New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Question on rehabbing wood smoother

Posts

Question on rehabbing wood smoother

#1

Question on rehabbing wood smoother

CJ in MPLS

Hello folks:

I've had a very nice horned smoothing plane for some time however it is a decoration on a bookshelf in the house. The plane is in very good shape except for the fact that the body has shrunk laterally and the blade is effectively frozen in place. The blade is tapered and has a cap iron.

The question that drives me to write is how thick the cheeks of a plane must be to maintain the integrity of the plane? I have about 7/16" on each cheek. Removing up 1/32" to 1/16" from each cheek shouldn't be a problem I think, but I'd prefer to leave well enough alone if my efforts were simply going to put me in a bad spot.

Cheers,

CJ

Re: Question on rehabbing wood smoother

#2

Re: Question on rehabbing wood smoother

david weaver

You have some wiggle room. Most planes are around 3/4 inch or a little more in total width beyond the cutting iron. A little more generally being up to a 16th or so.

I think if you take a 32nd off each side (after you get the iron out), you'll figure out that you have plenty of room to move the iron, and plenty of plane left.

(the horn will come out next if you use it heavily, but that's pretty easy to fix).

If you get feed problems because you have to take a lot out, you can just clip the iron corners or remake the wedge, but I doubt you'll have any issues.

Re: Question on rehabbing wood smoother

#3

Re: Question on rehabbing wood smoother

john Lucas

I'm with David. I would just grind the iron down. I wouldn't think it would take very much. Go slowly so you don't over heat it.

Re: Question on rehabbing wood smoother

#4

Not clear

CJ in MPLS

John:

I think David suggested trimming the body and you suggested grinding the iron (tapered iron stamped "Providence Tool Co". That is a bit equivocal.

So, let's you and him argue for a bit to see if we get a consensus. ;)

I don't think I'll need much lateral adjustment as the iron is well cambered. Therefore I'm leaning towards skimming the cheeks and not the iron. Definitely easier I think.

CJ

Re: Question on rehabbing wood smoother

#5

Re: Yes, Body

david weaver

I'd work the insides of the cheeks just a little. The plane will have plenty of adjustability (and then some) if the top of the iron can move laterally a 16th total.

If the iron is gripped tight from top to bottom, I'd try to remove the material in a taper so that there's a 16th of total lateral movement at the top and almost none at the bottom. It'll be better for the wedge and easier to set and adjust if the iron is closer to snug laterally at the bottom.

Nothing wrong with narrowing the iron and cap iron, it's just more work.

Re: Question on rehabbing wood smoother

#6

Re: Yes, Body

TomD

It's a lot less work if you have a belt sander. Is there another iron you can try in there from another plane?

You are OK with either approach it just depends one which you want to pursue. If I had made the iron, or otherwise had little reason to preserve it, I would grind it. Is the iron original to the plane? Normally they shouldn't shrink back like that if they were fitted together at birth.

I think C&W planes have 5/16" in the cheeks, and if I have your model correctly in mind the sides are probably higher.

Re: Question on rehabbing wood smoother

#7

Re: Yes, Body

david weaver

England and continental europe must be a bit more humid than here. I've stood on my share of planes with channelocks and a rag trying to get the irons out when they are sucked tight and mildly rusted.

One of the planes I had to do that on was one from baltimore, though. I think over time they just get tight and that's that, but the ones from the UK especially seem to do it more (especially evident in antique shops here where plow planes have boxwood nuts super tight on screw arms - tight or completely broken).

Re: Question on rehabbing wood smoother

#8

Re: Yes, Body

Kees

The planes I have have cheeks between 7 and 8 mm. They salso have a rather sloppy fit in the width of the iron, so overal I guess 3/4" plus the iron is the width of the plane, more or less.