New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Workbenches to buy

Posts

Workbenches to buy

#1

Workbenches to buy

Tony

There is an organization that might help me buy a workbench since my injuries make that one of the most difficult things for me to make myself. Of the workbenches that are available commercially and worth having I can only think of two - Plate 11 and Lie Nielsen.

Are there others? Input on these two?

Re: Workbenches to buy

#2

Re: Workbenches to buy

don stephan

What tools you want to be able to use efficiently, and what types of joinery you wish to make, may impact a desirable bench design for your needs.

Re: Workbenches to buy

#3

Re: Workbenches to buy

Tony

I've managed to kludge together enough work holding to plane faces and I built a moxon vise so I can get end grain/cut dovetails. Edge grain and marking tails to pins are my biggest obstacles so far.

Re: Workbenches to buy

#4

Re: Workbenches to buy

Howard Pollack

There are many. Lee Valley sells one, I think that Grizzly might also. Try a google search of "woodworking workbenches" you will find many.

-Howard

Re: Workbenches to buy

#5

Re: Workbenches to buy

david weaver

While the plate 11 benches are nice, it looks like the price before hardware for an assembled bench is $4450. Hardware would be quite a bit more unless you went stripped down and did something like a front wooden screw and a quick release on the end (the latter would be like putting used pressed steel wheels on a new corvette). By the time you add freight, you could be up to $6000 on something you'll never get a fraction of that back out of if it becomes impossible for you to woodwork.

The lie nielsen benches look like a decent option, and from time to time the large sjobergs benches are on sale and are probably in the price range of the lie nielsen bench.

You do have another option if you know your neighbors, and that is to build a bench and hire hourly some high school-aged male help.

I built a bench that's not too unlike the plate 11 bench last year, but I shortcutted some of the cosmetic details (no dovetails on the end and the tenons are not through tenons) and used a lake erie screw and a good quality QR vise from LV on the end. It cost me about $900 total (made of ash) and took about 30 hours to make. In my mind, a bench is timberframing work, and I didn't bother to face joint the boards I laminated because the wood was decent enough to just rip it, plane it in a lunchbox planer to thickness and then glue it together.

The only parts of the build that were difficult (physically) were moving the assembled top to the floor to be mortised, and then flipping the bench back up on its legs after putting the legs in, and shortcutting a lot of the things (like just lagging end caps on, etc) cut the time down considerably.

Point being, if you do something similar (I'm sure you can find 150 board feet of ash for $500 or so delivered from somewhere), and you hire a little muscle, I doubt it would cost close to twice what mine did after you pay off the muscle, and my bench is frankly a better bench (for me) to use day to day than the LN $2500 bench because it's almost twice as heavy and tailored to what I do - despite not being as nicely finished as any commercial benches. I had some concern about using ash due to large pores, but on the edges of a flatsawn board, there really isn't much in terms of pores.

http://s30.postimg.org/48i5jsju9/bench.jpg

Re: Workbenches to buy

#6

Re: Workbenches to buy

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Do your injuries affect your back and your ability to bend over? If so, should you consider a bench that can adjust in height?

I've never used/seen any of the benches I'm linking here (I'm still using a temporary workbench made from a solid core door, made when my sons were teenagers because I knew they'd beat it up* - and they're now 43 and 39).

If you haven't already, you might also ask around to see if the organization you're working with or some local community organization works with people with disabilities on accommodations. You might get some helpful design information, or at least a conversation that helps you define what you need from a bench to fit your physical needs, now and possibly in future.

Adjustable-height bench vendors I found on a quick search (the first design seems to take into account that benches have weight):

http://www.jack-bench.com/

http://www.adjustabench.com/about.asp

Googling "adjustable height workbench woodworking" got a whole array of links, including several worker-made benches.

If this post is irrelevant to your needs, of course disregard it.

-------------

*I did, finally, manage to clean off the lake of glue the older son left on the bench after gluing up some project. At 16, he used the same principle in spreading glue that he used in taking showers: more is better. And, at some point in the future, I hope to build a less temporary bench. Maybe, if one of the boys would just find the right woman and have kids, I could celebrate the grandkid by building a new bench...

Re: Workbenches to buy

#7

Re: Workbenches to buy

E Snow

The lie nielsen bench is pretty nice, nothing exotic. The program I was in ended getting several my last year in grad school. Seemed fine. Took a while to settle if I remember correctly, had to be flattened a few times.

Hoffman & Hammer may be another option for a traditional bench. I've never used one but heard okay things about them.

Re: Workbenches to buy

#8

americanworkbench.com.


Re: Workbenches to buy

#9

Re: Workbenches to buy

TomD

Other people telling you that they like a given bench is pretty useless, other than maybe for quality control. Two reasons. One is the rampant faddism of the whole bench thing. The other is the obvious individuality of needs, from available space, to the way one works. Benches basically come down to the base, the top, and the vises (if any). Evaluating the function of these elements is not all that difficult. In some cases it probably doesn't mater that much what you get. There are a variety of bases. Probably the least efficient, the Roubo, has been massively popular for quite a while indicating that the actual choice is not all that important. With bases, they all work so long as they are rigid. I have several benches in the shop and I never have got around to fastening the tops to the bases, further evidence that the whole this is more forgiving than one might think.

I was coming off a plane crash back 20 years ago and had to adapt a bench project to get it done. I substituted a base using LV legs, which I did not find stiff enough, but certainly they were OK, that reduced the work I had to do, and when I felt better I built a regular sled base. I made the top really big, but basically it was laminated out of a few pieces. Clamped up on top of some saw horses and then slid onto the bench so I never really had to do much lifting. I also made it in two pieces with a crack down the middle. Occasionally something falls down the crack, but overall the utility for tool holding and workpiece holding is still . I am not sure the heavy lifting quotient (or whatever we are controlling for here) is really that much worse than assembling a bench that arrives in pieces.

The Adjusta bench seems like a good idea. Never seen one to be sure it is dead nuts solid. I think one also has to physically lift the bench top to raise it, an end at a time. Depending on one's limitations, that might not suit. I would check out a motorcycle lift, to see if it was solid and level, they can be had cheaply during sales at places like HF.

I have a take down bench that I made up using a temporary plywood hollow beam as a top. I was going to switch out the plywood top when I got the right piece of wood. I eventually found my piece of wood, but the plywood top is so good that I did not replace it. Plywood for bench components is a really great option and will make construction a relatively easy thing.

My favorite five features on a bench are min 8 foot overall length; wedged trestle bases, look nice, and rock solid, easy to demount; hardware bonding, neater, cheaper, better looking; Square dog holes; mechanical vises. If I could have something I don't have it would be adjustable height, though I have multiple bench heights.