New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

All drawers are finally done

Posts

All drawers are finally done

#1

All drawers are finally done

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Well, almost ...

The drawer bottoms have still to be made for 4 of the drawers. After making each one separately, it occurred to me that this was the one item that I could build en masse.



After the drawer bottoms are in, the task will be to make the drawer fronts coplanar. They are close to one another in curve, but there are a few variations here-and-there. What I plan to do is shim the drawers by about 1/2" to raise them out an equal amount so that they all lie proud of the carcase, place the chest on its back so that the drawers face upward, and then sand the faces with a long sander made out of a 2x4.

What do you think of this method? Any other ideas?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: All drawers are finally done

#2

Ellis Walentine

Re: All drawers are finally done

Ellis Walentine

Awesome work, Derek. You do know how to rise to a challenge.

Regarding the drawers, I'm wondering what you'll be using for drawer stops. Whatever method you use, why not install the stops now and then put your shims between them and the backs of the drawer fronts (or whatever). Then you're working off the actual stopping arrangement instead of an arbitrary relationship to the back of the case.

Unless I'm reading this wrong...

Cheers,

Ellis

Re: All drawers are finally done

#3

Re: All drawers are finally done

Hank Knight

Derek,

That looks great, and those are some fine dovetails. Nice job!

Re: All drawers are finally done

#4

Any other ideas......yes, cockbead

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

To my eye, known to be design challenged, the drawers need to be defined. I don't find the large expanse of grain, going this way and that, attractive. I like the shape, but I would have cock beaded the drawers with a contrasting wood like African Blackwood to define them. The bonus would be to make small variations in the drawer plane unable to be detected.

Re: All drawers are finally done

#5

Re: All drawers are finally done

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Ellis

You read that correctly. While the lower section of the drawer acts as its own drawer stop, I have planned to tap in very small (M5) black nylon bolts. Remove their heads and add slots, and they will be also be able to be adjusted to tweek any irregularities in the drawer blades. This will be done before any surfacing is done on the drawers.

What I have decided is to use a long straight edge with very fine sandpaper (400 grit), which will mark high spots. These can then be planed down.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: All drawers are finally done

#6

Re: Any other ideas......yes, cockbead

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

You and your cockbeads, Bill! :)

But you are not wrong. The drawers do need defining (but not cockbeads - they are too formal). The grain does threaten to overwhelm.

It is intended that a 1/16" be removed from the lower edge of each drawer. This will create a thin dark line between the drawers.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: All drawers are finally done

#7

Agree with what Ellis advised 


Re: All drawers are finally done

#8

Re: Any other ideas......yes, cockbead

Brian Holcombe

I think the barrel type pulls are good for this cabinet, with the compound curves and so forth it seems just right. I'm sure it will work in Jarrah, but I think it would be best in ebony or Blackwood. Originally I thought the opposite but that was with a different type of pull in mind.

Re: All drawers are finally done

#9

Pulls

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Brian

I turned this very quickly, just to get an idea. The shape could be refined a little and the edges crisper, but you can get a feel ..

The same pull, in figured Jarrah ...



Lynndy likes the figured wood but I prefer the darker version as it gives the pulls better definition - and I don't think that it will detract from the drawers. What do you think?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: All drawers are finally done

#10

Re: Pulls

Brian Holcombe

I think the dark pull would be better. I feel it should start apart from the drawers. The frame and panel build calls for something on the drawers, so I think that the pull does the job and does it well.

Re: All drawers are finally done

#11

Re: Pulls

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Derek,

I think Lynndy is right on the merits, as it would leave the drawer fronts 'all of a piece'. In any case, best do it her way, if she is to be the user :) .

Wiley

Re: All drawers are finally done

#12

don't agree

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I would be using African Blackwood for the knobs, what ever shape they were to be. That large expanse of same colored wood on the front needs some contrast.


For example, to my untrained eye the contrasting blackwood pull added greatly to the appearance of this drawer compared to the effect of a same as ash pull.

Re: All drawers are finally done

#13

Re: don't agree

TomD

I agree with you there, those drawers are striking, but the rest of the piece is not as formal. One wants to avoid the bow tie with a track suit effect. Not to say that is what is there.

Re: All drawers are finally done

#14

Clint Searl

No!

Clint Searl

The beauty of a piece is composed of layers. As it is, your chest so far has two layers: the shape with its gentle curves and the spectacular wood. Adding wooden pulls would be a layer that adds nothing. Since the piece has a somewhat oriental feel, something derivative of antique Japanese tansu hardware in a patinated finish would seem most appropriate, IMO.

Re: All drawers are finally done

#15

Re: Pulls

Hank Knight

I thought I would like the Shaker knob style single pull, and I think they would work. I agree with Bill Tindall that a dark contrasting wood would be better than the same jarrah the rest of the piece is made from. My preference, were it my piece, would be very simple, narrow, linear pulls of ebony or blackwood that are graduated in length from small on the top drawer to wider at the bottom to mirror the shape of the case. But it's your wife's piece, so you probably ought to follow her request.

Re: All drawers are finally done

#16

Re: Pulls

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I thought I would like the Shaker knob style single pull, and I think they would work. I agree with Bill Tindall that a dark contrasting wood would be better than the same jarrah the rest of the piece is made from. My preference, were it my piece, would be very simple, narrow, linear pulls of ebony or blackwood that are graduated in length from small on the top drawer to wider at the bottom to mirror the shape of the case. But it's your wife's piece, so you probably ought to follow her request.

Hank, my head is sore from going around and around on the handle/pull choices.

There are really only three choices: no handle, short round Shaker knobs (in rows of pairs), or a horizontal pull (a single handle set in the centre of the drawer).

The no handle (pop out) idea was my first, but discarded when I could not see the mechanisms lasting 10, never mind 100, years.

The round knobs are small and not intrusive. Lynndy wants drawer colour, and I prefer dark/black. It is her chest of drawers, but I believe that she is wrong, and just going with her choice will no doubt frustrate me. The only way to decide this is to make both and let her decide that way.

The horizontal handle is another that I would make out of wood. I have drawn up plans and the construction is a one-piece affair. Incidentally, both the round knobs and the horizontal handle will be tapped for metal threads and connected to the drawers with brass bolts.

Below is a close representation of the horizontal handle. There would be just one in the centre of each drawer to minimise distractions, as the shape is also designed to do. Again, either Jarrah or black.


I do not plan to do anything about these until the top section (with mirror) is completed.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: All drawers are finally done

#17

Re: No!

TomD

Looking at it now, I think it would have worked better if there were horizontal lines that gave the unrelenting front some interest, and allowed finger pulls on the front lower edge. Glad to help.


Re: All drawers are finally done

#18

Re: No!

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Tom

There will be horizontal lines. The lower edge of each drawer will be reduced by 1-2mm. This will create a dark, relief line that separates each drawer. I believe that is very necessary to avoid the grain of the drawers overwhelming one.

Example ..


It is easy enough to make the "line" wider and bevel the back to form a finger grip. That is not my plan, however, as one would need to create a gap of at least 10-15mm, which is too wide for my taste.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: All drawers are finally done

#19

Re: Opinions about pulls

Hank Knight

Hi, Derek,

Opinions are like noses: everybody's got one, and they eagerly share them, me included. No wonder your head is spinning. I'm sure whatever you and Lindy settle on will be exquisite. The whole piece is exquisite. Everything about it - the shape, the joinery, the wood - is wonderful. I look forward to seeing the finished piece.

Hank

Re: All drawers are finally done

#20

Do What Lynndy Says..

david weaver

..either way, your eyes will get used to the piece however it's done. But one will make the mrs. happy.

Re: All drawers are finally done

#21

that would be my choice

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"simple, narrow, linear pulls of ebony or blackwood that are graduated in length from small on the top drawer to wider at the bottom"

Re: All drawers are finally done

#22

forged drawer pulls

Bruce Mack

If you bring up the images under this heading, you'll find some beauties to complement the beauty of your piece. I think the roughness goes well with the extraordinary figure of your wood. I am particularly taken by one of rebar (no kidding).

Re: All drawers are finally done

#23

Re: No!

TomD

Should have known you were on it!