New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Wood for bench?

Posts

Wood for bench?

#1

Wood for bench?

Tony

As I ponder a woodworking bench at long last I'm considering what would would be best/best bang for the buck. My thought right now is to build to the Benchcrafted Roubo plans I have*. I have thought about using a hardwood base such as Ash or Soft Maple paired with a softwood top of some description. Good idea or not? Any thoughts would be greatly appreciated.

* looked at a Nicholson style on and off but I think the wide aprons would interfere with when I need to sit on a stool to work.

** Acacia Hardwood is my local wood supplier and they have a website if your interested what I can get easily.

Re: Wood for bench?

#2

ash probably good

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

We sold hard maple to various industries for use in building carts, bumpers and such where a durable wood would be the material of choice. Then for a time the price of 8/4 maple shot past that of 4/4 walnut. We suggested substituting ash for the maple. To make a long story short the ash worked satisfactorily for applications where maple had been used. From this experience I suspect that ash would be a good choice. It is stable, durable and cheap. And I think it looks better than boring maple.

Re: Wood for bench?

#3

Re: Wood for bench?

david weaver

Ash all the way around. It should be cheap. If you have a hardwood supplier asking for an appreciable amount of money for 8/4 ash, find another supplier.

Last year, I got 8/4 ash delivered, planed two sides (didn't ask for that, it's just the way it came) for something like $2.50 a board foot.

If it's flatsawn, the edges should be fairly pore free (which is what will show up on the top of the bench)

Re: Wood for bench?

#4

Re: Wood for bench?

Tony

It's not much more than that locally for Ash.

Re: Wood for bench?

#5

cheap is good

Patrick Gibbons

Follansbee has a bench made from eastern white pine. I believe any wood would work for most of us. He's a pro and soft pine has worked fine for him. I used 4/4 brown hard maple for my top, 14 years ago. Planed and sanded it cost me about $1.75/bdft. Doing it now, I'd choose thick, clear, cheap, easy-to-work and light-colored.

Re: Wood for bench?

#6

Re: Wood for bench?

Dick Coers

I'm of the feeling that cost of a quality bench should not be the biggest concern. If this is an all out build, it will be with you for the rest of your life. A couple hundred bucks right now, won't make much difference in 30 years. Just guessing at the age thing. Made mine out of red oak and walnut, built about 30 years ago.


Re: Wood for bench?

#7

Re: Wood for bench?

david weaver

That's what I'd go with if it's significantly less than maple or 8/4 beech (supposing you could even find 8/4 beech - it's available in some places).

Re: Wood for bench?

#8

Re: Wood for bench?

TomD

Softwoods have the advantage of being a little sticky so for a bench you want to use without a lot of vising around, it can be a good choice.

I prefer hardwood for both base and top, but when I got around to making my last bench I had the hardwood I needed, but for the base. When I priced maple it was stratospheric, so I used Poplar for the base, and I don't really see the difference in use. I oiled it with a natural oil from a barrel that had rusted. Made a really nice finish.

If it was me I would spend more on the wood and less on the vises.