Re: Why not......
david weaver
I recognize all of the things you mention. when I started, it took little time for me to migrate to shaptons hones, and the final 15k hone that I used was sub micron. I didn't really understand all of the talk about wire edges.
It did take longer to hone than the washita does, though, even at two steps. Even if the honing speed was the same, I still had to fiddle with the stones by lapping them, etc.
Usually, if honing is done well, what's holding the wire edge on is a very small bit of steel - on a natural stone, the wire edge is long and thin, and when separated, the edge is still narrow and very sharp. With a synthetic stone, the wire edge doesn't happen on very fine grits because deep cutting of the grits tears up a fine wire edge. On coarse synthetics (like 10 microns or so), the wire edge is organized, but the edge behind it is terrible, so it does no real good to strop it off.
I can't say too much about the oilstones and their friendliness to leather or palm stropping other than that it's hard to "get" unless you do it for a while.
I did loose diamonds for a little while, too (I've tried most things just out of curiosity, and the only thing that I thought was really a severe pain in the ass was honing films - too fragile, too much fiddling to make sure you don't have the slightest particle anywhere under the film).
But I didn't like any of those things as much as oilstones. (the diamonds are OK, but when you go to sharpen carving tools on them, relatively unsavory - they also aren't as sparing of steel as washita and a follow on burnishing stone if you feel the need for that kind of thing), and I've got a couple of ice hard chisels that will not tolerate coarse work being done by things like diamond or silicon carbide.
To your point, though, if one didn't like the idea, conceptually, of "breaking off the wire edge" to reveal something unsavory, it's certainly a legitimate follow on step to work it off with a piece of true jasper (which works as an excellent edge aligner without raising a subsequent wire edge).
All of that said, using a single stone and palm stropping is a very handy, fast and meritable method. For me, using the washita, it is the easiest to keep contaiminant free and the least effort to use, and it has a nice feel with everything (chisels, plane irons, carving tools, etc). Of course, the washita can't do anything with the ice hard chisels, but I don't use those often and I am careful when I do.