New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Face Vise Recommendation

Posts

Face Vise Recommendation

#1

Face Vise Recommendation

Brad Chenoweth

I posted this over on the main board, but at Hank Knight's suggestion, I'll post it here as well (I have been following the bench thread below. Thanks, Hank).

I'm finally building an honest-to goodness workbench in my garage shop. No more plywood-on sawhorses contraptions! It's going to be a general-purpose bench (a dedicated hand tool bench is down the road). I want to install a face vise on the left front corner. I'm looking at the Jorgensen from Lee Valley and the Milwaukee from Joel (I like the ideas of buying American). I've looked at the Wilton as well, but I think the swiveling jaw would be a pain most of the time. Besides, I know Sir William came up with a shop-built solution to do the same thing with a regular vise. I'm also considering the face vise hardware kit from Lee Valley.

Anyone have a favorite brand to recommend? Likes and dislikes?

P.S.- I find myself more and more intrigued by hand tools. I was fortunate enough to acquire, from my aunt, a tool chest full of tools belonging to my great-grandfather a couple of years ago,and I really want to put them back to work. More on the chest and tools later.

Brad, enjoying the warmer weather (for now) in northeast Ohio

Re: Face Vise Recommendation

#2

Re: Face Vise Recommendation

Jim Matthews

I built my bench with a permanently mounted Moxon vise as described by David Barron on YouTube.

Re: Face Vise Recommendation

#3

Re: Face Vise Recommendation

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Jim

Just for reference, David Barron does not use a Moxon; he has a twin-screw vise. He sits down to drop his height for the twin-screw.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5I45mEWAJv4

By contrast, a Moxon is intended to raise the height of the vise so a person can stand more upright.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Face Vise Recommendation

#4

Re: Face Vise Recommendation

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Brad

I would not get too obsessional about this one at this stage.

There are many different types of woodworking, and there are different types of vises. Trying to accommodate for all possibilities is going to water down what you will have. It took me 20 years to decide what my priorities would be in a bench and vises.

My advice is to start with something that is basic and reliable, and be prepared to change when you are ready to do so. For example, try and get hold of an old Record #52 1/2, alternatively one of the modern reproductions.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Face Vise Recommendation

#5

Re: Face Vise Recommendation

Anji12305

https://youtu.be/D7ZNU7atoxc

Moxon vice in a workbench

My point to the OP is simple, the hardware for the Benchcrafted Moxon is $150 USD.

It's relatively simple to install and to the purpose for which most of use a face vise,

cutting boards on edge. Given that the antique Record vices sell in excess of $250 and have

real capacity limits, it's a viable alternative.

If the OP doesn't like the arrangement (for height, capacity, etc.) it is simple to remove and retrofit another

vice in its place. My experience with face vises, leg vises and Nicholson clamping methods show this to be really effective and forgiving.

Like Barron, i retrofitted the screws to make set up easier.

Unlike Barron I don't use springs, but rather brass bushings to make adjustments tighter.

That had the added benefit of keeping the front chop off the heavy acme screws.

Re: Face Vise Recommendation

#6

Re: Face Vise Recommendation *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Although David Barron may refer to that as a Moxon vise, it is in fact a twin screw vise (using the screws and wheels offered by BenchCrafted for we have come to refer to a Moxon vise). I would find it very awkward to saw dovetails at his vise - the mileage of others will vary.

Christopher Schwarz quotes a translation of Roubo ...

"We use these presses on the workbench with the rip tip, either for work or work to stick. In one or other of these different cases, we stop the press on the bench with two (holdfasts so) that it (will not move)."

(I posted this picture earlier of my Moxon vise)


Regards from Perth

Derek


André Roubo's Screw Press (and my Poor French)

Re: Face Vise Recommendation

#7

Thanks, Derek & All

Brad Chenoweth

Hi Derek and All,

Thanks for the input, everyone. Derek, I promise not to obsess:>). I'll probably pick up a vintage used vise for now. I can always upgrade later. The old Columbians are fairly common around here, probably because they were built in Cleveland.

By the way, this isn't really a bench in the truest sense, just a top on some shop-built cabinets. It will serve my purposes well for now, I think. Maybe something better as my needs/wants change.

Brad

Re: Face Vise Recommendation

#8

Wooden versus Metal Screws

Tony

Kind of a follow one, kind of a hijack. I'm looking at bench options (might have found some help to build one) and have been thinking about the vise hardware (and it's cost). I've been planning to use Benchcrafted hardware but it's pricy. I think you get what you pay for though. However, somewhere in my mind I remember reading about the advantages of wooden hardware. I don't remember the details though. The Lake Eerie screws etc are slightly cheaper.

So can somebody run down the advantages between the two?

Re: Face Vise Recommendation

#9

Re: Wooden versus Metal Screws

Dick Coers

I guess wood may have some advantage, but I sure didn't want to deal with seasonal fit issues. All steel for me, face and tail vise.

Re: Face Vise Recommendation

#10

Re: Wooden versus Metal Screws

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Tony

Wood screws tend to be between 2 1/2" - 3" in diameter and have a 2-3 tpi thread. The Lake Erie that Lee Valley sell is 2 1/2" diameter and 2 tpi. The BC metal screw is 1" in diameter and is 4 tpi.

What you can expect from this is that the LE would require about half the rotations of a BC screw to close or open up. All things equal (which they are not), the wood vise should be faster.

The other side of the coin is that the BC metal screw is a work of precision. The fit and finish are absolutely top notch. From reputation, the LE is also top notch work, but being wood the tolerances are not in the same class.

What you would expect from this is that the BC screw and fittings would have less friction as it spins, while the LE vise will have more.

The upshot is that they are probably equally fast, but do it slightly differently (the BC can spin under its own momentum, while the LE needs to be turned).

Which you prefer comes down to what you look for in a vise. I have a wooden screw (not LE) in my leg vise. The leg vise uses a chain for balance (details on my website), and this does promote a bit of spinning, but nothing like the BC. I am very happy with the way mine works. It does its job, and efficiently. I did spend on a BC wagon tail vise, and it is a work of art. After 3 years you will still get rave notices from me. (I have built a wooden wagon vise for my travel bench - details also on my website. It works well, but not in the class of the BC).

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Face Vise Recommendation

#11

Re: Wooden versus Metal Screws

david weaver

I can't speak to the benchcrafted, but I have the lake erie screw in the front of my bench. I contemplated building my own screw, and then noticed that the lake erie screw wasn't 90 degree threaded like a lot of old screws, it's instead something like 60 degrees with flats on the top (which probably protects the tops of the threads from chipping off).

I'm super pleased with it, and am glad that I didn't build my own screw even though I'm price conscious on bench stuff. It would've cost me half as much to to guy good KD turning billets, cut hardware out of brass and put together tooling to cut the threads in the first place.

It's a lot stronger feeling than I thought it would be, too, and the coarse thread is convenient.

One last thing that went into consideration for me, my shop is only partially/parasitically heated. When it's really cold, it may drop to 40 degrees (really cold being zero or subzero outside), and I have no interest in grabbing a metal vise wheel at that temperature.