Humidor Build - Interior part 1
Brian Holcombe
Thanks for taking a look, comments and questions are encouraged.
https://brianholcombewoodworkerblog.wordpress.com/2016/04/02/humidor-build-interior-part-1/
Some highlights;


Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Humidor Build - Interior part 1
Brian Holcombe
Thanks for taking a look, comments and questions are encouraged.
https://brianholcombewoodworkerblog.wordpress.com/2016/04/02/humidor-build-interior-part-1/
Some highlights;


Re: Humidor Build - Interior part 1
Frank D. in Montreal
Hi Brian,
I'm following your blog enthusiastically... I've built a few humidors and all I can say about yours is that the quality of build and design is breathtaking. Your write-up is also quite complete, so I don't have any questions yet. Next time I build a humidor or small box I'll definitely be tempted to try the blind dovetails.
Thanks for posting,
Frank
questions
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
Why is the box lined with another box of different wood? What are the cylindrical tubs with the copper colored bands? I didn't get a feel for the size of this box.
Thank you!
Re: questions
Brian Holcombe
Bill, thanks for the questions! The outside box acts as a seal, to hold in the moisture and the liner is made from unfinished Spanish cedar which acts to maintain the humidity when the box is opened and then reclosed, without that it would exhaust all of the humidity quickly and require the element alone to restore humidity.
Those tubs are for drying rice for sushi, the small tub is a storage container and the large tub is for mixing the rice vinegar in with the rice.
More questions on humidity
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
I don' t understand the role of the cedar. How can it do anything that the inside of the other box can't do, namely absorb or release moisture?
From the perspective of knowing nothing about this device....... Apparently there is something in the box that contains water and releases it as needed to maintain the humidity inside the box at some value above outside conditions (the "element"?)
1. In the beginning the inside of the box is in equilibrium at a value determined by the element(which contains water?)
2. The box gets opened and some "damp" air escapes and is replaced by dryer air.
3. Box gets closed trapping air at lower humidity than the equilibrium value from step 1. The volume of this box is small. It will take at most a few milligrams, and possibly even less than 1 milligram, of water to re-saturate the box humidity, depending on how dry the replaced air is and how much was replaced. I suppose I could believe that the larger surface area of the inside wood surface would provide this initial water.
4. However, If the wood gives up water to the air this water must be replaced by water from the element thing to reestablish the wood's equilibrium water content water content as in step 1.
The only source of new water in the box is the element that I suppose contains water. I don't see any role the wood plays in maintaining box internal humidity.
On a woodworking note, how did you saw or whatever the outside box miters? What did you use along with the rasp dust for filling (glue of some sort?)?
Air at 100% RH contains about 19 mg of water/L of air.
Re: More questions on humidity
Brian Holcombe
Great questions!
Basically the top choices are Honduran mahogany, Okoume' and Spanish cedar (which is actually a mahogany) the reasons that these are the top choices are that these woods can absorb a lot of moisture without decaying and because they're porous and transfer moisture very well.
Spanish cedar, Okoume and Honduran Mahogany are the choices of top makers like Elie Bleu and Davidoff.
Now I'm sure other woods will work, but not sure exactly which ones and how long they will live, so building something like this I tend to rely on tried and true practices. I appreciate your inquisitive nature, but unfortunately that is all I have.
I made the miter on those dovetails with a shoulder plane and a makeshift fence. I held the combination of the two like a football and planed with the fence up against my workbench.
Re: More questions on humidity
Frank D. in Montreal
Other than Spanish cedar's remarkable stability at high humidity (which in the end means at varying humidity, since the humidity when it's used for construction is usually less than it is with 70% relative humidity inside the humidor), I'd say (I've read, and being a cigar smoker, have tasted) the most important factor would be the aroma. Spanish cedar contributes to the aroma of a good cigar in a very subtle way, and it helps cigars age properly and improve (taste better) with time. It also helps repel tobacco parasites that can feed on fine cigars.
Here's more from Cigar Aficionado *LINK*
Ellis Walentine
Just about every cigar box I've seen, including all the ones from Cuba, have been lined with (or made entirely of) Spanish cedar, or cedrela. Here's what one authority has to say about liner woods....
Cedars for cigar boxes
I'll believe the odor but not the moisture theory
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
All wood has essentially the same bulk chemical composition. We have one table for % moisture content vs humidity, not one for each species. From the table, at 70% RH a kg ( 2 pounds) of wood contains 130 grams of water. The air in the box contains a few milligrams of water. Any wood will rise to the challenge of supplying moisture when the humidity of the box air changes.
From drying we know that moisture loss/gain is faster with lighter weight woods= poplar vs oak for example. The only piece of Spanish Cedar I ever held was heavy.
Data from Forest Products labs lab shows that Spanish Cedar is about average in its dimensional response to moisture changes.
I suspect that odor and tradition drive the choice.
Re: I'll believe the odor but not the moisture the
TomD
I am kinda surprised that spanish cedar and mahogany are regarded as similar woods, as far as their capabilities are concerned.
I don't agree that rate of moisture loss is basically related to weight, if that was the point you were making Bill, though it might be substantially true. That Beech I cut was possibly the fastest drying wood, including one huge slab of it, that I have ever used. One thing I have no info on, but would be interesting to know about is that when one harvests very wet wood, does it all weigh mostly the same. I am talking about wood so wet turning it is like taking a shower when you turn it. If so, the lighter woods would have a lot more water to drop.
Anyway, the ideal humidor wood, odor aside, would be one that when put in the box in the correct orientation, would have the shrinkage rate, and moisture release rate that the project required. If one thinks of beech, there are transverse pores that in a quarter sawn situation dump water like nobody's business. I am guessing that is not what one wants, but it illustrates that with several performance constraints (grain orientation, struture relative to moisture loss, rate of moisture loss, odor), you could end up with a few specialized results.
If materials are somewhat similar, and have different rates of shrinkage, wouldn't that suggest they actually do not dry at the same rate relative to material weight?