New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Roubo Molding planes?

Posts

Roubo Molding planes?

#1

Roubo Molding planes?

TomD

Anyone tempted. Looks like it would work well enough, and be silly easy to make. Though for low mileage users the Frink planes are even simpler. I feel if I made the Roubo ones I would use some wood from my precious, and overflowing beech stock and that might hold me back. I may try some in maple.


Re: Roubo Molding planes?

#2

Re: Roubo Molding planes?

TomD

I should say for those who may not have seen it, that it is the cover story for Popular Woodworking.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4WetOeFPHvE

Re: Roubo Molding planes?

#3

Re: Roubo Molding planes?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I made bouvet (plough) and feuilleret (fillister) planes like this forty years ago. I posted this picture on another forum in 2014 and David Weaver took an interest and made some of these planes and posted detailed instructions for making them. I earlier posted this picture on this forum 11/19/2011. I like to put a little bit of angle on the wedge where it meets the plane stock to keep it from popping out.


It is nice to put a little bit of spring on an ogee plane; it cuts the moulding a little faster and keeps the mouth more uniform.

Re: Roubo Molding planes?

#5

Re: Roubo Molding planes?

david weaver

I made a pair of them (or three, I can't remember). Took about an hour each or maybe just slightly more (I cut and filed out irons during that time, too). I made them as fast as I could to see how they'd work, and they work great, but I didn't taper the wedge area at all and it does take a little more care to make sure the wedge is in as well as possible as if it's not seated flush, it will pop out as you say.

I intend to replace them at some point with closed mortise planes, but I don't know if I'll ever actually get to that.

For the amount of time they take to make, they work incredibly well and cut very cleanly.

Re: Roubo Molding planes?

#6

Re: Roubo Molding planes?

TomD

That is an interesting pic Warren with the whatever, on the side of the wedge for removal. Well done for beating the popular field by 40 years.

David, where did you post your efforts, don't remember that.

One hour is good going, I can make a plane in 45 minutes, and at the time I timed it, it took 45 minutes longer to make the blade, so that is 50% longer in total. It is amazing the time saving making stuff can have compared to shopping online. :)

Why mess with the closed design, just the challenge? At 56 I bet there isn't enough time left to see any difference in function. The Finck design, (which is not original in the main) has a glued on cheek, and that solves all the problems that a morticed plane could solve. I found the escapement tended to clog a little, but still worked well enough. With bench planes, mortises are faster and somewhat better than glue ups, but in the tall narrow planes the glue-ups sure do go together well.

The Osage plane above uses a HSS tool bit, those wear like carbide and take a very fine edge and cost only a few bucks, but not available here in too many sizes.

Re: Roubo Molding planes?

#7

Re: Roubo Molding planes?

Kees

The French made these planes like this for a very long time. But they probably got sick of those popping wedges, so they nailed or screwed a batten to the side.

Re: Roubo Molding planes?

#8

Re: Roubo Molding planes?

david weaver

Unfortunately, I posted them on sawmill creek, which means the images aren't viewable for anyone who is not a member. I requested they ghost my login sometime last year, so I can't go fetch anything.

The planes I made weren't nice looking like Warren's picture, thus the hour time. They were literally made with the back side of the plane still rough lumber. I didn't spend any more time on any part than I absolutely had to, but they work great.

I think I would only make closed mortise versions out of laziness for being able to set the wedge thoughtlessly. I haven't thought enough about it to know what the details would be, though.

Re: Roubo Molding planes?

#9

Re: Roubo Molding planes?

TomD

I'm a member over there, so I will have a look.

Popping wedges doesn't sound all that great. The article suggests something like a 3 deg undercut, but I guess on could spline them.

Re: Roubo Molding planes?

#11

Re: Roubo Molding planes?

david weaver

3 degree undercut would probably be plenty. I didn't have any undercut, and when putting the wedge in just need to remember to hold it laterally to the plane (and then it's fine). If it comes out every couple of drawer bottoms, it's not like it's the end of the world.

I'm nearing the end of making planes just to make planes, though and figure that there are a couple of more things that I'll make while I'm relatively quick at it (that's a very relative term, not necessarily quick, but much faster than I was when I first started - and more accurate).