NOT a power sander. It was used to refine the surface - just as you mention above.
The sanding was quick: I ran through 120/220/400 grit. The Mirka grits are amazing. With the vacuum cleaner connected, it is extremely efficient. There is no waste dust to clog up the sander to slow things down, and the Mirka grit, itself, lasts and lasts.




But even 400 grit is not as clear as the scraped finish I showed earlier (below again), and the reason why I scraped after refining the surface with sanding.

Regards from Perth
Derek