New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Lumber drying tidbits

Posts

Lumber drying tidbits

#1

Lumber drying tidbits

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Over on the main board I posted some information with illustrations on drying lumber. For those experiencing cracks in KD beech, or any other lumber, note how stress cracks from too rapid drying close when the lumber becomes dry at the end of the KD process. But they are still there and can reveal themselves as the lumber is worked.

Re: Lumber drying tidbits

#2

Re: Similarity to Honeycombing?

david weaver

Maybe there's some similarity here to honeycombing? I'm gathering now that the starting temperature of a kiln with steam starts a rapid expansion of beech from the outside pulling the middle apart (or maybe my wacky logic is way off).

I was ill informed in making my comment about horizon having trouble with beech due to rushing the schedule. I think it may be more the difficulty of beech honeycombing because of the desire to start the process on steam, since steam prevents mold.

Re: Lumber drying tidbits

#3

Similarity to Honeycombing?no, opposite

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Honeycomb occurs at the end of the KD process as the internal part of the board shrinks. It is internal and the cracks don't close up as the lumber gets dry. These cracks don't usually extend to the surface.

Surface cracks are often started during too rapid air drying. They usually don't penetrate far into the lumber. I have only seen them in oak (but beech would be similar).

I have no idea how your source dries beech. A yard doing a lot of it would use air drying first or a predrier to cut down kiln costs- not the heat but capital tied up in the kiln.

"Maybe there's some similarity here to honeycombing? I'm gathering now that the starting temperature of a kiln with steam starts a rapid expansion of beech from the outside pulling the middle apart (or maybe my wacky logic is way off). "Yes, WAAY off.

I was ill informed in making my comment about horizon having trouble with beech due to rushing the schedule. I think it may be more the difficulty of beech honeycombing because of the desire to start the process on steam, since steam prevents mold. ...never seen a kiln "sterilized" at the start, but I have not seen everything. It is sufficient to get the surface dry and mold does not start. Nothing is harder to keep from staining than white pine and soft maple. Both can be kept bright by rapidly reducing the surface moisture during air drying or in a predrier.

I have a drying schedule (time temperature and humidity in the kiln) for 4 and 8/4 beech that I can look up. It is not unlike oak as I recall.

Re: Lumber drying tidbits

#4

Re:  Similarity to Honeycombing?no, opposite

david weaver

Somewhere, I saw a schedule for 16/4 beech, but I can't remember what.

Horizon air dries the beech first and then puts it in the kiln.

I'm convinced a lot of my troubles with air drying two sticks recently is very poor timing. I got wet wood and put it in a semi heated area when the outside temperature was about zero and the dewpoint was well below that.

I think it would work well if cut in the summer and ends sealed for air drying. I could show you the checks that I developed on wet lumber air drying (beech) but they're filled with wax right now and wouldn't look like much.

(the wet lumber came off of ebay, not from horizon. On the whole, horizon's stuff has been really superb).

Re: Lumber drying tidbits

#5

Re: Similarity to Honeycombing?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Surface checks are similar to honeycombing in that they are both caused by excessive moisture differential between the inside and outside of the timber. This moisture differential results from rapid drying.

When there is a moisture differential the outside wants to shrink so it becomes stretched around the still swollen core. When this stress is excessive it can be relieved by the surface cracking. As Bill mentioned, these surface checks can close up when the core later shrinks.

In honeycombing, the outside usually doesn't crack but is stretched and set in that condition as it dries. Meanwhile the interior can be compressed and suffer collapse. Because it is compressed, it dries to smaller dimensions than the outside and interior checking (honeycombing) results.

Re: Lumber drying tidbits

#6

end coating

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Once end checks develop, coating does nothing to stop them from propagating. (reference- VA Tech Forest Products Lab research report) If your green billets are end checked cut the ends off until you get to unchecked material, then coat.

I don't have a lot of experience end coating as I never do it on 4 and 8/4 lumber. I did end coat a large cherry log last year with AnchorSeal. It sat for months, sometimes in the sun, and never end checked. I have similarly coated 12 and 16/4 walnut planks and they didn't check while drying. Recently I end coated log sections destined for drawer sides. After 5 months the Anchorsealed sections were sound and the latex paint sealed sections had begun to check.

I believe Anchor seal, apparently a wax emulsion, completely eliminated moisture escape from wood end grain.

Re: Lumber drying tidbits

#7

Latex paint or Beewswax

david weaver

I've used latex paint and beeswax, and both work well. The things that have vexed me on the last batch of wood are checking on the flatsawn side in then long grain.

I think a lot of folks would say beeswax is an expensive option, but it depends on how smooth the ends were cut. If the end of a board is smooth, I'd imagine that with $8 worth of wax and mineral oil, you could do a couple of hundred billets.

Similarly, no problem after using latex paint, either. If I get more wet beech, and at this point I probably won't. But if I do get more green beech, I will wax the ends of the billets and either paint or wax the long grain leaving only the quartered faces free for a little while. But more importantly, I should be smart enough not to buy green wood and set it up in a semi-heated area when it's subzero temperatures outside.

Re: Lumber drying tidbits

#9

Re: Lumber drying tidbits

don stephan

Nicely done, Richard. Do you have a date yet when your book will be available here across the pond?

Re: Lumber drying tidbits

#10

Re: Latex paint or Beewswax

TomD

I haven't had any serious problems with the regular end coating, wood turners sell the good stuff, it always seems to come inbottles unbranded. but it is a lot easier to handle than beeswax, which is an amazing product, a little wasted here.

I also haven't had a problem drying wet beech. Certainly the undried stuff is so much cheaper that even loosing 10% one would still be way out in front.

Re: Lumber drying tidbits

#11

Re:  Similarity to Honeycombing?no, opposite

Steve Voigt

Just to clarify a bit about Horizon's process…

Pete told me that initially, they just air-dried the wood first, then finished it in the kiln. To prevent mold, they handled the wood multiple times during the air-drying process, restacking it, moving it around, continuously rotating the stock for good airflow. Using this method, they had great success. But it's extremely labor intensive, and they weren't able to keep doing it. So they worked out an approach that involved steaming the wood before air drying. This also seems to stop mold dead, but it (according to Pete) caused honeycombing and other problems and resulted in multiple lost loads, so they are abandoning that process. Last I heard, they were going to try spraying the wood with sta-brite before air-drying (unfortunately, that product is $400 for a 5-gallon bucket).

My local guy just got me a log, 21" and 12' long. I'll be air drying it in a protected area outside. I plan to spray the area with Concrobium (cheap and available at HD), and I'll probably spray the lumber too, though it won't provide any long lasting protection. Beyond that, I'll do what pete said: continuously rotate the stack to provide good airfow.

One other side point. I used latex paint for a long time, then I got some anchor seal. The anchor seal is worth it. It protects the ends better, and you also end up using less of it, so in the long run it's more economical.

Re: Lumber drying tidbits

#12

Re:  Anchorseal...

david weaver

..cheaper than beeswax/oil mix, and it looks like per gallon, it's as cheap as a lot of decent quality paints.

Thanks for the clarification on the horizon stuff, I get the sense that they're making more effort than most reasonable places would, experimenting and trying to do what they think the market wants.

Hopefully, the log drying will work out for you.

Re: Lumber drying tidbits

#13

I do not understand the mold issue

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If the surface of lumber is dry and stays dry it doesn't mold in my experience, and I have dried thousands of feet of it. Staying dry involves a leak proof cover and protection of the sides from blowing rain. That said, I have dried little beech except for firewood. And indeed, beech firewood can suffer mold (spalt) within a year if the top of the pile is not waterproof. But I didn't get the impression it was any more prone than hickory, soft maple or poplar.

If air circulation is normal I don't see the need to reshuffle the pile either. It is not the general experience that the interior of a typical pile of air drying lumber has any different moisture content in the middle than the outside. If this was not the case the kiln drying would be a failure.


Some years ago the market began to demand "bright" lumber. In response lumber is now dipped at many mills as shown in the picture. Dipping prevents sticker stain and darkening during air drying outside, as well as bug attack. The sodium salt of tetrachlorophenol was used ( a slightly more benign relative of "penta") but something more environmentally friendly is used today (I don't know what it is).

I don't understand what steaming would do to prevent molding during subsequent air drying. The lumber is going to promptly inoculate with airborne mold spores which will be in the air in abundance around any log yard.

Nor do I understand how steaming would promote honeycombing. In fact one would predict the opposite would be the case.

Re: Lumber drying tidbits

#14

Re: I do not understand the mold issue

david weaver

I'm not interested in any of this at this point other than superficial interest - future schedule is quickly squeezing out time to do anything like making planes. But I do know that the beech that I've gotten from mike digity has some mold issues, and the stain runs deep.

Nothing else that I've gotten from him has any issues with that (I haven't gotten poplar or soft maple, though).

I have read something from larry in the past where he said that they set aside time when they got wet lumber (at least that's what I recall it being) to bleach the lumber right away when it came in to prevent mold (despite presumably keeping it dry). Steve is a lot close to what larry has done, though - I can only superficially remember things and often not very accurately.

Re: Lumber drying tidbits

#15

Re: Lumber drying tidbits

Sgian Dubh

Don, I spoke to the publishers just yesterday: they indicate they're aiming, provisionally, for an autumn 2016 release date, October or November in book form and quite likely in digital download format, as well as perhaps excerpts as informational pamphlets. Slainte.

Re: Lumber drying tidbits

#16

Re: I do not understand the mold issue

Steve Voigt

Bill, I wish I could answer your questions. At this point, all I can do is relay what I've gotten from numerous sources. I've talked at length with half a dozen people, all experienced in sawing and drying, and they all bemoaned the tendency of thick beech to mold and check.

Re: Lumber drying tidbits

#17

what little experience I have had

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Something won't decay until after it discolors. Holly is legendary for discoloring, that is to say not staying white. I have dried 8/4 holly successfully to keep it white.

As soon as it was sawed I thoroughly dusted the saw dust from the surfaces. Then I wet the surfaces with Chlorox. There is nothing more effective for killing fungus spores. Then I put fans on the lumber to dry the surface as quickly as possible. Drying conditions were poor and mold growing temperatures were favorable. For insurance I wet the surfaces with Chlorox again after a couple of days. As soon as the surfaces felt/looked dry (about day 4) I moved the lumber into a shed with good air circulation around the boards. It stayed white.

I have air dried, then KD, some 6/4 beech along with some walnut and it dried fine with no decay or splits. I dried some 4 and 5" billets of beech by just moving them into the shop with good air circulation. I actually piled them on the remains of the winter firewood pile. I did not end coat. None decayed or discolored but the splits along the rays are astonishing. They run the length of a 30" billet. I think it will be critical to properly end coat which will involve end trimming after sawing to get a check free surface to start with. I remain unimpressed that beech is difficult to dry without decay or even discolor if done under cover with normal air circulation.