New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Who has had tallow dry? Does it and how long?

Posts

Who has had tallow dry? Does it and how long?

#1

Who has had tallow dry? Does it and how long?

david weaver

I ask that question in all honesty. I oil and wax my planes relatively regulary, and I put a grotesque amount on them sometimes because I care less about what they look like.

Not everyone does that, though, and a couple of years ago, mutton tallow was all the rage because there was a blog post about it.

I've got an old plane that has very hard tallow (i believe it to be tallow) on it. What actually happens when you put new tallow on a plane, does it grease up the surface (and thus end up on your hands and then on workpieces) or does it get soaked in or what?

Curious, as I bought a pound of it off of ebay - same brand as the 1 oz stuff sold by woodworking shops, just a lot cheaper in a pint tub.

Re: Who has had tallow dry? Does it and how long?

#2

Re: Who has had tallow dry? Does it and how long?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Almost any fat or veggie oil has reactive parts of the molecule that will cross link over time and make the stuff rubbery (oil) or crumbly (fat). The reaction might take months or years but it will go on forever.

I don't see why linseed oil would not be a preferred choice. It is dandy for gun stocks that are going to be used. If you want the oil to stay liquid use olive oil. If the plane is made of walnut use walnut oil :)

Re: Who has had tallow dry? Does it and how long?

#3

Re: Who has had tallow dry? Does it and how long?

david weaver

I liked the finish on my old jt brown plane when I got it. The plane was little used, perhaps not at all, but someone had diligently slathered it with stuff that had dried sort of crusty. I'm assuming it was tallow.

I'm also assuming since tallow is presumably the most refined state of fat rendered, that it's really stable and thus will take next to forever to change to that state.

I do like linseed oil, but some folks don't like oils with driers, and raw linseed oil does take a long time to cure.

I've noticed with my planes that I can get a shiny surface on a plane from oil and wax, but the plane seems to continue to absorb it over time, or something of that sort. I haven't really heavily built up the linseed oil yet, but I think I will on the next plane I build or maybe a pair of moulders that I've built in the past.

My solve all, or maybe I should call it salve all is beeswax and mineral oil. I use it to prevent rust and to make a non drying wax on things like handles. It also works well on hands.

Re: Who has had tallow dry? Does it and how long?

#4

they all harden with time

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"I'm also assuming since tallow is presumably the most refined state of fat rendered, that it's really stable and thus will take next to forever to change to that state. "

The ability of the typical fat or oil to react with oxygen and change is an inherent property of the acids that make up the glycerin ester mixture we call "fats and oils". Some fats and oils have more reactive acids than others and they change quicker- linseed oil curing for example. Some have greatly less like olive oil and they cure at glacial rates, essentially never. Most are in between.

Some acids result in a glycerin ester that remains oily. This case is typical of plant fat(oil). The larger acid molecules in animal fat make a glycerin ester that is more solid (beef) or less solid (chicken) or in between (sheep). But the acids that make up all these fats and oil react with oxygen to become more solid over time and produce stinky byproducts.

Re: Who has had tallow dry? Does it and how long?

#5

Linseed oil drier paranoia

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Where does this stuff come from?

The Linseed oil direr paranoia is amusing to someone that feeds animal mineral supplement to their stock. Cobalt and manganese, a typical drier constituent, is an essential mineral for animals. It is essential to supplement your stock with a mineral mix that contains this mineral if it is not already present in their forage.

A cattle mineral mix contains selenium, copper, cobalt, manganese, zinc, iron....And then we eat the cattle that eat these "toxic" minerals. Well, we also eat the vegetables that soak up these minerals from the earth. And this a good thing for we would die without them.

And given these facts some fret over a tiny amount of cobalt in linseed oil. What ever do they imagine it will do to them in this oil?

Re: Who has had tallow dry? Does it and how long?

#6

Lead

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Within my memory lead was the common drier in linseed oil and oil varnishes. Litharge, red lead, and lead acetate were used. Also sometimes manganese. I think cobalt is relatively new in this field. .

I probably used linseed oil that had lead in it 40 and 50 years ago; I do not notice a difference in today's oil.

Re: Who has had tallow dry? Does it and how long?

#7

Re: Lead

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I would presume lead vanished from linseed oil when it vanished from paint, if in fact it was ever used in linseed oil in the first place. I have a book on finish formulations, printed 1925. Manganese compounds are listed as a "drier", along with white lead and other lead pigments. One would presume that the lead pigment driers were only used in paint and not clear varnish. No formulations are given for making varnish; I suppose by this time finishers didn't make their own. So it remains unknown to me if lead was ever used in linseed oil. But in any case it is of no concern today, or then unless you intended to eat some.

I don't know when cobalt got recognized as an excellent drier. Likely by early 1970's.

Re: Who has had tallow dry? Does it and how long?

#8

Re: Linseed oil drier paranoia

david weaver

It's not one of my bugaboos - I use it readily and with bare hands (fastest way to get it on something without having half of the oil end up in a rag).

I have heard several people say that it gives them a headache (BLO) while linseed oil doesn't.

All of us are wired differently.

I know a lot of folks see shellac as a very easy to tolerate finish when applying, but I have (rare, unless excited) asthma that inhalation of alcohol vapors affects. So when I even do something like padding or brushing shellac on the inside of a case, I cannot tolerate it. It doesn't matter what the alcohol is, either, as the assumption is that alcohol for human consumption is fine to use since it doesn't have methyl or denaturants in it. Same result for me (which is not surprising, inhaling edible alcohol vapors still kills brain cells, though it's certainly less unhealthy than licking a plutonium lollipop).

I can't spray shellac because I don't have an explosion proof room, but I can spray water based finishes. They also cause asthmatic problems where as vapors of toluene, etc (which are known to be unhealthy) do not. Of course, 98% of the time I spray something, I'm wearing a respirator no matter what. I just don't necessarily trust that the things that are "environmentally" more friendly are people friendly, I'd bet they aren't.

Re: Who has had tallow dry? Does it and how long?

#9

Re: Lead

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have been using linseed oil since 1962. It was common knowledge that it had lead in it. Newell and Holtrop (1930, I have the 1972 edition) mentions lead as a drier for both "boiled linseed oil " and varnishes. They also mention cobalt, but suggest it was not much in use. Artist Materials, Ralph Mayer (1940, I have the 1976 edition) mentions that lead was added to linseed oil by the Romans (Pliny 78AD et al.) and in the Middle ages, but that cobalt was replacing lead as a drier for artist's paints. The impression I have had is that in the mid 20th century many varmishes had several different driers in their formulas.

Lead paint was outlawed in 1978.

Re: Who has had tallow dry? Does it and how long?

#10

Re: Who has had tallow dry? Does it and how long?

John in NM

I wouldn't assume tallow is especially stable - it is basically what is left over after one cooks their bacon after all :D Or roasts some beef (now I want roast beef and Yorkshire pudding!)

When I use linseed oil, it is usually whatever I have around or get at the hardware store, so I'm not much bothered by the drier question. However, if you want to avoid it in order to maximize appeal (as a plane maker I'm assuming?) you could consider a drying box. Cardboard box inside another with insulation between (more card board, vermiculite, fiberglass) and a glass top. Out here, if I need it fast, I just leave linseed oiled stuff in the sun a couple hours and it's dry.

Re: Who has had tallow dry? Does it and how long?

#11

Re: If I don't like it...

david weaver

...i could always turn it into soap, I guess. Most of my favorite shave soaps are tallow based or have extra stearic acid added.

(I think they use beef tallow, though, and it's probably similar but with a slightly different acid profile).

Re: Who has had tallow dry? Does it and how long?

#12

Or....

John in NM

You could put it on your boots :D Tallow is a bit stiffer than most commercial dressings and soaks in nicely with a bit of heat applied. I've been using sheep tallow that I got from Bill, and it works really well. Only trouble is your boots smell kinda sheepie, or in this case beefy (though I did have a dog for a while who just loved that! :D )

Of course, not everyone wears boots....

Re: Who has had tallow dry? Does it and how long?

#13

Re: right now...

david weaver

my shoes and leather stuff is already stinky from neatsfoot!

(but I'll keep that in mind, I doubt I'll use a pound of it on planes because I do like oil and wax so much).

Re: Who has had tallow dry? Does it and how long?

#14

Re: Who has had tallow dry? Does it and how long?

Ron Harper

I got some tallow from someone on this site a few years ago and I love it. However, I only use it on sawblades and metal plane soles. On my wooden planes, I use a wax that I make using BLO, beeswax,and Carnauba. I really do not put it on very thick.

Re: Who has had tallow dry? Does it and how long?

#15

Re: Linseed oil drier paranoia

AlanWS

The dose makes the poison. Selenium, for example is quite poisonous, but small amounts of it are necessary nutrients. There are lots of examples, but the most poisonous thing known is botulinum toxin, which some people have injected into their faces on purpose as Botox. It is possible that some metals used as hardeners might not be good for you even if they are added at some level to animal feed. But once hardened, they are not very accessible anyway.

Tallow is pretty much a saturated fat, meaning there are no C-C double bonds that could hold more H atoms. This means it has a much lower tendency to crosslink than do monounsaturated fats like those in olive oil, which have a much lower tendency to harden than polyunsaturated fats -- the "hardening oils". So my guess is that there is little hardening of tallow within your lifetime, and that any apparent hardening is simply dirt being held by the gummy stuff.

Re: Who has had tallow dry? Does it and how long?

#16

Tallow composition

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


As you can see about half the weight of the tallow is from unsaturated fatty acids.

The low amount of polyunsaturated acids means it will harden(some) slowly (months& years not days)

Re: Who has had tallow dry? Does it and how long?

#17

Re: Who has had tallow dry? Does it and how long?

david weaver

Thanks for chiming in, Ron.

I'm getting the sense that I'll do the same. I thought I might slather a plane with it (still might, just not one I'm using all the time), but it's sounding like a less good idea. I knew it would take a long time to dry, but I was led too much by the end result on a 200 year old plane, and not enough by sense about what it would be like to use the plane between.

I have a beeswax and mineral oil mix that functions the same way you're using tallow (and it costs about a quarter as much if you make it yourself).

Bill mentions that it might need more polyunsaturated oil to harden, which is an option now that "the internets" can serve up just about anything that's legal (or otherwise) to buy.

Re: Who has had tallow dry? Does it and how long?

#18

you have been misled.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

....by me.

"Bill mentions that it might need more polyunsaturated oil to harden, which is an option now that "the internets" can serve up just about anything that's legal (or otherwise) to buy."

The polyunsaturation needs to be in the fat molecule. It would take some sort of chemistry experiment to add the necessary unsaturation to tallow. This all seems like a needless way to replicate the properties of the drying oils readily available- Linseed, Tung and Walnut. Millions of gun stocks can't be wrong.

Re: Who has had tallow dry? Does it and how long?

#19

A few notes

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have never put a lubricant on a wooden plane. I have had a hand planed surface on all the soles for over 40 years. These surfaces are a quite a bit smoother than an abraded surface would be, and perhaps less in need of help. For flattening I use a smoothing plane and only plane the high spots, which is a different way of working than for a panel.

Roubo illustrates a "fat box" under the bench (plate 11 figure 7) and says it is for lubricating tools, but does not say which tools. Until recent years, I had been thinking saws rather than planes. Has any one seen a historic reference to lubrication, be it wax, oil, or tallow on plane soles? Do the Japanese lubricate a dai?

Re: Who has had tallow dry? Does it and how long?

#20

Re: A few notes

Brian Holcombe

I'm the Guinea pig for this one, I put some mutton tallow on my planes.

Re: Who has had tallow dry? Does it and how long?

#21

Re: A few notes

david weaver

Hi warren, where I was off base was that I noticed that the tallow or something similar had dried on the jointer that I have, but on the sides and top. It encased the front of the plane.

I hadn't even been thinking of using it as a lubricant, but more as a preventive to fast moisture chance since beech is so poorly behaved on the ends when it manages to lose moisture quickly.

It's only been in the last couple of days that I realize that most people are using it as a metal preservative or lubricant.

I agree on the solves of the planes, they are almost mirror. If mine get anything after the initial oil and wax that is the actual finish of the plane, it is only a small amount of paraffin, which is almost too slick. It is nice to have the tiniest bit of friction so as to encourage long shavings to be continuous from end to end when it's warranted.

Despite all of this, my jack plane still has a check in the middle of the sole. It could be a defect in the wood, though. I have gotten two billets in the batch that I've received that have a void in the center of the billet from improper drying.