New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Medicine Cabinets - Complete

Posts

Re: Medicine Cabinets - Complete

#2

Re: Medicine Cabinets - Complete

Steve Voigt

What a beauty! Lovely grain.

Brian, congrats on the blog. You should also consider posting your stuff on Instagram. It would fit your style of progress photos very well, and you would reach a different and ultimately much bigger audience than on the forums. Something to consider.

Re: Medicine Cabinets - Complete

#3

Re: Medicine Cabinets - Complete

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Handsome looking door. I can imagine using that appearance on some future project. Now I know what the door looks like I need to go back and review how it was put together. Your joinery is often novel by my limited experience and I sometimes have trouble seeing where the parts are going until they get there.

Re: Medicine Cabinets - Complete

#4

Re: Medicine Cabinets - Complete

Brian Holcombe

Thank you both!

Steve, definitely something to consider. I post on a few boards and actually have been getting hits from possibly google or another source...or just people who lurk the boards without posting.

Bill, I've been contemplating posting up some drawings or something of that effect prior to building. I've been thinking it may be helpful for people to follow along with a picture in their mind of the end product, especially when I get into certain joinery.

It may actually be helpful to me, as well, to draw things out in a sketchup type program. I've always just make some quick hand drawings and proceeded with a mental picture of how I want to proceed. I tend to work out the details on paper and kind of gloss over everything else, but it could be worthwhile to see the piece before going ahead with it.

Re: Medicine Cabinets - Complete

#5

I still don't understand the door joinery

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I can be dense about these things. I don't mean this to be negative in any way but your joinery is so different from my experience that I have trouble following it. In the case of the door I like the result so I would like to understand it.

Let's see if I do. referring to the picture.....


You built a frame out of 5 horizontal pieces and 2 vertical pieces then inset and glued or whatever the panel to this frame?

The middle wider three pieces are M&T into the verticals? The ends of the verticals are M&T into the top and bottom horizontals? I don't know how the panel is installed. Does it float somehow?

Re: Medicine Cabinets - Complete

#6

Looks great!


Re: Medicine Cabinets - Complete

#7

Re: I still don't understand the door joinery

Brian Holcombe

Pretty close, but with a few exceptions. The center three horizontal battens are mortised into the uprights. They are dovetailed into the panel with tapered sliding dovetails. The reason being is that it allows the panel to float, I rabbetted the outside edges of the panel to mostly cover the connection.

The top horizontal pieces are grooved to accept rabbetted edges at the top and bottom of the panel. They're joined to the verticals with a combination of half laps and stub tenons that are miters toward the outside edge.

All of this should basically make a strong frame and flush mount panel which can move with seasonal change and not self destruct but keep a minimal outside appearance.

Glad that you like effect! I think I'll put this to use again on future projects, especially those with sliding doors. My plan is to build new cabinets for the bathroom and do eventually all of the doors will match in style. I also plan done open shelving which will also match.

Re: Medicine Cabinets - Complete

#10

Re: Medicine Cabinets - Complete

North of the Border

Nicely designed and presented.

Re: Medicine Cabinets - Complete

#12

Re: Medicine Cabinets - Complete

david weaver

Very nice clean work, as usual!

What else can be said? 1000 other medicine cabinets and 999 wouldn't be as nice. Maybe not the thousandth either.

Re: Medicine Cabinets - Complete

#13

Re: Medicine Cabinets - Complete

Brian Holcombe

:D Thank you!

It was received well as a valentine's day gift, so that's a good sign. Usually when I give my wife woodwork for a holiday she will roll her eyes, hah.

Cheers!

Brian

Re: Medicine Cabinets - Complete

#14

Lovely but complex

GolfSteve in Calgary

Lovely medicine cabinets, and excellent woodworking skills.

However, after watching your build I have to quote Tage Frid when commenting on a student's table design: "You've just figured out the most complicated way to hold a board 30 inches off the floor."

I, too, will be building some medicine cabinets in the near future. Due to the fact that I'm only allocated four score and twenty years on this planet and I've already lived two score and six of those years, I think I'll use a simpler design :-)

Re: Medicine Cabinets - Complete

#15

Re: Reminds me of..

david weaver

.. what happens when I tell people I shave with a straight razor. They say "how long does that take?" and I tell them it takes about four minutes. Three to shave, and one to strop and put my stuff away, five minutes if I take two passes (because each doesn't have to be as good as one).

Everyone loves to tell me about how their electric shaver takes two minutes.

And they're confused when I say "yes, but I've taking something that used to just be something I have to do, and now it's something I love to do every day".

Brian could've built a very plain medicine cabinet like I have done in the past (though I did dovetail the case when I made mine, too), but then it might seem like something he just had to do, and not like something he could do the way he'd love to do it.

Re: Medicine Cabinets - Complete

#16

Re: Reminds me of..

TomD

I have a beard which still leaves a fair bit of shaving. No doubt the SR is faster than anything else. It cuts right up to the line, or past it. I do one side with one hand and the other with the other. I don't have to rinse the blade until I switch hands since there is nothing to clog. I can also trim the beard part with the razor using a slight combing action. It's fast. And there isn't that whole thing where I stand stunned in the aisle at the cost of blades.

Re: Medicine Cabinets - Complete

#17

Re: Reminds me of..

GolfSteve in Calgary

I understand wanting to build something complicated just because you want to :-) and I hope he has a big smile on his face every time he uses the medicine cabinet and knows that there's hidden half-blind dovetails hidden behind the drywall :-)

Re: Medicine Cabinets - Complete

#18

Re: Reminds me of..

North of the Border

When i build something, I usually go with the path that's least resisting. Not because I lack the skills or the interest to undertake a complex project, but because I have to be productive. Only when I am to show craftsmanship would I, for example, cut my dovetails by hand, or plane instead of sand.

I think I enjoy both equally, alternating between quick, simple work and elaborate, skill-demanding builds. Doing everything falling into just one category can be a bit boring.

Re: Medicine Cabinets - Complete

#19

Re: Reminds me of..

TomD

That is why Krenov originally said the best work was done by amateurs. It isn't taking too long if it is hobby woodworking and you are spending a certain amount of time a day on something you like. Whatever amount you get done, you are still making time fly.

Re: Medicine Cabinets - Complete

#20

Re: The decision process you described..

david weaver

...sounds familar to me, except I never cut dovetails any other way than by hand, but you can do fast work cutting them by hand, too, if you eyeball everything and don't worry about cosmetic perfection.

My judgement about whether or not I should do something quickly or exactly the way I'd want to has more to do with whether or not I wanted to build the project in the first place.

If the answer is no, then I tend to be less attached to the results, and I try to work with unbroken rhythm making progress such that all of my decisions about the fitness of the work actually occur while working. If the answer is yes, I'll stop to check results much more.

Re: Medicine Cabinets - Complete

#21

Clint Searl

Re: Reminds me of..

Clint Searl

Is "best work" that which is flawlessly constructed, or that which makes one swoon at the beauty of the design without looking at the dovetails?

Re: Medicine Cabinets - Complete

#22

Re: Lovely but complex

Brian Holcombe

Sorry for the late reply, I did not see this addition to the thread.

Dovetails were functional and mainly hidden in casework long before they were visible and broadcasted. They perform the task at hand and reduce reliance upon glue, with the addition of the outside surround on the case it minimizes the possibility that a miter will open at some point or that the case sides will bow.

So in a time when a mitered case was assumed to have a row of hidden dovetails, were they making things complicated or simply making good work?

The piece, to my eye, appears simple and that was one goal of the project. To allow those who do investigate further to discover the thought process and complication involved in making something appear simple.

As an aside, I saw a video some time ago of a Japanese workshop turning out some impressive furniture in a very unassuming unpretentious manner. There was one fellow who stands out in my mind, sitting on the floor and knocking out full blind dovetails at a pace quicker than I can do through dovetails, then knocking them together to achieve what appeared to be a flawless miter. How does one get to that point? I assume it takes quite a few hours in the workshop reliant upon hand and eye.

Re: Medicine Cabinets - Complete

#23

Re: Reminds me of..

Brian Holcombe

Both :D

Re: Medicine Cabinets - Complete

#25

Re: Kotaro Tanaka

Brian Holcombe

Thanks David, that's the guy. I get a kick out of when he karate chops the thin stock as well.