New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

An Unexpected Interest in Washitas

Posts

An Unexpected Interest in Washitas

#1

An Unexpected Interest in Washitas

david weaver

This is sort of a nothing post, but I'm going to post it, anyway :b

I sharpen 95+% of the time with a washita and bare leather and nothing else. It's easier for me to keep track of, and you do give up a little bit of initial sharpness, but not in a way that affects much.

I babbled on about it in a few youtube videos (probably because someone asked to see the process, I can't remember), and figured I might find some like-minded folks.

The unexpected part is that instead of striking up discussion from purists, I got a bunch of behind the scenes questions from people who were looking not to get into much hand work (set of chisels and a block plane and nothing else types), and those folks bummed off all of my extra washita stones. I expected most would get them and get the bug to chase ultimate sharpness and not be too impressed, but what I got back from them was semi-ecstatic messages that such a cheap and simple process could make a functional edge.

That's pretty much it. Very surprised to see people who really aren't into hand tools going for the old stuff.

Re: An Unexpected Interest in Washitas

#2

Re: An Unexpected Interest in Washitas

Chuck Bjorgen

You actually drew me into the Washita stone experience too and I managed to acquire two so-called Lily White Washitas, each with somewhat different properties. One is a bit coarser than the other. Nevertheless I satisfied myself that I could sharpen a plane iron with the one stone, finish on a leather strop with green compound and get excellent results. I do have one other stone marked Washita that came from Woodcraft about 20 years ago. It has the brownish, mottled color of what I used to think as the classic Washita.

As with so many members here, I'm a sharpening stone pig and currently choose the two-stone Spyderco set and the strop.

Re: An Unexpected Interest in Washitas

#3

Re: An Unexpected Interest in Washitas

Ron Harper

I know several guys much more highly skilled that I am who use 2 stones and a strop. I think medium India and Black Arkansas. They have been doing this for years. They have had their work in the popular mags. I am working at simpilfying.

Re: An Unexpected Interest in Washitas

#4

Re: An Unexpected Interest in Washitas

Sgian Dubh

"... what I got back from them was semi-ecstatic messages that such a cheap and simple process could make a functional edge."

As far as I can tell, getting a functional edge cheaply and simply has always been very achievable, albeit requiring some practice to develop the necessary skills. My sharpening of plane blades and chisels, in probably 90 per cent plus of cases, consists of honing on an 800 grit ceramic stone followed up by some stropping on the palm of the hand, and back to work. The other 10 per cent of cases, when I'm after a 'really' sharp edge for some particular task, means I move from the 800 grit stone to a 'fine' ceramic stone for a few strokes, followed by a bit of palm stropping.

I suppose my relatively rudimentary sharpening routines developed through the way I was taught with very basic kit, i.e., a shop owned grindstone and some water in a pot, and a craftsman owned combination oilstone along with a bit of lubricant. Those craftsmen didn't use much to sharpen with, and me, being young at the time, didn't know any better, so I suppose I took their lessons on board, and those lessons stuck! My big change in forty or so years of sharpening was to switch from an oilstone to a ceramic stone, but that was primarily because I didn't like oil residue (mostly stuck to skin) sometimes getting on the wood I was working on after I'd sharpened either planes or chisels. Slainte.

Re: An Unexpected Interest in Washitas

#5

Re: An Unexpected Interest in Washitas

david weaver

Unfortunately for most of us, we didn't grow into skill by watching a pro hands on. Otherwise, a lot of the stuff out on the internet would be different.

I've tried medium waterstones only and bare leather, and didn't like it, but I certainly can't refute that it works. Same with a fine india.

A friend, whose dad literally wore out a couple of planes as a joiner in the UK, came back with his recently deceased dad's tools. In the box was a worn hollow carborundum combination stone and a washita stone. He (the friend) being of the shapton 30k and honing guide type was horrified by those two stones. At the time, I thought they looked like torture, but think the combination is a pretty nice one at this point. A stone that can grind, and a stone that can hone. Pretty handy.

(I think he threw those stones away...not a sentimental guy, for sure. I have a couple of the planes that were his fathers, they were also headed for the trash can - a record 5 1/2 and a slater bullnose).

Re: An Unexpected Interest in Washitas

#6

Re: An Unexpected Interest in Washitas

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I think you have to look at what you are doing with the planes. If you are just using a plane as an intermediary step between a thickness planer and a belt sander, well then you are not using a plane enough to get tired and you are not looking for a fine surface.

If you are using planes for stock preparation you want a nice edgeto reduce fatigue. And if you are wanting a surface far cleaner than a sanded surface, then you want some polish to your iron's edge.

Re: An Unexpected Interest in Washitas

#7

Re: An Unexpected Interest in Washitas

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Given how quick a "nanometer refined edge" becomes less so in use I have suspected we tend to over sharpen for many asks.

I do wonder what the rubbing on the palm of the hand accomplishes? I have a vision of "hands as tough as a horse's butt" but probably not.

Re: An Unexpected Interest in Washitas

#8

Re: An Unexpected Interest in Washitas

Sgian Dubh

I think you make a good point about receiving instruction from experienced hands, although that experience doesn't necessarily have to come from a professional, just someone who knows how to do it, and with the ability to demonstrate the technique. I must admit to keeping my sharpening instructions to learners as simple as I was taught, although I do mention there are a plethora of methods out there.

I also admit to cautioning learners about getting too involved in overly complex sharpening regimes - I don't really think making things complex aids learning at the outset. Once a learner has grasped the basics, if they want to later make the job very involved later, at least they have a solid base against which to compare to decide if the complicated method has any merit over the simple method.

Talking of stones, I've come across plenty of severely dished ones. A slight dishing, both lengthways and crossways is not too much of a problem for me, but badly dished examples are often best dumped and replaced with new. Combination oilstones, for example, aren't overly expensive, so why struggle either trying to flatten or to use a horror of a stone. As to beaten up old planes, some are worth salvaging, but I suppose not all are worth the time to fix. Slainte.

Re: An Unexpected Interest in Washitas

#9

Re: An Unexpected Interest in Washitas

david weaver

It's a quick way to bend the wire edge back and forth until it's removed.

Quite effective.

Re: An Unexpected Interest in Washitas

#10

Re: A local instructor..

david weaver

..a local instructor here tells his students to avoid the internet once they are proficient with something.

Agree on the dished stones, and I have seen them from cabinetmakers/joiners, as well as once chancing upon a huge dished escher stone that a barber had been using.

I've never (at least not once learning to sharpen freehand) considered the dishing to be much of a detriment as long as the stone isn't wider than the item being sharpened (that assumes a lateral dishing - dishing along the length doesn't matter at all). I've flattened my stones initially when I've gotten them, though, but not since. It feels like the luxury treatment more or less to start them flat when they really don't need to be.

When some folks advise that oilstones must be flattened often, i wonder what it is they're talking about.

(re: the combination stones, the old ones here, except for a few barber type hones, are always overhardened and almost worthless - especially old silicon carbide stones. I don't know why they get hard when they're old, but the new ones are just friable enough to be very nice to work with. I throw the old ones out when I chance across them. )

Re: An Unexpected Interest in Washitas

#11

Re: An Unexpected Interest in Washitas

William Duffield

I usually carry an emergency sharpening kit in my wallet and hand held. It consists of three credit card size diamond plates, http://www.woodcraft.com/product/143652/dmt-credit-card-diamond-stone-extra-fine.aspx in coarse, fine and extra fine, and my palm strop. While stropping on the palm of my hand doesn't get edges quite as refined as the horse butt charged with 0.3 µ Chromium Oxide I use in the shop, it results in a sharper edge that finishing with the extra fine diamond card.

I haven't analyzed the size, chemical composition or source of the abrasive particles that are obviously embedded in my skin, but I know they are there and I know they are efficacious, on O1, A2 and M2 steel edges at least. I don't yet have enough experience with PM-V11 to draw any conclusions.

Re: An Unexpected Interest in Washitas

#12

Why not......

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

....just rub the blade on a wood surface, undoubtedly near at hand?

On a philosophical note, if there is a wire edge left to be broken off it would seem that the edge left would be less refined and robust than for the case where the wire edge was ground away with a grit fine enough to thin this edge to oblivion.

I typically don't need to deal with a persistent wire edge after sharpening. One micron diamond on cast iron thins the edge to where it breaks loose and flats away in the lubricant even for the case of the tenacious wire edge that forms on CPM 3V.

Re: An Unexpected Interest in Washitas

#13

Re: Why not......

david weaver

I recognize all of the things you mention. when I started, it took little time for me to migrate to shaptons hones, and the final 15k hone that I used was sub micron. I didn't really understand all of the talk about wire edges.

It did take longer to hone than the washita does, though, even at two steps. Even if the honing speed was the same, I still had to fiddle with the stones by lapping them, etc.

Usually, if honing is done well, what's holding the wire edge on is a very small bit of steel - on a natural stone, the wire edge is long and thin, and when separated, the edge is still narrow and very sharp. With a synthetic stone, the wire edge doesn't happen on very fine grits because deep cutting of the grits tears up a fine wire edge. On coarse synthetics (like 10 microns or so), the wire edge is organized, but the edge behind it is terrible, so it does no real good to strop it off.

I can't say too much about the oilstones and their friendliness to leather or palm stropping other than that it's hard to "get" unless you do it for a while.

I did loose diamonds for a little while, too (I've tried most things just out of curiosity, and the only thing that I thought was really a severe pain in the ass was honing films - too fragile, too much fiddling to make sure you don't have the slightest particle anywhere under the film).

But I didn't like any of those things as much as oilstones. (the diamonds are OK, but when you go to sharpen carving tools on them, relatively unsavory - they also aren't as sparing of steel as washita and a follow on burnishing stone if you feel the need for that kind of thing), and I've got a couple of ice hard chisels that will not tolerate coarse work being done by things like diamond or silicon carbide.

To your point, though, if one didn't like the idea, conceptually, of "breaking off the wire edge" to reveal something unsavory, it's certainly a legitimate follow on step to work it off with a piece of true jasper (which works as an excellent edge aligner without raising a subsequent wire edge).

All of that said, using a single stone and palm stropping is a very handy, fast and meritable method. For me, using the washita, it is the easiest to keep contaiminant free and the least effort to use, and it has a nice feel with everything (chisels, plane irons, carving tools, etc). Of course, the washita can't do anything with the ice hard chisels, but I don't use those often and I am careful when I do.

Re: An Unexpected Interest in Washitas

#14

Re: An Unexpected Interest in Washitas

Sgian Dubh

"If you are just using a plane as an intermediary step between a thickness planer and a belt sander, well then you are not using a plane enough to get tired and you are not looking for a fine surface."

If I'm looking to prep a surface polish ready with a belt sander, a very rare occurrence, there's no plane involved.

If I want a fine surface ready for polish then, yes, the hand planes come out to remove planer marks followed, if necessary, by scrapers, and finally a bit of abrasive paper. I seldom polish straight over hand planed surfaces.

I use hand planes extremely rarely for stock preparation, i.e., truing up and squaring rough sawn wood, and I even when I do my core sharpening technique doesn't change. Slainte.

Re: An Unexpected Interest in Washitas

#15

Re: An Unexpected Interest in Washitas

Sgian Dubh

"I do wonder what the rubbing on the palm of the hand accomplishes? I have a vision of "hands as tough as a horse's butt" but probably not."

I don't think the palm rubbing thing does much, perhaps just taking off a whisker or two of stray metal. It's primarily just a habit I suppose, but I can't see there's anything detrimental in it. It takes just a few seconds as I find the parts needed to reassemble the plane, or the time it takes to walk a couple or three paces from where I've sharpened the chisel to where the work's going on. No need for horse butt tough palms either as far as I'm aware, ha ha. Slainte.

Re: An Unexpected Interest in Washitas

#16

Hand stropping - I was trained the same

Andrew F in Australia

It does sharpen up an edge - removes the wire edge, I suppose. It also works when the chisel's getting blunt. I maintain 25 planes and about 40 chisels so I still do it daily.

Not that you'll find it in any manual these days.

I saw the tradesman that trained me get distracted one day. The surrounding area was a bit busy thereafter.

I recommend using the end grain of cedar or something similarly soft to those that ask me.

Cheers,