Re: Medicine Cabinet Doors Part V
david weaver
I can only provide a single opinion on sandstones - I've got two, but they are bench stone size. One of them is like a coarse (or is a coarse) hindostan stone, and the other is something a lot more like a sandstone grindstone (more coarse and aggressive).
They are OK, but they are a step down from novaculite, and they struggle to cut things that are very hard. I think they make a good grindstone on something like an old english or american tool that's on the soft side, but nothing really beats crystolon stones for grinding. Sharp particles and just a little bit of friability. And a light oil works much better for keeping the stone clean than water.
It puts you in a real conundrum for things like kiyotada because kiyotada's stuff will sometimes shatter at the edge on silicon carbide (I wouldn't even think of coarse diamonds), but the things that are gentler on steel can't touch it because of hardness. It's best to do whatever it takes to get those tools in shape and maintain them incrementally. That doesn't help much with kanna, though - it's easy to stretch a chisel way out in terms of time between sharpenings that remove an appreciable amount, but not kanna.
What makes a suita able to cut the very hard japanese steel is a small amount of natural aluminum oxide mixed with the silica particles. Without the alumina, they're dead in the water on 65 hardness type stuff.
(I could be in the weeds - a sandstone would work fine on the plane iron I sent you, but carborundum/crystolon doesn't injure those on a bevel grind and it's still faster).