Re: Soft blades
TomD
I'm not knocking Bailey, by the way. Just if it takes me too long to cycle the blade through sharpening, I tend to leave it longer, and then getting it back with just the 14K might be more of a hassle. I have a bailey that has a fine depth adjuster that doesn't loose depth set and a screw for the cap vs. a lever; I made a single blade for it, or one could fit a Clifton breaker to it. With the right set-up it would be fast to cycle also, though that is a lot of gear to get it to where a piece of wood and steel are already at.
The pro set-up in some activities is to be constantly sharpening. One sees this in scything, shaving, butchery, leather work. Leather workers sharpen almost every cut. (There is some cultural dependence here, because other cultures do it differently...) From 10,000 feet, one thing a person might note is that these are activities where soft steel is often used (not so sure about butchery, but I think relatively soft, yes). It isn't that they don't get that hard steel holds an edge better, but there are specifics that make that undesirable. Scythes are not only sharpened continuously, but the edge needs to be peened to draw it out to a foil that will cut grass. All in a day's work.
What we have is a ratio where the sharpness requirement, steel hardness in proportion to the speed at which it can be sharpened, that favors constant touch ups with one type of sharpener, rather than running the edge down and then rebooting it with several stones/steps. Diamond makes this possible, but so does power.
Actually as far as bowl turning is concerned I have been sharpening gouges right off the grinder, single grit only, for 30 years. Same concept. The factor there is that the grinder is powered, but so is the lathe. The sharpness requirement is reduced because the lathe energizes the workpiece. A gouge needs a fresh edge, but it doesn't need to be sharp in the 8000 grit stone sense. It needs to be as keen as it can be off the grinder (there are other approaches to be sure). Since it takes no time to turn to the grinder, run a pass and keep on turning, that is one of the workable strategies. Though it is OT, lathes also allow some very powerful shear cutting, and often the use of wet wood. It is interesting all the factors that affect tool edge strategy.