New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Medicine Cabinet Doors Part IV

Posts

Re: Medicine Cabinet Doors Part IV

#3

Re: Medicine Cabinet Doors Part V

david weaver

Love the suita stone (of course)!

At some point, I'm going to have whittled my sharpening stone pile down to the basics, and that will be oilstones, a diamond hone, a jasper and a (maybe two) suita stone.

It's too bad they aren't more available for cheap prices.

Re: Medicine Cabinet Doors Part IV

#4

Re: Medicine Cabinet Doors Part V

Brian Holcombe

The Suita has treated me very well, I use it for everything but the Kanna, well I use for that but everything shy of the finished edge.

I know what you mean I basically dump everything I don't find useful after a short while.

I've been doing a bit of research on giant sandstones....and my wife thinks I'm loosing my mind haha.

Re: Medicine Cabinet Doors Part IV

#5

Re: Medicine Cabinet Doors Part V

david weaver

I can only provide a single opinion on sandstones - I've got two, but they are bench stone size. One of them is like a coarse (or is a coarse) hindostan stone, and the other is something a lot more like a sandstone grindstone (more coarse and aggressive).

They are OK, but they are a step down from novaculite, and they struggle to cut things that are very hard. I think they make a good grindstone on something like an old english or american tool that's on the soft side, but nothing really beats crystolon stones for grinding. Sharp particles and just a little bit of friability. And a light oil works much better for keeping the stone clean than water.

It puts you in a real conundrum for things like kiyotada because kiyotada's stuff will sometimes shatter at the edge on silicon carbide (I wouldn't even think of coarse diamonds), but the things that are gentler on steel can't touch it because of hardness. It's best to do whatever it takes to get those tools in shape and maintain them incrementally. That doesn't help much with kanna, though - it's easy to stretch a chisel way out in terms of time between sharpenings that remove an appreciable amount, but not kanna.

What makes a suita able to cut the very hard japanese steel is a small amount of natural aluminum oxide mixed with the silica particles. Without the alumina, they're dead in the water on 65 hardness type stuff.

(I could be in the weeds - a sandstone would work fine on the plane iron I sent you, but carborundum/crystolon doesn't injure those on a bevel grind and it's still faster).

Re: Medicine Cabinet Doors Part IV

#6

Re: Medicine Cabinet Doors Part V

Brian Holcombe

That's where I am at most of the time. I'm pretty happy on chisels and so far on Kanna.

The issue crops up when I get a small chip or something of that nature and spend an hour or two grinding it away.

I wouldn't mind a slightly quicker method, but it looks like they're all trade offs. I may well get a grinding wheel for my western stuff and just continue the same approach on my Japanese stuff (which works quite well but could certainly be quicker in the prep stages).

Re: Medicine Cabinet Doors Part IV

#7

Re: Medicine Cabinet Doors Part V

david weaver

That time spent is what eventually drove me away from using kanna on a regular basis (especially on anything with any hardness). there is no way around the total sharpening time being more, but there also really isn't anything that matches the brightness of finish on soft wood.

A crystolon stone works well as a starting point on most of them, though, except perhaps the hardest of hard due to brittleness.

Re: Medicine Cabinet Doors Part IV

#8

Re: Medicine Cabinet Doors Part V

Brian Holcombe

I enjoy the Kanna, but for me I am feeling the exact same way. The #4 plane is hard to surpass on harder material. If I sharpen up the blade on the #4 and then on the kanna, the Kanna will beat it....barely. With my best stone and the Kunio blade I can turn an absolute mirror on softwoods, but it's a tough act to keep going. Where the #4 is simple, in and out and back to work.

I'll keep at both of them, maybe at some point I will be able to master both sides and can really crank along....not quite there yet.

Re: Medicine Cabinet Doors Part IV

#9

Re: Medicine Cabinet Doors Part V

david weaver

Not that anyone else is interested in our discussion, but...I lost steam on the kanna when I looked around on youtube and saw obviously professional users spending 5-7 or more minutes in some cases resharpening their planes.

I am *way* too lazy for that.

I've fiddled with just about everything, though, before landing on the washita for most plane irons, but a middle stone and a suita doesn't work bad, either (or soft ark and then suita). Same principle, fast resharpening without removing too much more material than what is there in wear.

I still will keep a couple of japanese planes around, though. Just past the idea that I'll use them regularly (a cheap one is nice to have around for a jack if you are really doing a lot of dimensioning and starting to get tired from pushing - I have one of the fuunji planes that japan woodworker used to sell for $60, and the temper isn't that hard so you can sharpen and grind them and they are still very good dry plain carbon steel).

Re: Medicine Cabinet Doors Part IV

#10

Re: Medicine Cabinet Doors Part V

Brian Holcombe

Absolutely, the western planes, at least in my experience are much easier to get back to work with. I took apart the try plane this morning after about three days of planing and had it back on the wood in a few minutes.

The higher pitch also allows me to put significantly more wear on the western blades prior to resharpening. I notice pretty quickly when the Kanna gets dull. I probably get 1/2 day of serious planing out of it before I'm back at the stones, I can see why Stanley carries two in the box.

It's good to have both, and I'm pretty happy with both, but I tend to save my Kanna for that last operation and I could probably due with one setup as a jack as well (which would probably last a good while), but I'm very happy with the wooden jack.

I'm waiting on some parts for this project (hinges) so I've been prepping stock for a tool box - toy box, and I still have not sharpened the jack and it still doesn't even blink.

Random toys keep finding their way into my study, so I've decided to build a Japanese tool box to house them....a little excessive, but it should provide a nice storage spot for my boy's stuff that he can use when he is older for whatever he wants to use it for....or tools.