New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Japanese Toolbox Build - Part V

Posts

Re: Japanese Toolbox Build - Part V

#3

Re: Japanese Toolbox Build - Final

TomD

Going to go back over this, some very interesting joinery here. The elegance of this box style is that like a crate it is designed to be nailed together. I mention it just in case some people's head's are swimming at the complexity in this result. But I like the result, no reason why it shouldn't be given this kind of spin.

Re: Japanese Toolbox Build - Part V

#4

Re: Japanese Toolbox Build - Final

Brian Holcombe

Thanks Tom! Absolutely, it's certainly good to mention that the basic design is intended to be quick.

This project is mainly intended as a joinery study, which also happens to be useful, so it is made to be complicated.

It was very helpful to take Chris' approach, or my version of Chris' approach. He works differently from how I do so it was enlightening to build in his manner. I like to have a major sub assembly pretty quickly, which in this case the box doesn't come together until the final stage.

Re: Japanese Toolbox Build - Part V

#5

Re: Japanese Toolbox Build - Final

david weaver

Looks excellent. I couldn't begin to guess the kind of accuracy and patience it takes to make something that nice, but sometimes it is nice to make something nicer than it needs to be just so you can learn. Every saw stroke makes us better and more reflexive, even if it's just cutting a million wedges.

Re: Japanese Toolbox Build - Part V

#6

Re: Japanese Toolbox Build - Final

Brian Holcombe

Thanks David! This project definetly expanded my limits and also tested my repertoire of tools, encouraging some expansion. I finally bought a block plane, a 42mm ko-ganna (kunio), just for these thin wall light projects where a big plane is ackward to use after assembly.

More saws too, just keep running into situations where I needed different saws to speed up the project.

So it's kept me out of a rut, trying to continue improving my ability but also my speed.

Cutting all of those wedges was brutal, lol.

Re: Japanese Toolbox Build - Part V

#7

Re: Japanese Toolbox Build - Final

TomD

Yeah, when I built my version of the Underhill tool box, very shabby compared to your masterpiece, it was under an injunction to nail it together, rather than do some crazy dovetails. Well, I wasn't going to waste all that fairly nice HD pine! So of course I dovetailed it. The only reason I mentioned the nails and your project was just so people wouldn't miss the brilliance of the original design. I remember when I got my Connover lathe in some crates. I looked at them for a while in wonder. How efficient and knowing the design was. I once read how many crates were made to supply the WWII efforts. A colossal number. Not last I heard, with some equivalent of the Emerald Ash borer stowed away...

Re: Japanese Toolbox Build - Part V

#8

Re: Japanese Toolbox Build - Final

Brian Holcombe

And practical as well, one thing that always strikes me about classical Japanese design is that it never lacks practicality. That covers the full spectrum of design, not just architecture or containers.

Re: Japanese Toolbox Build - Part V

#9

Re: Japanese Toolbox Build - Final

TomD

So true, and probably also true of our stuff at a similar period of development over here. Today we all mostly manufacture stuff nobody really needs, or if they do, it doesn't meet the need at all well.

Re: Japanese Toolbox Build - Part V

#10

Re: Japanese Toolbox Build - Final

Brian Holcombe

That's one of the major factors, on the practical side, of why I woodwork for my own purpose. By the time a product is out of the typical range of 'function until dead in x-years and replace', and into the range of quality for quality sake it moves into a price bracket that requires much more careful consideration and somewhat sparse application.

I can now build in range of quality where I expect my results will serve me for a very long time, and those few pieces which were learning excercises early on have been serving me well and living lives longer than comparably priced commercial furniture.

To some extent this thinking drives my wife crazy, hah, as I will not buy cheaply made anything since I believe it furthers the production of cheap things and deters people from producing quality.

Re: Japanese Toolbox Build - Part V

#11

Re: Japanese Toolbox Build - Final

TomD

It's funny, been at this a long time and now that I am post heart attack (no biggie) and 56. I pretty much know the necessary lifespan of anything I make. Best case it has to last 30 years, more likely 10 before the great wind down starts up. And I have been at this around 40 years, so conveniently I now know just how well one has to build to make stuff last 30 years. Not so well, it turns out... :) My biggest accident was probably my trimaran, that despite best practices, and testing, ended up being built of non-waterproof plywood, of known low quality. And as it turned out, even pieces that shed their coating over the years and stood unnoticed under the wet or snowy sky, lasted just fine. Quite a far cry from furniture, nothing of which I built, other than a kid's art table I in a fit of rage kicked off the back deck, ever ended up with the slightest sign of wear other than cosmetic. Still, at least the land fill will appreciate the quality when the time comes.

Actually even highly perishable things like flies I made when I was under ten, are still good to go as far as their materials are concerned. I don't break a lot of stuff.

Re: Japanese Toolbox Build - Part V

#12

Re: Japanese Toolbox Build - Final

Brian Holcombe

Good point, for the most part I've chalked my interested in using primarily joinery to personal progression. If I always add some dimension of newness to a project, for me, then I continue to remain interested.

There are plenty of not so greatly built things that do seem to last an extraordinary amount of time. My kitchen cabinets, for instance. I've been waiting for them to sag so that I have the excuse to prioritize tearing them down and building replacements.....but they still hang on...