New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

work bench top glue choices

Posts

work bench top glue choices

#1

work bench top glue choices

Eric in Los Gatos

I'm starting to build my last (I know) bench and have decided on the split top roubo design from Benchcrafted. I was just going to use extended open time PVA but recall that The Schwartz said somewhere that he used and like epoxy for a bench build. I'm pretty open and am wondering what your folks experience is. Any recommendations would be welcome.

Thanks for your help.

Eric in Los Gatos

Re: work bench top glue choices

#2

reson for epoxy?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I would want to hear a reason for using epoxy before enduring the expense. Any commonly used woodworking glue makes a bond stronger than wood so strength is not a reason to deviate from traditional glue.

Re: work bench top glue choices

#3

Re: reson for epoxy?

Eric in Los Gatos

Agreed. All I can think of is gap filling. I certainly would like to avoid the expense.

Eric

Re: work bench top glue choices

#4

Re: reson for epoxy?

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

If I remember, Chris only used epoxy to fill the cracks and voids in the work bench top.

Re: work bench top glue choices

#5

Re: work bench top glue choices

david weaver

Inexpensive yellow glue. I think I got a gallon of titebond on sale for $23 and used less than half of it on my bench.

it's better to just do a good job milling the boards and not have gaps than it is to need epoxy for them.

Re: work bench top glue choices

#6

Re: work bench top glue choices

TomD

I never epoxied the tops of my benches except to hardware bond breadboards and stuff. Also I saturated end grain on one of them which is worth the effort and basically an outgrowth of bonding Good epoxy is more resistant to creep than average yellow and white glues and will sometimes hold wood better, though the end result of not having the creep resistance on a bench top might be that a raised edge could be felt, which can be fixed with a swipe from a plane, so it probably isn't worth the trouble. I use Titebond 1 for creep resistance in that category of products. Epoxy is like grease, so something to keep the boards aligned is worthwhile. Raka is a good brand I wouldn't call it expensive, west is better, but mostly depends on what you want down to do with the surplus, or which you want to learn.

Re: work bench top glue choices

#7

You are correct - only for the cracks


Re: work bench top glue choices

#8

Re: work bench top glue choices

AZ in Colorado Springs

Titebond extend.

Re: work bench top glue choices

#9

Re: work bench top glue choices

Eric in Los Gatos

That was my thought. Although I read someplace recently that you can make any Titebond extend by diluting it about 10% with water.

Re: work bench top glue choices

#10

Re: work bench top glue choices

AZ in Colorado Springs

I would not do that, myself. I'm not a chemist, but it seems to me that you'll just have watered-down glue. The same volume of "stuff" from your glue bottle will be between the boards but it'll contain 10% less glue. And there will be more water in that same space.

TB extend does seem to be more viscous than regular TB but I doubt it's simply watered-down.

Re: work bench top glue choices

#11

Re: work bench top glue choices

TomD

You can extend open time by just using a lot of the stuff. Not a great practice in neat joinery situations, one reason I like white glue for some of that. But on a lam top, just belt it to it, the greater volume of wet will keep it open. And if you stack the parts, you get a lot of open time when they are in contact and not able to dry, but not yet clamped. Titebond one is the most creep resistant, which is pretty much all that maters to me.

Re: work bench top glue choices

#12

Re: work bench top glue choices

Paul M

When I built my bench, I assembled the top in two sections. That way I could run each half of the bench through my little thickness planer to hog off most of the rough board edges. I glued up each of the half benches with Titebond, and there has been no creep for years.

But when I glued the two half-benches together, I used slow set epoxy since I had gaps to fill. Trying to get two 10" x 3" x 8ft bench segments to mate together perfectly for Titebond usage was just not going to happen. And no amount of clamps were going to close any gaps in that much timber.