New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Scary sharp sandpaper glue

Posts

Scary sharp sandpaper glue

#1

Scary sharp sandpaper glue

john Lucas

I use the scary sharp system of gluing sandpaper to glass. Since I'm a wood turner this doesn't get used a lot. Every now and then I do flat wood project and need to touch up my hand planes or chisels. I use 3M super 77 spray and it's always hard to get the sandpaper off when I need to replace it. Anyone have a better idea. Right now I use 4"x 10" pieces of glass as my substrate and cut the sandpaper to fit.

A second question. I sharpen to 1500 grit and then go to the strop. Is that where you guys stop. My chisels seem quite sharp and will shave hair easily. I did find some 2000 grit paper and wonder if I should go that extra step. It would require finding some more glass.

If you want the ultimate sharp edge (I'm thinking carving tools) what method would you use.

Re: Scary sharp sandpaper glue

#2

Re: Scary sharp sandpaper glue

Kevin French

I use WD40 or mineral spirits, then wash the glass with windex.

I go to 2000

Re: Scary sharp sandpaper glue

#3

Re: Scary sharp sandpaper glue

TomD

I use psa sandpaper, on birch ply, usually. I don't change it much, but when I do, I may need to heat gun it.

I use LV's second finest paper which is something weird like 6U.

I would switch out your fine to a 14K diamond paste. I use hard leather on birch, and just a dab will do you for a very long time. Cheap and surreal fast. Sounds expensive but you can get if for a few bucks from Amazon or Ebay. The key with diamond paste is just refresh the edge like a butcher, barber, or leather worker. Every so often, well before it goes off, refresh it. This works because the diamonds are so fast that at the earliest point you notice something off, you can still get it back with a few strokes on the 14K, so you don't need to use anything other than the 14K. That doesn't work the same with other stuff because by the time it is that gone it pays to go through the grits. Which is a whole other thing.

On chisels, or your skews you have edge access all the time. With planes it really pays to have a plane you can get in and out of action for the 14K. I can do that in 20 seconds, or less, with a Japanese plane, but it isn't something I even enjoy doing with a Bailey. I think this is a real world beating advantage to wooden planes with current sharpening tech. !0-20 seconds doesn't include the time sharpening.

Re: Scary sharp sandpaper glue

#4

Thanks most interesting


Re: Scary sharp sandpaper glue

#5

Re: Soft blades

TomD

I'm not knocking Bailey, by the way. Just if it takes me too long to cycle the blade through sharpening, I tend to leave it longer, and then getting it back with just the 14K might be more of a hassle. I have a bailey that has a fine depth adjuster that doesn't loose depth set and a screw for the cap vs. a lever; I made a single blade for it, or one could fit a Clifton breaker to it. With the right set-up it would be fast to cycle also, though that is a lot of gear to get it to where a piece of wood and steel are already at.

The pro set-up in some activities is to be constantly sharpening. One sees this in scything, shaving, butchery, leather work. Leather workers sharpen almost every cut. (There is some cultural dependence here, because other cultures do it differently...) From 10,000 feet, one thing a person might note is that these are activities where soft steel is often used (not so sure about butchery, but I think relatively soft, yes). It isn't that they don't get that hard steel holds an edge better, but there are specifics that make that undesirable. Scythes are not only sharpened continuously, but the edge needs to be peened to draw it out to a foil that will cut grass. All in a day's work.

What we have is a ratio where the sharpness requirement, steel hardness in proportion to the speed at which it can be sharpened, that favors constant touch ups with one type of sharpener, rather than running the edge down and then rebooting it with several stones/steps. Diamond makes this possible, but so does power.

Actually as far as bowl turning is concerned I have been sharpening gouges right off the grinder, single grit only, for 30 years. Same concept. The factor there is that the grinder is powered, but so is the lathe. The sharpness requirement is reduced because the lathe energizes the workpiece. A gouge needs a fresh edge, but it doesn't need to be sharp in the 8000 grit stone sense. It needs to be as keen as it can be off the grinder (there are other approaches to be sure). Since it takes no time to turn to the grinder, run a pass and keep on turning, that is one of the workable strategies. Though it is OT, lathes also allow some very powerful shear cutting, and often the use of wet wood. It is interesting all the factors that affect tool edge strategy.

Re: Scary sharp sandpaper glue

#6

Re: Soft blades

john Lucas

Tom I won't argue about turning tools not needing to be 8000 grit sharp. I'm simply trying to prove that particle metal tools will sharpen as well as Carbon steel or HSS. I've pretty much proved that already but just for grins I'm trying to see if I can sharpen them incredibly sharp just to see if they still sharpen the same or is one better. It's not a scientific test although I do plan to photograph them through a microscope to look at the edge. The problem I only have 3 tools, one from each group and don't know the actual hardness of any of them. As you probably know hardness can also affect how sharp a tool can get. It's just a fun experiment that started when I hear over and over that particle metal won't take a good edge. I knew that was wrong because I can sharpen my particle metal skew sharp enough to cut big swaths of hair off my arm. I've sharpened the 3 tools to a very fine edge and can't tell the difference but thought I would try to sharpen them even finer just to see.

Re: Scary sharp sandpaper glue

#7

Glass

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

A couple of years ago, at a local place that buys storage lockers and sells off the contents, I picked up a truly ugly 80s coffee table consisting of 1/2" plate glass panels, nicely rounded edges, assembled into table legs with metal brackets. One panel had a corner chipped off, so I paid maybe $5 for it. I gave away the chipped panel to someone just starting out in woodworking, but still have plenty of glass for scary sharpiness. Odd how, when you become aware of the uses of that sort of material, it starts to show up.

Re: Scary sharp sandpaper glue

#8

Re: Soft blades

TomD

Yeah. I used to hear that carbide router bits couldn't be razor sharp due to some size of the carbides stuff. But when I got my TR12 router it came with a shaving sharp bit. I have no problem with sharpening turning tools razor sharp and do it for certain cases. Just drawing a picture of how certain variable work together, and the turning tools popped into my head, but that was Raffan stuff, people have come a long way. Equally there are razors, head knives, butcher knives, and scythes based on hard laminated blade tech, and they are used by pros in their respective countries.

Re: Scary sharp sandpaper glue

#9

Re: Glass

TomD

It's the Secret, you are manifesting, like an SOB. I often wonder how when I read something, and some odd thing comes to my attention, maybe an antique sewing machine, my Hardinger Mill, or my South Bend shaper, and I check on Ebay, or KIJIJI, and there it is. Sometimes I go for it, more recently now that I need a lazy suzan to turn around in the shop, I mostly don't. But the funny thing is I often never find another one of those deals ever again.

Recently I have picked up some glass tops. I am making some glass top coffee tables. Not sure that is really my thing, but it sure makes cleaning up coffee stains easier.

Re: Scary sharp sandpaper glue

#10

Re: Glass 'showing up'

Kevin French

Back in the day when I had a great dump to pick I showed up and there was a stack of around 60 pieces of 10 x 16 x 3/16" beveled edge plate glass sitting in the 'Mini Mall'.

Because it was so thin I Duct Taped the back to keep it from shattering when it did break. I put a pair of 3 x 11" piece of sandpaper on each sheet of glass and have 10 different grits of paper 60 - 2000. I keep extra sheet with the lower grit as they have to do most of the initial work but then its just a matter of wiping and swapping out plates of glass.

Re: Scary sharp sandpaper glue

#11

Work already been done and reported

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Check out Steve Elliot's web site. He showed equivalent results on any tool steel so long as the sharpening media was appropriate.

Re: Scary sharp sandpaper glue

#12

Re: Work already been done and reported

john Lucas

Bill I can't find his website. At least not one with any info on sharpening.

Re: Scary sharp sandpaper glue

#14

I'm at work

Steve Elliott

The information you're looking for is on a page called "Initial Sharpness" in the "Results" section of my blade testing site. I'll try linking to it below.

To summarize: by using fine diamond paste on a cast iron lap I was able to bring all the types of steel I tested up to a level of sharpness equal to the sharpness I could achieve with plain high carbon steel on fine waterstones. They were sharp enough to catch and cut arm hair with the blade held a quarter inch above my skin. I'm sure there are greater degrees of sharpness possible but I doubt they are needed for woodworking.

The more wear-resistant alloys contained carbide particles that were harder than the abrasives in oilstones and waterstones, at least the ones I was familiar with at the time. I haven't followed the newer generation of waterstones. These alloys could be abraded by cutting the steel matrix but the edge sharpness was limited by the size of the carbide particles.

If you want to get a good sharp edge on high speed steel (M2 or M4) or Holtey's S53 I would suggest fine diamond or chromium oxide as the final honing medium.

I can't find a way to link to the web page using my smartphone but will try again using my home computer.

Re: Scary sharp sandpaper glue

#15

The URL *LINK*

Steve Elliott

Here's the link to the "Initial Sharpness" page on my website.


Initial Sharpness

Re: Scary sharp sandpaper glue

#16

My sharpness test

john Lucas

Thanks Steve. Very interesting. I have sharpened 3 tools at roughly 30 degrees. One High Carbon steel, one High speed steel and one V11 particle metal. All were sharpened to 1200 grit using wet or dry paper. All seemed to achieve the same level of sharpness cutting hair and shaving paper. Not a definitive test like yours but the most practical I could come up with.

Then I stropped them with a hard Felt wheel charged with Gold carvers stropping paste. It brought all of them to a level above the previous sharpness. I judged this by shaving paper but starting the cut about 3 inches from my fingers which I have found over the years to be a good indication of sharpeness. If it starts the cut easily and then shaves the paper it's plenty sharp enough for the most delicate hand carving.

As near as I can tell all 3 steels achieved the same level of sharpness.

Re: Scary sharp sandpaper glue

#17

Re: I'm at work

david weaver

"greater degree of sharpness"

Probably not. The gold standard in razoring is catching a hair and severing it without splitting it.

Anything beyond that is too transient to be practical *on a razor*. On a tool, the level of practicality in the context of work is well below for all but a very few tasks.

(I'm picturing in my mind, the users in this forum attempting to hold their plane irons and chisels 1/4" above their arms to see if they can catch and separate and sever a hair without splitting it along its length. Those with very fine arm hair will be disappointed in the results).

Re: Scary sharp sandpaper glue

#18

I ageee

Steve Elliott

The degree of sharpness I shoot for in my everyday work is lower than the level I described. Speed of sharpening matters to me and the I'm well satisfied with what I get from 1 micron diamond (for smoothing plane blades) and 8000 or higher waterstones (for chisels).

The edges I get are pretty much equivalent in sharpness but some of my plane blades are more highly alloyed.

I've seen a few videos of sharpness tests for razor blades that go way beyond what I need for woodworking. There may be differences in achievable sharpness for different alloys at that level but that doesn't matter to my work.